Not disagreeing with Montmartre as a location,but I will contrast two locations I stayed at on previous trips.

one was in 16th, near Metro Mirabeau. Easy walk to M from hotel, nice cafe near M for breakfast. Some good restos in area, no tourists at all. For sightseeing, only choice was 2 block walk to Seine to see eiffel in distance. To get to Marais, for example, was about 20 min ride, longer back. So everyday I would metro central, do a lot of walking. Before dinner, I would go back to 16th, drop off camera, any purchases and just rest. Then metro back in to eat in 4-7th.

second home base was across from RER St Michel. Out of my window I could see sunrising over Notre Dame. From that location I was 'at' a lot of sights, plenty of restaurants, shops, Seine,etc

I agree wholeheartedly that public transit is great, and Montmartre is not a bad location. But there are some small advantages, on a first trip, to staying a bit more central.

Bonne Annee a tous!

Et à vous de même, Michel! Heureusement, tout le monde n'aime pas les mêmes chose.

"les mêmes choses."

Resolution for me: Learn to proofread!

Merci Beaucoup everyone for your thoughtful replies. After a lot of research, I have booked a room in Beauborg (near the Pompidou). I think it will be better, as many of you point out, being my first trip to Paris. I can walk to the River Seine, Notre Dame and Louvre from there. Will definiately make a trip to Montmarte also. Am getting excited!!

toypary,
Bien fait!
Debbie..I think you will happy with your choice.

Too bad! People are often warned away from where they should have stayed in the first place.

Kerouc