Fodor's Expert Review Alley's General Store

Step back in time with a visit to Alley's General Store, a local landmark since 1858, and the island's oldest retail business. Stock includes everything from groceries to gourmet cheeses, and toys for all ages, from stuffed animals for the kids to housewares for adults. Alley's is a treasure trove of the playful and practical items that define a country store. The coffee bar sells some of the best brew in town, and there's a post office inside.