8 Best Restaurants in The Southern Black Hills, South Dakota

We've compiled the best of the best in The Southern Black Hills - browse our top choices for the top things to see or do during your stay.

Buffalo Dreamer

$$$$
Co-located with Moccasin Springs Natural Mineral Spa, this restaurant is run by a local chef who trained in New York and is now attempting to bring high cuisine to the High Plains. The evolving menu promises food prepared "with love and deep intention," including dishes incorporating duck, salmon, grass-fed beef, and locally grown farm vegetables.
1829 Minnekahta Ave., Hot Springs, SD, 57747, USA
605-745--6100
Known For
  • Sophisticated food presentation
  • Elaborate desserts
  • Organic ingredients
Restaurant Details
Rate Includes: Closed Mon. and Tues.

Dockside Grill at Legion Lake Lodge

$
The restaurant at Legion Lake Lodge is an affordable, faster-food option. You can sit down by the floor-to-ceiling windows inside and enjoy an appetizer, salad, sandwich, or burger, or you can order from the picnic menu and take your food to go. There are numerous places to sit outside at the lodge and alongside Legion Lake.
12967 U.S. 16A, Custer, SD, 57730, USA
605-255--4521
Known For
  • Simple menu
  • Great views of the lake
  • Fried-pickle appetizer
Restaurant Details
Rate Includes: Closed mid-Oct.-late Apr.

Hat Creek Grill

$
For a convenient place to eat while you're checking out the local museum or the Mickelson Trail in Edgemont, try the Hat Creek Grill, which is right next door to both. This is a bar and grill, serving a basic selection of pub-style food at affordable prices for lunch and dinner.
521 Second Ave., Edgemont, SD, 57735, USA
605-662--5888
Known For
  • Laid-back atmosphere
  • Friendly local service
  • Burgers

Recommended Fodor's Video

Mornin' Sunshine Coffee House

$
Coffee, tea, smoothies, and quick choices for breakfast, lunch, and dinner are served in a small, historical, and architecturally interesting structure with exposed-stone interior walls. This friendly, locally owned establishment is a great place to stop on your way through Hot Springs, before or after your adventures in the area.

State Game Lodge Restaurant

$$
Located in the historic Game Lodge where President Calvin Coolidge and First Lady Grace Coolidge lived for nearly three months on a 1927 vacation, the Game Lodge restaurant has the biggest dining capacity of any restaurant in the park. There are multiple seating areas ranging from basic to elegant to outdoors (be sure to inquire about the options). Breakfast and lunch buffets are available, and the menu includes a wide range of salads, burgers, and entrees, with a focus on local ingredients, including bison meat.

Sylvan Lake Lodge Restaurant

$$
There's no better setting for dining in Custer State Park than the Sylvan Lake Lodge, which is perched on a hillside above beautiful Sylvan Lake. The dining area has vaulted ceilings, hardwood floors, large windows, and a stone veranda. Like other restaurants in the park, the menu includes a selection of salads, sandwiches, burgers, and locally inspired entrees featuring bison meat and other specialties.
24572 S.D. 87, Custer, SD, 57730, USA
605-574--2561-reservations recommended
Known For
  • Beautiful outdoor patio
  • Bison steak
  • Great location near Sylvan Lake and Needles Highway
Restaurant Details
Rate Includes: closed Nov.--Apr.

The Custer Wolf

$$
This bar and grill is in a renovated brick building with wood floors and a long, wooden bar, where the food is elevated a bit beyond standard pub fare. It's a great spot for a casual, affordable meal during a day of exploring the southern Black Hills.
607 Mt. Rushmore Rd., Custer, SD, 57730, USA
605-673--9653
Known For
  • Outdoor seating area
  • Surprising menu choices for a bar and grill, like the falafel burger
  • Selection of craft beer and wine

Woolly's Grill and Cellar

$$

As it's family-owned and -operated, it's no surprise that this place caters to families. Though it specializes in hand-cut steaks and prime rib, entrées on its modestly priced menu include helpings from the 18-foot salad bar. It's right next to the Mammoth Site.

1648 Hwy. 18 Bypass, Hot Springs, SD, 57747, USA
605-745–6414
Known For
  • Family-friendly
  • Great value for money
  • Convenient location
Restaurant Details
Rate Includes: Closed Sun.–Wed., Credit cards accepted