Fodor's Expert Review Katie's Ice Cream
$
Hyannis
American
Making small batch ice cream and pastries in-house daily, Katie's has a huge following for its delicious flavors, like the popular Cape Cod Mud, a concoction of coffee ice cream, chocolate, house-made fudge, roasted almonds, and chopped chocolate sandwich cookies. Try to figure out the secret recipe of the Cape Cod Sand ice cream, a hit since 2002, when it was developed by Katie’s younger brother Gene, but don't expect anyone to give it away. Cookies and other sweet treats are also available.
Quick Facts
Known For:
- Creative flavors, like lavender honeycomb and ginger lemon cookie
- Friendly staff
- Offers both soft serve and hard-packed ice cream
Restaurant Details:
Rate Includes: Closed early Oct.-mid-Apr.
