55 Best Hotels in Northeast Coast, Florida

Background Illustration for Hotels

For the busy seasons—during summer in and around Jacksonville and during spring, summer, winter, and holiday weekends all over Florida—reserve well ahead for top properties. Jacksonville's beach hotels fill up quickly for PGA's The Players Championship in mid-May. Daytona Beach presents similar problems during the Daytona 500 (late February), Bike Week (late February–early March), spring break (March), and the Coke Zero 400 (early July).

St. Augustine stays busy all year. In late summer and fall rates are low and availability is high, but it’s also hurricane season. Although northeast Florida hasn't been hit directly since 1964, it's possible for threatening storms to disrupt plans.

Hilton Daytona Beach Oceanfront Resort

$$$ | 100 N. Atlantic Ave., Daytona Beach, FL, 32118, USA

Perched on one of the few traffic-free strips of beach in Daytona, this high-rise is as popular with families as it is with couples. Every room has a great ocean view, and the Florida tropical decor is warm and inviting. If the beach isn't your thing, check out the spacious sundecks and two pools, or stroll down to the pier or boardwalk, both within walking distance. The hotel is also connected to the Ocean Walk Shoppes via covered walkways.

Pros

  • Direct beach access
  • Proximity to shops and restaurants
  • Pool scene

Cons

  • Inconvenient self-parking
  • Resort fee
  • Not all rooms have balconies
100 N. Atlantic Ave., Daytona Beach, FL, 32118, USA
386-254–8200
Hotel Details
744 rooms
No Meals

Quick Facts

Something incorrect in this review?

Hilton Garden Inn Cocoa Beach Oceanfront

$ | 2080 N. Atlantic Ave., Cocoa Beach, FL, 32931, USA

Proximity to the beach and comforts like in-room microwaves and refrigerators make this six-story hotel a favorite of vacationing families, particularly Orlandoans on weekend getaways. Most rooms have ocean views with private balconies. Free Wi-Fi is available throughout the property.

Pros

  • Private beach access
  • Free Wi-Fi
  • Balconies with ocean views

Cons

  • $12 per day self-parking
  • Thin walls
  • Slow elevators
2080 N. Atlantic Ave., Cocoa Beach, FL, 32931, USA
321-783–9222
Hotel Details
160 rooms
No Meals

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Hilton St. Augustine Historic Bayfront

$$ | 32 Ave. Menendez, St. Augustine, FL, 32084, USA

In the heart of historic St. Augustine, this Spanish colonial–inspired hotel overlooking Matanzas Bay has 19 separate buildings in a village setting, and most rooms have water or city-attraction views. Given its location in the thick of the Oldest City, the hotel caters to the tourist throngs with amenities such as in-room refrigerators and a coin-op laundry.

Pros

  • Good location for sightseeing
  • Comfortable beds
  • Great for families

Cons

  • Expensive valet parking only ($32)
  • Late-night noise at street level
  • Not all rooms have bay views
32 Ave. Menendez, St. Augustine, FL, 32084, USA
904-829–2277
Hotel Details
72 rooms
No Meals

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?

Recommended Fodor's Video

Hilton University of Florida Conference Center Gainesville

$ | 1714 S.W. 34th St., Gainesville, FL, 32607, USA

With 12,600 square feet of meeting space, the University of Florida's flagship hotel caters most obviously to business travelers, but its location on the southwest corner of campus also makes it a good choice for UF visitors. Guest rooms, which look like they came straight off the Rooms to Go showroom floor, have two phones with voice mail, large work desks, coffeemakers, and 50-inch flat-screen TVs. The hotel offers room service, and its on-site restaurants include Shula's American Steakhouse.

Pros

  • Proximity to college
  • Spacious rooms
  • Free use of business center

Cons

  • Spotty service
  • Rates skyrocket on football weekends
  • Charge for Wi-Fi
1714 S.W. 34th St., Gainesville, FL, 32607, USA
352-371–3600
Hotel Details
248 rooms
No Meals

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Hotel ELEO at the University of Florida

$ | 1514 SW 14th St., Gainesville, FL, 32608, USA
The Hotel ELEO, which opened in 2020 directly across the adjacent Lake Rush from the university's medical center, keeps health and wellness in mind throughout, with a fitness studio that has Peleton bikes and TRX equipment, a yoga platform overlooking the lake, and rooms that are bright thanks to floor-to-ceiling windows. The on-site Covey Kitchen + Cocktails features creative drinks, local brews, and modern-American cuisine from chef Charlie Keller. For a mouthwatering meal, try The Burger, complete with a special sauce. As the property is also just a mile from the Ben Hill Griffin Stadium, it's also a convenient choice for families and prospective students visiting the university.

Pros

  • Walking distance to hospital and Ben Hill Griffin Stadium
  • On-site Covey Kitchen + Cocktails
  • Modern amenities in room

Cons

  • Only valet parking
  • Long hallways
  • Not all rooms are lakefront
1514 SW 14th St., Gainesville, FL, 32608, USA
352-792–0881
Hotel Details
173 rooms
No Meals

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Hotel Indigo Jacksonville-Deerwood Park

$ | 9840 Tapestry Park Cir., Jacksonville, FL, 32246, USA

Although it's part of a chain, this bright, bold boutique hotel makes you feel like you're staying in a hip apartment rather than a by-the-night lodging. Suites have a spacious soaking tub, as well as a kitchen alcove with a small refrigerator and microwave, a dining area, and a living room with a second large TV. All rooms have a desk, flat-screen TV, high-end coffeemaker, tiled walk-in shower, and large windows, as well as free Wi-Fi and access to a tech concierge on call. A stay here puts you 20 to 30 minutes from Downtown, amid office parks where many businesses have headquarters. Tapestry Park's collection of stores and restaurants is only steps away. The hotel has a bar and eatery with outdoor seating that overlooks the nicely landscaped lake. Room service is available.

Pros

  • Pet-friendly
  • Walking distance to restaurants
  • Silent Film Sundays with $5 movies

Cons

  • Wooden floors can be noisy
  • Convenient to business parks but not Downtown
  • Lots of rush-hour traffic
9840 Tapestry Park Cir., Jacksonville, FL, 32246, USA
904-996–7199
Hotel Details
96 rooms
No Meals

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Hyatt Regency Jacksonville Riverfront

$ | 225 E. Coastline Dr., Jacksonville, FL, 32202, USA

It doesn't get much more convenient than this 19-story, waterfront hotel within walking distance of TIAA Bank Field, Vystar Veterans Memorial Arena, Daily's Place, Florida Theatre, Jacksonville Center for the Performing Arts, MOCA, and all things Downtown. The property, on the north bank of the St. Johns River, offers a rooftop pool; grab-and-go food and coffee 24/7 at Market; the Tavern for cocktails; the SHOR Seafood Grill for breakfast, lunch, and dinner; and Morton's The Steakhouse for upscale dining. Rooms have cool turquoise color schemes, triple-sheeted beds, pillow-top mattresses, and ergonomic work chairs. Since the hotel encompasses 110,000 square feet of meeting space, chances are pretty good you'll share an elevator with someone wearing a name tag.

Pros

  • Rooftop pool and hot tub
  • Free Wi-Fi
  • 24-hour gym and business center

Cons

  • Not all rooms are riverfront
  • Packed with meetings
  • Huge, with a chain-hotel feel
225 E. Coastline Dr., Jacksonville, FL, 32202, USA
904-588–1234
Hotel Details
963 rooms
No Meals

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

The Inn at Cocoa Beach

$ | 4300 Ocean Beach Blvd., Cocoa Beach, FL, 32931, USA

This charming oceanfront inn has spacious, individually decorated rooms, some with four-poster beds, upholstered chairs, and balconies or patios; most have ocean views. Deluxe rooms are much larger, with a king-size bed, sofa, and sitting area; most also have a dining table. Jacuzzi rooms are different sizes. Included in the rate are evening wine and cheese and a continental breakfast that includes a quiche du jour.

Pros

  • Quiet
  • Romantic
  • Yummy breakfast

Cons

  • No on-site restaurant
  • Tiny bathrooms
  • Thin walls
4300 Ocean Beach Blvd., Cocoa Beach, FL, 32931, USA
321-799–3460
Hotel Details
50 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

La Fiesta Ocean Inn & Suites

$ | 810 A1A Beach Blvd., St. Augustine Beach, FL, 32080, USA

Chains have since taken over St. Augustine Beach, but this longtime favorite—the only remaining "Mom and Pop" on the beach—is still doing business (lots of it) and remains as beloved as ever. The location, just steps from the beach, helps, of course. But so do the inviting, consistently updated rooms, in-room continental breakfast delivery (you choose the time), private walkway to the beach, warm service, and reasonable rates. There are a wide variety of room types and locations (some with balconies and/or fireplaces), so it's best to call and make sure you get the room you want. For a special treat, book a room in the property's adults-only bed-and-breakfast, a short walk from the main building.

Pros

  • On the beach
  • Breakfast delivered to rooms
  • Refrigerators and microwaves in rooms

Cons

  • Tiny lobby
  • Resort fee
  • Strict cancellation policy
810 A1A Beach Blvd., St. Augustine Beach, FL, 32080, USA
904-454–3182
Hotel Details
46 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

The Laurel Oak Inn Bed & Breakfast

$ | 221 S.E. 7th St., Gainesville, FL, 32601, USA

Guests at this 1885 Queen Anne dwelling say they're so comfortable and at ease that they feel as if they're in a home, not an inn. The inn's Southern hospitality begins with breakfast by the fireplace and continues with complimentary beverages, homemade cookies or fresh bread throughout the day, and a social hour in the evenings. The "bedchambers" have thoughtful touches, such as plush robes, house bath salts, and organic coffee. Rooms feature a fireplace or gas stove and flat-panel TVs; most have thermo-massage tubs. Lush gardens and stately oak trees give the property a secluded feel, though downtown Gainesville is just a short walk away.

Pros

  • Lots of thoughtful touches
  • Location that's secluded but close to downtown
  • Hospitable staff

Cons

  • Processing fee for cancellations
  • No pool
  • Two-night minimum on weekends
221 S.E. 7th St., Gainesville, FL, 32601, USA
352-373–4535
Hotel Details
5 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Marker 8 Hotel & Marina

$ | 1 Dolphin Dr., St. Augustine, FL, 32080, USA

The nautical theme at this boutique hotel is no gimmick, as the charming establishment also serves as a working marina, and all its rooms have balconies or patios that capitalize on the views of the Matanzas River, Bridge of Lions, and downtown. A hearty, made-to-order breakfast is served each morning in the Captain's Table, and afternoon hors d'oeuvres are offered in the Driftwood Lounge. All in all, this a great place to drop your anchor on a visit to St. Augustine.

Pros

  • Bay views
  • Made-to-order breakfast
  • Comfortable beds

Cons

  • Small pool
  • Tiny elevator
  • 10-minute walk over bridge to downtown
1 Dolphin Dr., St. Augustine, FL, 32080, USA
904-829–9042
Hotel Details
26 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Marriott Jacksonville Hotel

$ | 245 Water St., Jacksonville, FL, 32202, USA

From the upper levels of this imposing 16-floor tower, which is across the street from the Jacksonville Center for the Performing Arts, the smart, neutral colors and modern lines of the furnishings set off the views of the St. Johns River and its iconic bridges. A marble-floored, wood-paneled lobby leads to the reception area, an upscale lounge (JBar), and Juliette's Bistro, where cozy banquettes and tables bask in the airiness of a lofty atrium. Bell service is exemplary; many porters have more than a decade on the job, so they can and will happily help you find just about anything, including a cab.

Pros

  • On-site restaurant
  • Heated, fourth-floor pool with views of the river
  • Pet-friendly

Cons

  • Fee for Wi-Fi and parking
  • Pricey restaurant
  • Can be chaotic when there's a show across the street
245 Water St., Jacksonville, FL, 32202, USA
904-355–6664
Hotel Details
354 rooms
No Meals

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

One Ocean Resort & Spa

$$ | 1 Ocean Blvd., Atlantic Beach, FL, 32233, USA

Atlantic Beach's only high-rise oceanfront hotel captures the serenity of the sea through a color palette of translucent green, sand, and sky blue and reflective materials such as glass and marble. A sophisticated yet relaxed "art gallery" theme is carried through to the original photographs that hang in every room. Some guests balk at the $30-a-day resort fee that's tacked on to the room rate, but considering all it includes (Wi-Fi, mini-refrigerator, two bicycles for two hours daily, beach chairs and umbrellas daily), it's not such bad deal.

Pros

  • Walking distance to restaurants, shops, and the beach
  • All rooms have an ocean view
  • Room service

Cons

  • Tiny bathrooms
  • No self-parking on property
  • Steep resort fee and separate valet-parking fee
1 Ocean Blvd., Atlantic Beach, FL, 32233, USA
904-249–7402
Hotel Details
190 rooms
No Meals

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?

Radisson Resort at the Port

$ | 8701 Astronaut Blvd., Cape Canaveral, FL, 32920, USA

For cruise-ship passengers who can't wait to get under way, this splashy resort, done up in pink and turquoise, already feels like the Caribbean. Guest room decor is simple and restrained, but the pool is lushly landscaped and features a cascading waterfall, tiki bar, and occasional appearances by the "Radisson parrots," about a dozen wild birds who call the resort home. This resort, a little south of Port Canaveral, is not on the ocean, but only a short ride away.

Pros

  • Tropical landscaping in pool area
  • On-site eateries
  • Shuttle to Port Canaveral

Cons

  • Rooms around the pool can be noisy
  • Dated rooms
  • No complimentary breakfast
8701 Astronaut Blvd., Cape Canaveral, FL, 32920, USA
321-784–0000
Hotel Details
356 rooms
No Meals

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Renaissance St. Augustine Downtown Hotel

$$ | 6 W. Castillo Dr., St. Augustine, FL, 32084, USA

Located in the heart of the Historic District, this luxurious property is within walking distance of Castillo de San Marcos, St. George Street, and more. Along with modern amenities and a lively restaurant and lounge—Castillo Craft Bar + Kitchen—there is also an on-site Starbucks coffee shop.

Pros

  • On-site, upscale dining
  • Excellent location
  • Large, modern rooms

Cons

  • Not all rooms have balconies
  • Only valet parking ($35)
  • Small pool
6 W. Castillo Dr., St. Augustine, FL, 32084, USA
904-824-4457
Hotel Details
89 rooms
No Meals

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?

Residence Inn Amelia Island

$$ | 2301 Sadler Rd., Fernandina Beach, FL, 32034, USA

Travelers love this all-suites property for its great location, modern design features, and family-friendly amenities. The beach and restaurants are a short walk away, though many prefer to prepare meals in their spacious suites, which are all equipped with contemporary kitchens, as well as cozy sitting areas, wood-paneled accent walls, and mood lighting in the bedrooms. Adjacent to the pool is an outdoor lounge and fire pit, where guests gather in the evenings

Pros

  • Full kitchen in suites
  • Bike rental on property
  • Pet-friendly (hefty fee, restrictions)

Cons

  • No on-site restaurant or room service
  • Historic district not within walking distance
  • Not directly on the beach
2301 Sadler Rd., Fernandina Beach, FL, 32034, USA
904-277–2440
Hotel Details
133 suites
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?

Residence Inn by Marriott Cape Canaveral Cocoa Beach

$$ | 8959 Astronaut Blvd., Cape Canaveral, FL, 32920, USA

The four-story Residence Inn is one of the closest all-suite hotels to the Kennedy Space Center. Considerably larger than traditional hotel rooms, the one- and two-bedroom suites include a full kitchen (dishwasher and all) and separate living and sleeping areas. The morning buffet and manager's reception are popular with guests. It is also convenient to other area attractions such as Port Canaveral, the Cocoa Beach Pier, the Brevard Zoo, and Cocoa Village, and is only an hour from Walt Disney World.

Pros

  • Helpful staff
  • Only an hour from Walt Disney World
  • Spacious suites

Cons

  • Less-than-picturesque views
  • Street noise in some rooms
  • Fee for parking
8959 Astronaut Blvd., Cape Canaveral, FL, 32920, USA
321-323–1100
Hotel Details
150 suites
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?

Riverdale Inn

$ | 1521 Riverside Ave., Jacksonville, FL, 32204, USA

In the early 1900s, Jacksonville's wealthiest residents built mansions along Riverside Avenue (dubbed the Row), and the three-story Riverdale Inn—well-preserved, with heart-pine floors, crown moldings, and guest rooms decorated to period—is one of only two such homes remaining. Despite being more than 100 years old, the mansion feels pristine, inside and out. Some rooms have fireplaces; all have bathrooms with tub–shower combos or showers only; one room has a whirlpool tub. Complimentary breakfast is made to order each morning, and the inn is within walking distance of numerous restaurants, as well as the Cummer Museum of Art & Gardens and the Five Points district. You can also pop downstairs for a drink at the Gum Bunch Pub.

Pros

  • Close to area restaurants and shops
  • Private baths
  • Charming, walkable neighborhood

Cons

  • Small rooms
  • Limited parking
  • Strict cancellation policy
1521 Riverside Ave., Jacksonville, FL, 32204, USA
904-354–5080
Hotel Details
11 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Riverview Hotel & Spa

$ | 103 Flagler Ave., New Smyrna Beach, FL, 32169, USA

A landmark since 1885, this former bridge tender's home is set back from the Intracoastal Waterway at the edge of the north causeway, which still has an operating drawbridge. Rooms open out to plant-filled verandas and balconies, and views look either through trees to the waterway or onto the private courtyard and pretty pool. Each room is furnished differently with charming antique touches, such as an old washbasin, a quilt, or a rocking chair. An "expanded" continental breakfast is served in your room. The inn has a charming waterfront restaurant, full-service spa, and an excellent gift shop; it's also near art galleries and stores.

Pros

  • On-site spa and dining
  • River views
  • Homey feel

Cons

  • Small rooms in main house
  • Strict cancellation policy
  • Blocks from the beach
103 Flagler Ave., New Smyrna Beach, FL, 32169, USA
386-428–5858
Hotel Details
18 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Sawgrass Marriott Golf Resort & Spa

$$ | 1000 PGA Tour Blvd., Ponte Vedra Beach, FL, 32082, USA

Golf is at the heart of this luxurious resort, but there's no lack of opportunity for other recreation or for sheer indulgent relaxation, if that's what you're after. Besides offering access to the renowned Stadium Course at TPC Sawgrass, which hosts THE PLAYERS Championship each year, the resort has trails for jogging or biking, as well as an acclaimed 18-hole miniature golf course that appeals to the whole family. There are plenty of other activities for the kids, too. Or, you can simply laze about in the highly regarded spa or by one of the many swimming pools. It's not an oceanfront resort, but that's just a technicality: the exclusive oceanfront Cabana Beach Club is a three-minute drive or shuttle ride away. The elegant hotel tower is home to several casual restaurants and lounges, including Alice & Pete's Pub and the upscale Vernon's First Coast Kitchen & Bar featuring farm-to-table cuisine.

Pros

  • Beautiful surroundings
  • Readily available shuttle
  • Efficient staff

Cons

  • Beach requires a shuttle
  • Steep resort fee
  • Some rooms are noisy
1000 PGA Tour Blvd., Ponte Vedra Beach, FL, 32082, USA
904-285–7777
Hotel Details
514 rooms
No Meals

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?

SpringHill Suites Amelia Island

$ | 2700-2 Atlantic Ave., Fernandina Beach, FL, 32034, USA

This hotel, a relative newcomer, is a block from the Atlantic and 2 miles from Fernandina Beach's historic district. It features a resort-style pool deck with fire pits and a full-service bar. Amenities include free, hot breakfast; free Wi-fi; pet-friendly rooms; and the on-site Tides Pool Bar and Grill, which serves small plates and cocktails. 

Pros

  • Vibrant pool deck with fire pits
  • Peleton bikes in fitness center
  • On-site dining and full-bar options

Cons

  • Not within walking distance to historic district
  • Not all rooms have balconies
  • A car is a must
2700-2 Atlantic Ave., Fernandina Beach, FL, 32034, USA
904-491–1221
Hotel Details
134 suites
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

St. Francis Inn Bed & Breakfast

$$ | 279 St. George St., St. Augustine, FL, 32084, USA

This late-18th-century inn in the Historic District, a guesthouse since 1845, offers main-house rooms and suites, a room in the former carriage house, and a five-room cottage—all with a serene vibe and a delicious Southern breakfast buffet included. If the walls of the oldest inn in the Oldest City could talk, they would tell tales of buried doubloons and Confederate spies. Furnishings are a mix of antiques and just plain old; the food is fresh and well prepared (there's a chef on property). A stay includes thoughtful extras like free admission to the Anastasia Athletic Club; use of bicycles; complimentary admission to the St. Augustine Lighthouse and Museum; and an evening social with enough snacks, desserts, and house-blend coffees, teas, and hot chocolates to pass for dinner.

Pros

  • Warm hospitality
  • Lots of extras
  • Short walk to Historic District attractions

Cons

  • Small rooms
  • Small pool
  • Small bathrooms
279 St. George St., St. Augustine, FL, 32084, USA
904-474-3637
Hotel Details
17 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?

St. George Inn

$$ | 4 St. George St., St. Augustine, FL, 32084, USA

You can't be any closer to the St. George Street bustle than this inn nestled in the City Gate Plaza. A continental breakfast of assorted cheeses, fresh-baked breads, and pastries is included. For a splurge, book a Castillo Suite—a romantic two-story suite with a spiral staircase and wraparound balcony with views of Castillo de San Marcos, Matanzas Bay, and St. George Street.

Pros

  • Convenient downtown location
  • Balconies have views
  • Comfortable beds

Cons

  • Some street noise
  • Parking two blocks away
  • Shared balconies
4 St. George St., St. Augustine, FL, 32084, USA
904-827–5740
Hotel Details
25 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?

Sweetwater Branch Inn Lodging & Events

$ | 625 E. University Ave., Gainesville, FL, 32601, USA

Inside two grand Victorian homes—surrounded by gardens in historic downtown and within walking distance of restaurants and entertainment venues—nicely appointed guest rooms have gleaming hardwood floors, antique furnishings, and modern conveniences like free Wi-Fi. There's also plenty of Southern hospitality, as well as amenities such as an eco-friendly salt pool, business services, and detached cottages with full kitchens.

Pros

  • Southern-style breakfast
  • Whirlpool suites
  • Walking distance to town

Cons

  • Occasional noise issues
  • Frequent on-site weddings
  • Strict cancellation policy
625 E. University Ave., Gainesville, FL, 32601, USA
352-373–6760
Hotel Details
19 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

World Golf Village Renaissance St. Augustine Resort

$ | 500 S. Legacy Trail, St. Augustine, FL, 32092, USA

If you want to be within walking distance of all that World Golf Village has to offer (including championship courses and a full-service day spa), this resort is an excellent choice. Rooms and suites, stylish and elegant with spa-inspired bathrooms, surround a 10-story atrium, at the bottom of which is the Villagio Italian Grille set amid tropical foliage and streams. In addition to playing rounds of golf and indulging in a spa treatment, you work out in the 24-hour fitness center or play a game or two in the billiards room.

Pros

  • Excellent restaurant and bar
  • Large bathrooms
  • Free shuttle to golf courses, spa, and downtown

Cons

  • Small pool
  • Daily fee for Internet/phone
  • 25 minutes from downtown
500 S. Legacy Trail, St. Augustine, FL, 32092, USA
904-940–8000
Hotel Details
301 rooms
No Meals

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?