We visited Nevis in December and dined at Mangos, Bananas, Montpelier but our favorite was Coconut Grove. Gary greeted us personally, gave us a tour of his wine cellar and we truly enjoyed the food (and we are used great Manhattan restaurants).
We had lunch at Sunshine's - we must have missed something re everyone's raves. We got a plate with a piece of chicken and rice on it and were charged $20 each. Nothing special