Fodor's Expert Review Amelia Schoolhouse Inn

Set in what was originally the island's first school (circa 1886), this adults-only boutique hotel is within walking distance of the shops and restaurants along Centre Street. There's a schoolhouse theme throughout, including in The Principal's Office, an upscale lobby bar. Other amenities include a quaint pool, a quiet courtyard, a putting green, and coffee that's available 24/7 in the common area.