Bermudians swear by this spot, where a maritime-theme dining room is filled with brass nautical gear, lobster traps, and sun-bleached rope. The fresh local lobster, available September through March, is most requested next to rockfish, snapper, wahoo, and mahi mahi with fried bananas and almonds, all local favorites. Ask for your seafood to be cooked to your liking and be sure to taste the Bermudian classic dish: fish chowder. The "Cup Match Special" is everything locals love about fried seafood dinners: crispy fish strips on a bun with a decent helping of coleslaw and fries. If you're looking for a good deal, there's also a limited-availability three-course set lunch for $21.75.
6 Bermudiana Rd., Hamilton, Hamilton Parish, HM08, Bermuda