Base in highlands Scotland?
#21
Join Date: Oct 2013
Posts: 1,086
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Janisj, which part of 'example' do you not understand?
The comments I made re Pitlochry applied to this sentence, "My point is, there are things to see and do everywhere but you have to make some decisions as to which areas appeal to you most, no one can decide that for you."
If you want to disagree with something, disagree with the point being made, not the example.
Since you have chosen to make an issue of Pitlochry, "But there are better, nicer, prettier and more interesting options."
Let me be quite clear. What you think of Pitlochry is up to you but do not attempt to suggest that what I think of it is in any way incorrect. It's a subjective opinion. It is incorrect to say, 'there are better, nicer, prettier....'.
You can say, 'I think' or 'in my opinion' but to state, 'there are' simply shows a lack of either an understanding of what is an opinon vs. what is a fact or a lack of English language skills. Your choice.
The comments I made re Pitlochry applied to this sentence, "My point is, there are things to see and do everywhere but you have to make some decisions as to which areas appeal to you most, no one can decide that for you."
If you want to disagree with something, disagree with the point being made, not the example.
Since you have chosen to make an issue of Pitlochry, "But there are better, nicer, prettier and more interesting options."
Let me be quite clear. What you think of Pitlochry is up to you but do not attempt to suggest that what I think of it is in any way incorrect. It's a subjective opinion. It is incorrect to say, 'there are better, nicer, prettier....'.
You can say, 'I think' or 'in my opinion' but to state, 'there are' simply shows a lack of either an understanding of what is an opinon vs. what is a fact or a lack of English language skills. Your choice.
#22
Actually, in this case there ARE better, nicer, prettier places than Pitlochry. I use IMO a lot -- but when it is a given I don't . . .
Absolutely <u>nothing</u> <i>wrong</i> with Pitlochry. I've stayed there or nearby probably 10 or more times over the years. But <B>IMO</B> it doesn't fit in the OP's plans/short trip.
Absolutely <u>nothing</u> <i>wrong</i> with Pitlochry. I've stayed there or nearby probably 10 or more times over the years. But <B>IMO</B> it doesn't fit in the OP's plans/short trip.
#27
Original Poster
Join Date: Oct 2013
Posts: 35
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks for all the opinions and discussion. We have decided (for now) on four nights in Fort Augustus and 4 nights around Callander. My question now is whether to go from Windemere to Callander and then to Fort Augustus and then to Edinburgh or to Fort Augustus first then Callander and finally Edinburgh? I've got a map and it looks like coming from Windemere we would pass to the South West of Callander but to come back there from Fort Augustus would involve some backtracking (which is fine). However, people who know the routes well might be able to advise what makes sense. What looks straight forward on a large map may not be the reality. Look forward to your opinions even if they vary!
#28
I'd personally do Callander first. From Windermere to Callander takes about 3.5-4 hours car time. That would give you time to take a short detour to Hadrian's Wall or even a boat ride on Loch Lomond e route.
The drive to Ft Augustus would require at least 6.5 hours 'car time' and very likely more.
The drive to Ft Augustus would require at least 6.5 hours 'car time' and very likely more.
#30
Original Poster
Join Date: Oct 2013
Posts: 35
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks Janis, that was the order that made sense to me and I don't want such a long drive in one day when there will be nice things to see along the way. What route would you advise then from Fort Augustus to Edinburgh?
#31
Original Poster
Join Date: Oct 2013
Posts: 35
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Forgot to say that I've been looking at some accommodation in the Callander area and right in Callander. One is a self catering cottage near Balfron, http://www.ballatsmithycottage.com/
The other is a well reviewed B&B in Callander (Annfield). Any opinions?
The other is a well reviewed B&B in Callander (Annfield). Any opinions?
#32
The cottage looks nice - I don't remember if you said when you are traveling. Short breaks may not be offered if it is in summer/high season.
I haven't stayed at annfield house but do know it. It is just a block from the Rob Roy and Trossachs visitors center (the main tourist information office for the area). It would be a much more convenient location for a short visit.
Here is a modest but very nice B&B on the Lake of Menteith
http://www.inchiefarm.co.uk/
I haven't stayed at annfield house but do know it. It is just a block from the Rob Roy and Trossachs visitors center (the main tourist information office for the area). It would be a much more convenient location for a short visit.
Here is a modest but very nice B&B on the Lake of Menteith
http://www.inchiefarm.co.uk/
#34
Original Poster
Join Date: Oct 2013
Posts: 35
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
We will be in Callander area June 16th. The cottage owner is prepared to do a four night stay. Just not sure how isolated it might be and whether Callander would be better. We like self catering as it gives a bit more freedom for what you eat instead of always eating out. We all love to cook. I've emailed Annfield house for a price per room. Will see what the costs are for both options. Lake Menteith looks good too. In Fort Augustus we have been looking at apartments in the Highland Club complex which was an Abbey http://www.holidaylettings.co.uk/ren...ch-ness/127225 By getting in early there is a lot to choose from and the Highland Club self catering apartments are available for four nights.
#36
The problem with the cottage is you will almost have to self cater your evening meals - unless you don't drink at all. (Same w/ Inchie farm except there is a hotel with a casual pub and posher restaurant about a mile away).
I actually prefer renting cottages/flats - but usually try to pick ones that are in or walking distance from a town or village with dining options.
I actually prefer renting cottages/flats - but usually try to pick ones that are in or walking distance from a town or village with dining options.
#37
Original Poster
Join Date: Oct 2013
Posts: 35
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The not drinking at all would not suit us but catering for evening meals might be okay as we will hopefully be out and about during the day and may eat out for lunch and just chill out at home in the evenings. I can't see the cottage location in relation to a village. I will email th owner.
#40
I know exactly where that cottage is (if their map is accurate). Just off the junction of the A81 and A811 - it isn't in a village.
(I've spent many weeks in the general Callander, Aberfoyle, Lake of Menteith area and have been over those roads countless times)
(I've spent many weeks in the general Callander, Aberfoyle, Lake of Menteith area and have been over those roads countless times)