Fodor's Expert Review Beach House Restaurant at Cape Santa Maria

$$ North Long Island: Cape Santa Maria to Gray's Seafood

Upstairs in the Cape Santa Maria Beach House, guests enjoy sweeping vistas of the turquoise bay during the day and bobbing boat lights in the evening, along with the gentle sounds of the sea. Breakfast can be light with yogurt parfait and a seasonal fruit medley, or a splurge with banana bread French toast topped with caramelized plantains or Bahamian-style eggs Benedict. Sit under a colorful umbrella on the oceanfront deck for lunch with a pizza, wrap, or fancy salad. For dinner, delight in Caribbean coconut shrimp, fresh grouper, or Bahamian lobster tail—just don't miss the chocolate drizzled rum cake! Full bar service is available in the open-air, screened-in oceanfront bar, and a lively happy hour takes place every evening from 5 to 7, with complimentary conch fritters. This is one of the best spots on the island to grab a drink and watch the sunset.

Seafood Breakfast Lunch Dinner $$ Family

Quick Facts

Long Island  Bahamas


Known For:
  • Nightly happy hour with free conch fritters
  • Oceanfront bar
  • Banana bread French toast
Restaurant Details:
Rate Includes: Closed Sept. and Oct., Reservations essential, Meal plans available

What’s Nearby

Related Forum Posts