Long Island Restaurants

We’ve compiled the best of the best in Long Island - browse our top choices for Restaurants during your stay.

Recommended Fodor’s Video

Sort by: 15 Recommendations {{numTotalPoiResults}} {{ (numTotalPoiResults===1)?'Recommendation':'Recommendations' }} 0 Recommendations
CLEAR ALL CLEAR ALL
Loading...
  • 1. Aji 53

    $$ | Japanese

    In a market crowded with sushi joints, this one is an original, and remains a standout with its unique selection of specialty rolls and unpretentious...Read More

  • 2. Beach Bakery Café

    $ | Bakery

    This is really the place to be in WHB. Sit and sip an iced coffee and watch the world go by from the porch or sidewalk tables or grab a gelato...Read More

  • 3. Hamptons Chutney Company

    $ | Indian

    One of Paul McCartney's favorites, this place is not much bigger than a shack, and is tucked away in the back of Amagansett Square off Main...Read More

  • 4. Pancho's Cantina

    $$$ | Mexican

    This place has been selling tacos on Long Island for more than two decades, so when Hurricane Sandy destroyed the restaurant in October 2012...Read More

  • 5. Pridwin Bar & Restaurant

    $$$ | Seafood

    Fish doesn't come any fresher than at this waterfront resturant, where it was most likely caught that very morning off the Pridwin's boat by...Read More

  • 6. Astro's Pizza and Felice's Ristorante

    $$ | Pizza

    Its facade is unassuming and interior unpretentious, but you can't go wrong with any of the pizzas or house specialties at this family-owned...Read More

  • 7. Crickets

    $ | American

    This family-favorite Main Street mainstay is best known for simple but good pub fare served up in a warm, homey atmosphere. Menu items include...Read More

  • 8. Downtown Burger at Five Points Café

    $ | American

    The eponymous burger—smothered with a variety of cheeses, sauteed onion, and secret sauce—has quickly made this relative newcomer to Sayville...Read More

  • 9. Fellingham's Restaurant Sports Bar

    $ | American

    With dark-wood furniture, wood beam ceilings, and Yankees memorabilia on almost every wall, this one of the few true old-school neighborhood...Read More

  • 10. Il Capuccino

    $$ | Italian

    Chianti bottles hang from the ceiling over tables draped in red-and-white-check cloths in the three rooms of this cozy and slightly kitschy...Read More

  • 11. Lobster Roll

    $$ | Seafood

    Set along the no-man's-land between Amagansett and Montauk, this local institution (affectionately known as "Lunch") is the proverbial shanty...Read More

  • 12. Margarita Grille

    $ | Mexican

    In the center of town, with outdoor seating out front, this casual restaurant attracts visitors and locals of all ages, lured by the aroma of...Read More

  • 13. Modern Snack Bar

    $$ | American

    Anyone who has driven Main Road in Aqueboque at night, driving back from the wineries or heading home from Greenport, has most definitely noticed...Read More

  • 14. New Moon Café

    $$ | American

    Standing the test of time, this rustic, homey family-run restaurant has been serving local folks and visitors for almost four decades. Bright...Read More

  • 15. Michael’s Ristorante & Pizzeria

    $$ | Ocean Beach | Italian

    Bacon cheeseburger pizza—need we say more? Creative pizza, made with handmade mozzarella and hand-rolled dough (also available in gluten free...Read More

No Restaurants Results

Please try a broader search, or expore these popular suggestions: