40 Best Hotels in The Northwest, Argentina

Background Illustration for Hotels

We've compiled the best of the best in The Northwest - browse our top choices for the top things to see or do during your stay.

THE BEST HOTEL IN THE NORTHWEST

Estancia Colomé

$$$$ | 20 km (13 miles) west of Molinos, Molinos, 4419, Argentina

FODOR’S EXPERT REVIEW

An ideal stopover between Salta capital and Cafayate on the picturesque Ruta 40, this stunning lodge is located on the Colomé wine estate 20 km (13 miles) from Molinos.

Pros

  • Spacious and well-designed rooms
  • Restaurant uses ingredients from its organic garden
  • Authentic experience at a working vineyard

Cons

  • Wi-Fi is spotty
  • Very remote
  • Not all staff speak English well
20 km (13 miles) west of Molinos, Molinos, 4419, Argentina
3868-49–4200
Hotel Details
9 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

Something incorrect in this review?

Altos de la Viña

$$ | Pasquini López 50, San Salvador de Jujuy, 4600, Argentina Fodor's Choice

This former state-owned hotel, a short ride out of town, has comfortable rooms and recreational facilities that invite you to linger; the view from the swimming pool takes in most of the city and the mountains beyond. Altos de la Viña's 12-acre property also includes a spa and tennis court, plus reasonably priced restaurant Olaroz.

Pros

  • Great pool
  • Good for families
  • Helipad

Cons

  • Very little within walking distance
  • Own transport is useful
  • Some rooms could do with an update
Pasquini López 50, San Salvador de Jujuy, 4600, Argentina
11-5031–9635
Hotel Details
60 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?

El Manantial del Silencio

$$$ | RN52, Km 3.5, Purmamarca, 4618, Argentina Fodor's Choice

At this tranquil retreat, weeping willows, red rocks, and gardens filled with birdsong are hemmed in by the craggy Quebrada and its utter calm; inside the colonial-style stucco mansion, local artifacts and earth tones make things warm and harmonious throughout. The view from the Jacuzzi is unbeatable. The restaurant offers sophisticated takes on local fare.

Pros

  • One of the grandest lodgings in the Quebrada
  • Great gardens, restaurant, spa, and pool
  • Welcoming shared areas

Cons

  • One of the most expensive lodgings in the area
  • Noise reverberates down hallways
  • Friendly staff aren't necessarily on the ball
RN52, Km 3.5, Purmamarca, 4618, Argentina
388-490–8080
Hotel Details
20 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

Something incorrect in this review?

Recommended Fodor's Video

Grace Cafayate

$$$ | RN40, Km 4340, Cafayate, 4427, Argentina Fodor's Choice

A contemporary offering in the area, Grace Cafayate isn't just a step away from the local style—it's a whole world away. Located within the well-heeled La Estancia de Cafayate residential and recreational complex, its lodging options include suites overlooking vineyards in the main building, as well as stand-alone villas and apartments across the way. Relax by the infinity pool or head to the spa for a grape-based treatment, then watch dinner being prepared in the open kitchen at the gourmet restaurant. Golfers can book a round on the Estancia's 18-hole course. 

Pros

  • Infinity pool and spa on-site
  • Comfy king-size beds
  • Wine bar

Cons

  • Breakfast is on the small side
  • It can seem overly quiet
  • Not all staff speak English
RN40, Km 4340, Cafayate, 4427, Argentina
386-842–7000
Hotel Details
52 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

Something incorrect in this review?

Hacienda de Molinos

$$ | Molinos s/n, Molinos, Argentina Fodor's Choice

This lovely 18th-century hacienda belonged to the last Spanish governor, its fantastic open courtyard, white adobe walls, and racing green doorways denoting the colonial era. Rooms are spacious and well-appointed, with king-size beds and large bathtubs. Kick back with afternoon tea under the pink pepper tree or laze about next to the swimming pool. Its location opposite the church ensures you can soak up Molinos’ atmosphere easily; the in-house restaurant is ideal for lunch stop-offs (the beef empanadas are widely touted as the best in the region) if you can't stay.

Pros

  • Spacious rooms
  • Good restaurant with local wine list
  • Swimming pool

Cons

  • Service can be slow at peak times
  • Noisy doors
  • Few staff speak English
Molinos s/n, Molinos, Argentina
387-684–8090
Hotel Details
18 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?

Hotel Huacalera

$$ | R9, Km 1790, Tilcara, 4626, Argentina Fodor's Choice

This hotel, on the main road in the heart of the Quebrada de Humahuaca, is a stunning colonial-style property, complete with a spa, an outdoor swimming pool, and spacious, well-appointed guest rooms. Design and simplicity combine for a comfortable stay. 

Pros

  • Courteous staff
  • Good restaurant
  • Large breakfast

Cons

  • Trucks on the main drag can be noisy
  • The restaurant lacks atmosphere
  • Echoing in hallways
R9, Km 1790, Tilcara, 4626, Argentina
388-581–3417
Hotel Details
32 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?

Kkala

$$ | Las Higueras 104, Salta, A4408KAD, Argentina Fodor's Choice

This elegant 10-room abode represents Salta, right down to the cardon cactus door panels and hand-stitched headboards depicting Andean landscapes. Comfortable en suite guest rooms, each named after a national park, have terraces and some boast a poolside view. You can lounge in the living room with a glass of Torrontés after a long day of sightseeing.

Pros

  • Delightful bilingual staff
  • Stylish en suite rooms
  • Honesty bar

Cons

  • Not that close to main attractions
  • Some rooms are compact
  • Some areas could use paint
Las Higueras 104, Salta, A4408KAD, Argentina
387-439–6590
Hotel Details
10 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?

La Merced del Alto

$$ | Fuerte Alto s/n, Cachi, 4417, Argentina Fodor's Choice

Although this stately white-adobe building looks like it's been here forever, it was in fact built in 2006. Inside, rooms are huge and comfortable with tasteful wood and iron furniture. Communal areas include an enormous reading room, a well-stocked bar, a wine cellar, and a lovely restaurant. In a separate building there's a fully equipped spa with outdoor Jacuzzi, and hotel staff can arrange trekking, horseback riding, and visits to archaeological sites. The hotel sits between two streams, with the Nevada de Cachi on one side, the Parque Los Cardones on the other, and the town spread out below.

Pros

  • Expansive grounds with great views
  • Spa, wine cellar, bar, and restaurant on-site
  • Accessible for people with disabilities

Cons

  • 3 km (2 miles) from Cachi
  • Echoing corridors
  • Wi-Fi is flaky
Fuerte Alto s/n, Cachi, 4417, Argentina
3868-490–020
Hotel Details
13 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?

Legado Mítico

$$$ | Bartolomé Mitre 647, Salta, 4400, Argentina Fodor's Choice

Sister to the Buenos Aires hotel of the same name, the family-run Legado Mítico attends to every detail—from the gorgeous guest rooms named after notable figures from the city's past and individually decorated to suit the titular person right down to the welcome glass of wine. Shared areas, hung with artworks by the owners' mother, Norma Adamo, are extremely inviting.

Pros

  • Warm and pleasing spaces
  • The living room and terrace are comfy spots for a moment of relaxation
  • Attractive decor

Cons

  • Located on a rather busy main drag
  • Street-facing rooms can be noisy
  • Noisy doors
Bartolomé Mitre 647, Salta, 4400, Argentina
387-422–8786
Hotel Details
11 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

Something incorrect in this review?

Patios de Cafayate Wine Hotel

$$$$ | R40 at RN68, Cafayate, 4427, Argentina Fodor's Choice

Creature comforts, a fine restaurant, and rustic-chic rooms overlooking the vineyards make this luxury property a top choice. In the Wine Spa (which is open only to hotel guests), local blends are used for grape baths and other treatments. If you are more interested in drinking wine than soaking in it, the on-site Bodega El Esteco produces several well-received lines, including Old Vines and Fincas Notables. Comprehensive tours and tastings are available. Be sure to dine at La Rosa restaurant, which has an imaginative menu comprised of local dishes given contemporary twists by chef Virginia Marín; many ingredients are sourced from the organic garden.

Pros

  • Exclusive
  • Wonderful pool surrounded by vines
  • Fabulous facilities including wine spa and bodega

Cons

  • Pricey
  • You'll need a car to get around
  • Large tours can spoil the ambience
R40 at RN68, Cafayate, 4427, Argentina
3868-422–229
Hotel Details
31 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

Something incorrect in this review?

Pristine Camps

$$$$ | Salinas Grandes, Purmamarca, Argentina Fodor's Choice

An ambitious glamping project tucked away in a salt mine south of the Salinas Grandes, this debut lodging from Pristine Camps comprises four luxurious domes, two including Jacuzzis, and a restaurant located 3,600 meters (11,811 feet) above sea level. Members of the local indigenous community Aguas Blancas, who also manage the salt mining co-operative, form the staff’s core. The arrival in 4x4 from the designated pickup point is mind-blowing in itself, especially when it has recently rained, and the sight is so off the beaten track, you can only expect peace, quiet, and stunning 360º and unique vertical-horizontal views. Those on modest budgets should book in for lunch.

Pros

  • The night skies balance out the high cost
  • All-inclusive experience means seeing the Salinas from a different perspective
  • Friendly staff come from the local indigenous community

Cons

  • The high elevation is hard for some to deal with
  • More salt-related activities should be welcomed
  • It can be extremely hot in the day then cold at night
Salinas Grandes, Purmamarca, Argentina
Hotel Details
4 domes
All-Inclusive

Quick Facts

Something incorrect in this review?

Villa del Cielo

$$ | Prospero Nieva s/n, Tilcara, Argentina Fodor's Choice

Tucked away in one of the more elevated parts of Tilcara, thereby offering priceless panoramas, cozy rooms and cabins sporting traditional style, and plenty of comfort for up to four guests await at Villa del Cielo. Given that the hotel’s owner is also behind Huichaira Vineyards in Huichaira near Tilcara, there’s also a small vineyard. Shared spaces include a relaxing zone and a solid eponymous restaurant that opens to the public (mains around 12,000 pesos) and stocks local wines.

Pros

  • Friendly service
  • Great breakfast
  • Knowledgeable staff to help with planning

Cons

  • Walking back up the mountain can be hard work
  • Not the best Wi-Fi
  • Neighbors' dogs can be noisy
Prospero Nieva s/n, Tilcara, Argentina
388-495–5537
Hotel Details
10 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?

ACA Hosteria

$$ | Av. Automóvil Club Argentino s/n, Cachi, 4417, Argentina

Once the only decent place to stay in Cachi, the Argentine Automobile Club hosteria is gaining some stiff competition, but is still a practical option thanks to its swimming pool, children's facilities, attractive garden, and reliable restaurant.

Pros

  • Lovely pool views
  • Buffet breakfast
  • Large play area

Cons

  • Compact rooms
  • Rooms can echo
  • Lacks character of other local hotels
Av. Automóvil Club Argentino s/n, Cachi, 4417, Argentina
3868-491–904
Hotel Details
33 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?

Altalaluna Boutique Hotel & Spa

$ | RN40, Km 4326, Cafayate, 4141, Argentina

This gorgeous boutique hotel in the village of Tolombón, 14 km (9 miles) south of Cafayate, occupies an 1892 colonial mansion; there's a wine bar and cellar, an excellent restaurant, a reading room complete with fireplace, and a peaceful spa overlooking endless vines. Rooms are spacious and nicely decorated, with views of the garden and large swimming pool. At the back of the hotel you can find the Tolombón Ruins.

Pros

  • Great facilities
  • Perfect for star-spotting
  • Spacious rooms

Cons

  • The pool isn't heated
  • Own transport required
  • Passageways can echo
RN40, Km 4326, Cafayate, 4141, Argentina
387-582–4501
Hotel Details
20 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Amalinas

$ | Ruta Provincial 28, Km 11.5, San Lorenzo, Argentina

A contemporary option than Salta's often more traditional hotels, Amalinas' design features poured cement and soothing natural hues adorned with splashes of primary colors, plus airy rooms offering views across leafy San Lorenzo. Great thread count sheets ensure a good night's sleep. Service from both reception and restaurant staff is attentive.

Pros

  • Rooms with a view of rolling hills
  • Quiet and peaceful
  • Restaurant puts fresh spin on local classics

Cons

  • You need a car to get around
  • Check-out time is early at 10 am
  • Pool isn't heated
Ruta Provincial 28, Km 11.5, San Lorenzo, Argentina
0387-492–1738
Hotel Details
10 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Ayres de Salta

$$ | General Güemes 650, Salta, 4400, Argentina

Conveniently located between the main plaza and Balcarce Street, Ayres de Salta has a small pool and fitness center on the roof and a good little restaurant on the ground floor; rooms are large and well-equipped. The staff can arrange excursions to the rest of the province and parts of Jujuy.

Pros

  • Efficient, professional staff can arrange excursions
  • Good location
  • Buffet breakfast

Cons

  • Some rooms look into the windows of other rooms
  • Street-facing rooms are noisy
  • Could do with new paint
General Güemes 650, Salta, 4400, Argentina
387-422–1616
Hotel Details
40 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?

Cafayate Wine Resort

$ | 25 de Mayo s/n, Cafayate, 4427, Argentina

Three km (2 miles) from the plaza on a straight dusty road lined with vineyards and in the shadow of San Isidro is a large white adobe building with 22 rooms built around a wide courtyard. Highlights include walk-in closets, a well-stocked cellar with tastings and talks, an excellent gourmet restaurant, and an elevated swimming pool with views of vineyards and mountains.

Pros

  • Spacious shared areas and access to veranda from all rooms
  • Swimming pool with great views
  • Lovely garden surrounded by vines

Cons

  • Some furniture may feel dated
  • Isolated from the town
  • Some noise from hallways
25 de Mayo s/n, Cafayate, 4427, Argentina
386-840–5024
Hotel Details
22 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Delvino Boutique Hotel

$ | Ameghino 555, Salta, 4400, Argentina

Oenophiles will appreciate the decor at Delvino—a remodeled, Spanish-style villa where the airy guest rooms are painted in grape tones (Malbec red among them) and decorated with wine-themed artworks. All are named after one of Argentina’s sacred grapes; try the Torrontés suite for size (it comes with a Jacuzzi). You can relax with a bottle of vino from the on-site wine store in the cozy living room or, in warmer months, sip it on the veranda by the swimming pool.

Pros

  • Two blocks from Train to the Clouds railway station
  • Glass of wine on arrival
  • Swimming pool

Cons

  • Exposed stairway can be chilly
  • No elevators
  • Some rooms are poky
Ameghino 555, Salta, 4400, Argentina
387-432–0092
Hotel Details
18 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Eaton Place

$$ | San Martín 2457, San Lorenzo, 4401, Argentina

Despite appearances, this striking Georgian-style mansion only dates from the 1980s, when it was built as a private home. It still feels like one, with bright and airy rooms in the main house and in a guesthouse with huge windows, hardwood floors, and period furniture. The dark-wood-paneled penthouse suite has a vaulted ceiling; two of the double rooms in the guesthouse share a sitting room, making them ideal for a family or group.

Pros

  • Well-appointed
  • Large breakfast
  • Lovely property with pool and gardens

Cons

  • A long way from the center of Salta
  • No on-site restaurant
  • A vehicle is necessary
San Martín 2457, San Lorenzo, 4401, Argentina
387-492–1347
Hotel Details
7 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?

El Bodeguero

$$ | 20 de Febrero 877, Salta, 4400, Argentina

After renovating a colonial-style mansion into a boutique hotel, El Bodeguero—named in tribute to its former owners, the renowned Etchart winemaking family—refreshes the accommodation options in downtown Salta. The property opened in 2024, and aesthetics are contemporary blended, stylish rooms using natural tones as well as natural materials such as leather and wool, and retaining original features such as the elevator and stairways. Details include upcycling wooden blinds as headboards. The in-house restaurant is excellent, includes an underground cellar room for private meals, and is an equally refreshing addition to Salta’s often traditional dining scene. 

Pros

  • Stylish design
  • Great restaurant
  • Houses a wine and cocktail bar

Cons

  • Located on a busy road
  • Garden patio needs to grow into itself
  • Library is rather cramped
20 de Febrero 877, Salta, 4400, Argentina
387-242--2090
Hotel Details
12 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?

El Cardon

$ | Belgrano s/n, Purmamarca, 4618, Argentina

It's small and no-frills, but if you're just looking for a place to sleep in between excursions, this friendly lodging a short walk from the main square is a good bet. Its seven rooms are arranged around a small courtyard, and are decorated sparingly.

Pros

  • A reliable, in-town option
  • Budget-friendly
  • Great terrace

Cons

  • Few, basic facilities
  • Often full in high season
  • Staff can be cross
Belgrano s/n, Purmamarca, 4618, Argentina
388-490–8672
Hotel Details
7 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

El Cortijo

$$ | Av. Automóvil Club Argentino s/n, Cachi, 4417, Argentina

Converted from a vintage villa, this boutique hotel stands out for its chic and traditional style and friendly service; the 12 guest rooms are tastefully decorated with traditional antiques and art. Common areas include a charming courtyard, a wine cellar, and a gorgeous stone-walled restaurant (Catalino) serving Andean cuisine.

Pros

  • Artistic decor
  • Charming courtyard and wine cellar
  • Free Wi-Fi

Cons

  • Rooms vary in terms of size and views
  • Breakfast is basic
  • Passageways echo
Av. Automóvil Club Argentino s/n, Cachi, 4417, Argentina
(387)-3868-587–8513
Hotel Details
12 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?

El Hospedaje

$ | Salta 13, and Camila Quintana de Niño, Cafayate, 4427, Argentina

This century-old building used to be a youth hostel until the owner got tired of the noise and chaos; rooms are basic, but they're set around a pleasant courtyard or around the inviting swimming pool.

Pros

  • Quiet and close to center
  • Continental breakfast in a large dining room
  • Friendly staff

Cons

  • Few facilities
  • Rooms are basic
  • Rooms next to street are noisy
Salta 13, and Camila Quintana de Niño, Cafayate, 4427, Argentina
3868-421–680
Hotel Details
12 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

El Porvenir Wine Lodge

$$ | Belgrano 32, Cafayate, 4427, Argentina

For a taste at playing vineyard owner, book an elevated loft housed on El Porvenir de Cafayate's wine estate. Five contemporary suites opened in 2024 and the well-appointed rooms with queen-size beds and great linen include a wine cava, a coffeemaker, and a communal swimming pool. Vineyard and mountain views abound from the property, offering peace despite proximity to Cafayate's center.

Pros

  • Excellent vistas
  • Walking distance to main square
  • The wine flows

Cons

  • The key and lock are finicky
  • Floors are cold on bare feet
  • The interior design is rather stark
Belgrano 32, Cafayate, 4427, Argentina
386-840–6905
Hotel Details
5 suites
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?

El Refugio del Pintor

$ | Alverro 660, between Jujuy and Ambroseti, Tilcara, 4624, Argentina

The building that houses this hotel was formerly used by the painter Medardo Pantoja from Jujuy, hence the name (Refuge of the Painter) and the artwork adorning the walls. The sweeping views are timeless, but everything else has been redone with style and imagination; rooms are small yet efficient, with wooden beams, striped fabrics, and big windows. Common spaces are light and welcoming. There's a fogón (open fireplace) for cooking in the courtyard or for warming chilly feet. Look carefully for the hotel sign or you'll miss it.

Pros

  • Great views
  • Plenty of common spaces
  • Good breakfast with homemade bread

Cons

  • Stairs can be difficult with luggage
  • Small rooms
  • Staff could be more attentive
Alverro 660, between Jujuy and Ambroseti, Tilcara, 4624, Argentina
388-427–1432
Hotel Details
13 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Fancy Rancho

$ | Ruta Prov. Nº 2 km 6, Cafayate, Argentina

An adorable one-room B&B located on the vineyard slopes that form part of the Bodega Yacochuya wine estate, Fancy Rancho makes for a very private stay. Enjoy breakfast accompanied by a fantastic view of the valley before heading out to nearby wineries Domingo Molino and Piattelli. There’s also a grill, so you can try your hand at making asado, Argentina style.

Pros

  • Close to wineries
  • Peaceful setting
  • Stunning valley vista

Cons

  • Best reached by car
  • Few kitchen facilities
  • Cash only
Ruta Prov. Nº 2 km 6, Cafayate, Argentina
386-863–9027
Hotel Details
1 suite
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Gregorio 1

$ | Independencia 829, San Salvador de Jujuy, 4600, Argentina

This downtown boutique hotel has sober rooms with parquet floors and all the modern conveniences. Large comfy armchairs draped with woven textiles dress the public areas; the decor, with its clean and simple lines, is well executed.

Pros

  • Close to sights
  • Attentive service
  • Comfy rooms

Cons

  • Few in-hotel services
  • Isn't quite "boutique"
  • Breakfast isn't very imaginative
Independencia 829, San Salvador de Jujuy, 4600, Argentina
388-424–4747
Hotel Details
19 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Hotel Asturias

$$ | Av. Güemes Sur 154, Cafayate, 4427, Argentina

The swimming pool is terrific, the garden is ample, and this property—the biggest and oldest hotel in town—is quite comfortable. Half the rooms are standard, the other half superior, with better views and decoration; all feature big bathrooms and lots of storage space.

Pros

  • Great garden and pool
  • Central
  • Friendly staff

Cons

  • Many staff don't speak English
  • Breakfast is standard
  • Weak Wi-Fi in some rooms
Av. Güemes Sur 154, Cafayate, 4427, Argentina
386-842–1328
Hotel Details
57 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?

Hotel del Antiguo Convento

$$ | Caseros 113, Salta, 4400, Argentina

This charming property in a former convent is run by a cheerful, attentive young staff; rooms are clean, bright, and well-priced. You can opt for a more private, apartment-style suite in the back with its own parrilla (barbecue). The hotel is on a lively street just a few blocks from many downtown attractions.

Pros

  • Staffers go out of their way to be helpful
  • Convenient location
  • Private, apartment-style suites available

Cons

  • Courtyard and pool are small
  • Some rooms are cramped
  • Rooms next to the courtyard are noisy
Caseros 113, Salta, 4400, Argentina
387-422–7267
Hotel Details
15 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?

Hotel Salta

$$ | Buenos Aires 1, Salta, 4400, Argentina

Designated as a National Historic Monument, the Salta occupies a handsome neocolonial building in the heart of the city; antique furniture and views of either the plaza or the surrounding mountains make every room attractive. You'll also find wooden balconies, blue-and-white tiling, sitting rooms on every floor, and a poolside bar-restaurant with an area for barbecues. Local master Ernesto Scotti painted the frescoes in the dining room.

Pros

  • Ideal location
  • Access to Salta Polo Club
  • Decent spa

Cons

  • Rooms facing the plaza can be noisy
  • Corridors can echo
  • Bathrooms are dated
Buenos Aires 1, Salta, 4400, Argentina
387-431–0740
Hotel Details
99 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?