2 Best Restaurants in Isla Mujeres, Mexico

This quietly sophisticated hotel restaurant has an open-air dining room connected to a deck overlooking the water. A northern Italian menu includes wonderful carpaccio di tonno alla Giorgio (thin slices of tuna with extra-virgin olive oil and lime juice), along with excellent pastas. Even the simplest dishes, such as angel-hair pasta in tomato sauce, are delicious. For something different, try the seafood risotto or costolette d'agnello al forno (lamb chops with a thyme infusion). The sunset views, of course, are spectacular. Tables are set with beautiful linens, china, and cutlery, making Casa Rolandi the most upscale and romantic restaurant on the island.

Named for its Italian chef Angelo Sanna, this charming bistro on Hidalgo's busy main strip is done up with soft lighting and a wood-fired oven. Come for the pizza, which has a thin crispy crust and is quite delicious. A large selection of Italian classics round out the menu. Try the famous wood-oven lasagna or mussels steamed in white wine. Angelo, who has lived and worked in Isla Mujeres for more than 20 years, is a hospitable host and a great source of local information. Angelo's stays open late and will deliver pizza if you're hungry at the end of a long night.