A new entry in discussion about tipping the maid
#1
Original Poster
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 3,491
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
A new entry in discussion about tipping the maid
On one of the morning talk shows (think it was Today after 9 am), Lawrence Tisch (now where have we heard that name before?), who is now CEO of Lowe's, talked about the experience of doing various jobs around his hotels -- it was part of a "Now Who's Boss" series, I believe. He said that by far the hardest job was the chambermaid's and how horrible it was that people tip everyone else but often don't tip the maid. He said that would now be a "special crusade" of his.
Well, I have always felt strongly that maids should be tipped, and tipped generously, and I've never bought the idea that we shouldn't be coerced into making up for low pay levels. But Tisch really ticked me off -- proposing that his response to finding out how hard a job is should be to turn to the public to pay the maids more. When Matt Lauer (I think it was) said, "yeah and how 'bout a raise all around?" he changed the subject. My first nomination for the Bronze Willfully-Missing-the-Point award for 2004.
Well, I have always felt strongly that maids should be tipped, and tipped generously, and I've never bought the idea that we shouldn't be coerced into making up for low pay levels. But Tisch really ticked me off -- proposing that his response to finding out how hard a job is should be to turn to the public to pay the maids more. When Matt Lauer (I think it was) said, "yeah and how 'bout a raise all around?" he changed the subject. My first nomination for the Bronze Willfully-Missing-the-Point award for 2004.
#5
Guest
Posts: n/a
Well, of course he's not gonna say, "gee, I should pay them more." But he should. It's disgraceful what housekeeping staff is paid.
I always tip, and tip daily -- when possible, I try to identify who does my room early in my stay (it does change sometimes, esp. over weekend duty) and say hello and thank you. You'd be surprised what little extras that (tipping and saying thanks) can sometimes buy you.
Shame on Tisch.
I always tip, and tip daily -- when possible, I try to identify who does my room early in my stay (it does change sometimes, esp. over weekend duty) and say hello and thank you. You'd be surprised what little extras that (tipping and saying thanks) can sometimes buy you.
Shame on Tisch.
#6
Join Date: Jan 2004
Posts: 14
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I cleaned hotel rooms over summer and Christmas breaks from college. I almost never got tipped, and it was by far the most physically demanding and all-around crappy job I've ever had. It makes me furious that our hotel couldn't "afford" to pay maids more than $6 an hour, while the owner's daughter goes gallivanting around the world, wearing haute couture and discarding the clothes after one use (for herself and her chihuahua), filming her sex life, etc. I'm not dropping any names here am I? =)
#11
Join Date: Feb 2004
Posts: 1,038
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
In restaruants the servers do not earn minimun wage, their income is dependent on tips. I think this is also true of some baggage handlers and drivers who basically rent a car.
While housekeeping staff are paid minimum wage or above, it is true that their job is very hard and underappreciated.
rpn, I have noticed a definate difference in service as I tip housekeepers and others don't. Thanks
While housekeeping staff are paid minimum wage or above, it is true that their job is very hard and underappreciated.
rpn, I have noticed a definate difference in service as I tip housekeepers and others don't. Thanks
#15
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 23,138
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
When we travel with our teenagers I spend a few dollars to tip the housekeeping staff - then I feel less guilty abut the clutter my kids leave around (note - it is clutter - not dirt, food leavings, destruction, etc. - I would not let them get away with that - just routine clutter, primarily clothing and CDs). If I travel alone and stay for just one night, I tend not to since I bearly disturb anything in the room.
For multiple night stays and especially in suites with any kind of kitchen facilities, even though we clean up after ourselves, I tip more generously.
For multiple night stays and especially in suites with any kind of kitchen facilities, even though we clean up after ourselves, I tip more generously.
#16
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 15,749
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
As a side note, I generally consider myself an "over" tipper. But I never leave a tip for the maid on a one night stay. It seems that there has been absolutely no personal service for me. The hotel provided me with a clean room and made bed. What is there to tip for? That's different than a maid working around my open suitcases, the wet towels left on the floor, or cleaning the sink around all my stuff. When she cleans a room I'm staying in, I leave a tip.
#17
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 13,407
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'm surprised by the people who say they don't tip for one nighters. If the room is clean and everything is in order when I arrive, I still leave a tip. My biggest peeve is when the alarm clock isn't turned off or reset from the previous guest's stay and I'm awakened at 4:00am the next morning.
#19
Guest
Posts: n/a
OK, if you don't tip for staying just one night, and there is a new guest each night for seven nights, does that mean the maid has to change the bed 7 times and get no tip? That's harder work than coming in to vacuum and just re-make the bed.
I recently had to stay for a prolonged visit in a suites-type place, where we had two tiers of service: make the bed and refresh the towels most days but change the sheets and really scour everything once a week. I tipped the first day -- to set a precedent -- and tipped the guy who offered to bring my suitcase up the stairs, and thereafter I tipped bigtime on the day they changed sheets and cleaned. Within one week, I started to get little extras (extra soaps, etc.), and a little more spiffing up on the "regular" days (like running the dishwasher and putting the dishes away, which she didn't have to do).
But I still would have tipped had I only been there one day. Just because her service preceded your arrival doesn't mean she didn't perform a service. Or to put it another way, if you leave a royal mess once you check out, then she will have performed a service after the fact.
And by the way, can anyone verify that they are, in fact, paid minimum wage? It's a pittance and you can't live on it, but I thought they didn't even get that much because it's thought that maids get part of their income through tips, true or not.
I recently had to stay for a prolonged visit in a suites-type place, where we had two tiers of service: make the bed and refresh the towels most days but change the sheets and really scour everything once a week. I tipped the first day -- to set a precedent -- and tipped the guy who offered to bring my suitcase up the stairs, and thereafter I tipped bigtime on the day they changed sheets and cleaned. Within one week, I started to get little extras (extra soaps, etc.), and a little more spiffing up on the "regular" days (like running the dishwasher and putting the dishes away, which she didn't have to do).
But I still would have tipped had I only been there one day. Just because her service preceded your arrival doesn't mean she didn't perform a service. Or to put it another way, if you leave a royal mess once you check out, then she will have performed a service after the fact.
And by the way, can anyone verify that they are, in fact, paid minimum wage? It's a pittance and you can't live on it, but I thought they didn't even get that much because it's thought that maids get part of their income through tips, true or not.
#20
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 15,749
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
About how hard the job is and tipping even for one nighters when the maid has no personal contact or done something special -- where do you leave the tip for the handyman who unplugs toilets, cleans up the leaks, the oil spills in the garage, etc? Do you leave a tip for him? I still maintain the basic idea of paying money to a hotel is that they provide you with a room. Why in the world would you tip someone who just did their part of that? A tip is for someone who did something "personal" for you in my humble opinion.