Fodor's Expert Review Albatross
$$ Fire Island American
This place is always packed, and for good reason. It is simple food done right, the kind of comfort food you can make at home—burgers, fresh seafood, pasta, steak—but better. The bar scores high marks with local beer on tap and freshly made cocktails. Stay on for late-night fun like live music and D.J.s, darts, and special party events, but, whatever you do, don't swing the lights.
320 Bay Walk
Fire Island, New York 11770, USA
Rate Includes: Closed mid-Oct.–early Apr.