3 Best Restaurants in Rincón and the Porta del Sol, Puerto Rico

Background Illustration for Restaurants

If you like seafood, you're in the right place. Throughout northwestern Puerto Rico you'll find wonderful criollo (Puerto Rican creole) cuisine. Most local eateries serve deep-fried tapas, commonly called frituras (meaning "fritters"). Offering a break from fried food are dozens of foreign-owned eateries that serve everything from sushi and hamburgers to vegetarian and Thai cuisine. Farther south along the coast options are limited, so you may want to ask the chef to grill or sauté your fish. A trip to Puerto Rico is not complete without sampling Puerto Rico’s most iconic dish, mofongo relleno, made from fried, seasoned and mashed plantain or yuca stuffed with your choice of seafood or meat. Simply head to where locals from all over the island go for fresh seafood—Joyuda. When it comes to beverages, locals usually drink rum and coke or mix it with fresh-squeezed orange or grapefruit juice. You’ll also see people sipping on Medalla Light, Puerto Rico's most popular and affordable beer. All restaurants are no-smoking. Tips, normally 15%–20%, are usually not included in the bill, but it's always wise to double-check.

Estela

$$$$ Fodor's choice

On weekends, patrons come from as far as San Juan to dine at this cozy restaurant. Operated by husband-and-wife team Juan and Nerylu, it's found a niche in Rincón offering dishes made using locally sourced ingredients—you may even see a fisherman pull up with a giant yellowfin tuna. The regularly changing menu by chef Abel Mendoza might feature dishes such as pan-fried octopus with squid ink corn fritters, and the fresh catch of the day with a purple yam mash. You can't go wrong with any of the daily specials. The dining room can get loud, so ask to be seated outside on the terrace.

Rte. 115, Km 14, Rincón, 00677, Puerto Rico
787-823–1795
Known For
  • Fresh seafood
  • Farm-to-table dining
  • Good wine list
Restaurant Details
Closed Sun. and Mon. No lunch
Reservations essential

Something incorrect in this review?

Reina Mora

$$$$

Located on the Rincón–Aguada border, this supper club run by a husband-and-wife team has a multicourse menu that changes weekly and highlights locally sourced and grown food. Vegan and vegetarian options are available upon request, as well as a variety of wines. Dinners are by reservation only and they sell out quickly. Note, too, that payment is made at the time of booking.

Rte. 414, Km 6, Aguada, 00602, Puerto Rico
404-431–1587
Known For
  • Supper club
  • Seasonal, farm-to-table menu
  • By reservation only
Restaurant Details
Closed Sun.--Wed.
Reservation required

Something incorrect in this review?

Restaurant at La Casa

$$$$

Many things stand out at this picturesque resort restaurant: the emerald-green golf course in the foreground, the majestic cliffs on the coast, and the roaring ocean in the background. A fair amount of the fruits and vegetables used in the dishes here are grown at Royal Isabela's River Farm and Gatehouse Garden; all the fish is caught offshore.

396 Av. Noel Estrada, Isabela, 00662, Puerto Rico
787-609–5888
Known For
  • Freshest seafood
  • Roasted duck breast
  • Farm-to-table approach

Something incorrect in this review?

Recommended Fodor's Video