Don Rufino
The L-shaped bar fronting the main street is a popular expat and tourist hangout for its fresh food and tasty cocktails. Their grilled meats are local, organic, and are served with a side of polenta, lentils, and caramelized apples in a balsamic dressing. The tilapia in bacon-and-tomato sauce is also very good. Although this is one of the more upscale restaurants in the area, there's no need to dress up here: this is still La Fortuna, after all.