This new format
#22



Joined: May 2004
Posts: 6,412
Likes: 0
You know,now that you mention it I can't stand that word "community" either. The word just sounds way too left wing ,politically correct, communistic, etc. to me, sorry.
How about Neighborhood or Travel Talk, something that makes more sense?
How about Neighborhood or Travel Talk, something that makes more sense?
#24
Original Poster

Joined: May 2004
Posts: 13,860
Likes: 0
Yeah...Travel Talk...I hate the word..."Community", too. And I'm not going to remember that when friends who are new to the forum asks me how to log on. Before I just told them to go on fodors.com and then click on Talk and then Asia..."REAL" easy and easy to remember. Happy Travels!
#25
Joined: Sep 2008
Posts: 2,804
Likes: 0
We hear you loud and clear! Internally here we often refer to member-oriented projects as "community" projects. I really like receiving your feedback on this point as we often discussed name consistency.
Eventually, we would like that main landing page to be a more consolidated and communal space for all things "member-minded". Perhaps "Talk" will still make sense to use; perhaps we will shift to something else. At the moment, I admit that it is confusing; I will look into having it changed back to "Talk".
The fixed topic box improvement is a good one. I will pass that along as well.
Eventually, we would like that main landing page to be a more consolidated and communal space for all things "member-minded". Perhaps "Talk" will still make sense to use; perhaps we will shift to something else. At the moment, I admit that it is confusing; I will look into having it changed back to "Talk".
The fixed topic box improvement is a good one. I will pass that along as well.
#26
Joined: Mar 2003
Posts: 2,552
Likes: 0
Hi Katie, here's my two cents: It seems like Fodor's has reached a sort of tipping point with the popularity of the forums, matched by the company's desire to do more for this area and its incorporating Fodorite tips in the guidebook Word of Mouth quotes. One aspect of this is that, from what I've seen, the forums are frequently (always?) referred to as Travel Talk. To change the nomenclature to Community at a point when there is (I assume) increased traffic has the potential to be confusing.
Since you mention that the changes to that main landing page would occur "eventually", my suggestion would be to make the name change at that point. It will make more sense from a user perspective to change the nomenclature with a significant functional/cosmetic redesign, and to have the name reflect those changes. You might find that "Community" works best, or that something completely new occurs to you as you flesh out those (eagerly anticipated!) enhancements.
Also, I figured out what was making it so disorienting for me to find my username. On the main Fodor's page, the link is in the middle of the header, below the banner ad and the menu bar. On the forums pages, there is no ad at the top, so the link is actually in a physically different place, above the menu bar, I'm sure in order to save real estate. Not much to do about that, I'm afraid!
Overall, the font and graphic elements are an elegant improvement. I look forward to whatever comes next!
Hope this helps!
Since you mention that the changes to that main landing page would occur "eventually", my suggestion would be to make the name change at that point. It will make more sense from a user perspective to change the nomenclature with a significant functional/cosmetic redesign, and to have the name reflect those changes. You might find that "Community" works best, or that something completely new occurs to you as you flesh out those (eagerly anticipated!) enhancements.
Also, I figured out what was making it so disorienting for me to find my username. On the main Fodor's page, the link is in the middle of the header, below the banner ad and the menu bar. On the forums pages, there is no ad at the top, so the link is actually in a physically different place, above the menu bar, I'm sure in order to save real estate. Not much to do about that, I'm afraid!
Overall, the font and graphic elements are an elegant improvement. I look forward to whatever comes next!
Hope this helps!
#27



Joined: May 2004
Posts: 6,412
Likes: 0
Suggestions,
Talkroom
Travel Talk
Travelchat
Travelchatter
Traveler's Opinions
Chat room
Travel Chatroom
Travel Views
Traveler's Reviews
Fodor's chat
Talk About It
Talk About Travel
ok, wasted enough time, back to work
Aloha!
Talkroom
Travel Talk
Travelchat
Travelchatter
Traveler's Opinions
Chat room
Travel Chatroom
Travel Views
Traveler's Reviews
Fodor's chat
Talk About It
Talk About Travel
ok, wasted enough time, back to work
Aloha!
#29
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 33,288
Likes: 0
I'm having log-in problems. Sometimes the site recognizes me, sometimes not... If the site doesn't recognize me, when I sign it, the sign-in doesn't work. But if I sign in (and it doesn't accept my log-in) but I click on Talk, then on the Asia forum, it than has me signed in. weird.

