Fodor's Expert Review Treadwell Inn

Editor's Note: This location is reported to be under new ownership and therefore this review may contain inaccuracies.

This is one of the best locations in town, with gardens stretching to the water's edge and the harbor just two short blocks away. Built by a ship's chandler in about 1820, the property has been faithfully restored and furnished to reflect the era. All the rooms are lovely, and five have balconies overlooking the bay. Rooms 5 and 6 have kitchenettes and Jacuzzi tubs. A recent addition to the inn is St. Croix Olive—a tasting room and shop for an international array of olive oils and more than two dozen balsamic vinegars.