Ok I'm hoping I can find someone here with first hand experience. I will be on Culebra in mid January for 4 days fishing and snorkeling. I will be camping / based out of Flamenco Beach .
To get around - I need a rental car - already dismissed the idea of Golf cart - no way to lock stuff up - no weather protection etc. So I'm down to 3 options as far as I can tell
1. Carlos Jeep Rental - advertising $100/ day - not sure of insurance and other add ons
2. Jerrys Jeep Rental - $80 bucks a day - insurance and extra driver a bit more than others
3. Chocos Bronco Rental - $105 / day - haven't seen their add on prices yet.

anyone have any recommendations - or horror stories? insider info that can guide me in my decision?

thanks