Well, after YEARS of planning each vacation myself, DH has weighed in and is willing to plan most of the vacation. The final plan, well, for now, is to go to St. Martin...again..Not my choice at all!!! Staying on Orient Bay and heading to St. Barts. We are taking the ferry to Anguilla, for the day, to check it out before saying yes to it. DH wants to go back to both islands to EAT! We are very healthy people, but I think he is needing the food. Fine with me due to lack of time to properly research a new place and I did want to see St. Barts for a longer stretch of time.

Thanks for all of the info! I will weigh in on the day trip to Anguilla.....