I asked a similar question re: frequent flyer miles. Kind of where is it really expensive to fly. Basically I cant think of a place I havent wanted to see or travel too but I am not aware of where I MIGHT not be able to afford to fly myself. Africa is a biggie. New Zealand is too for me.
I live on the east coast so some Europe isnt that out of whack for me but Pacific Islands are-- I would also pick places like Hawaii and Pacific Islands.

OR- If i wanted to do Europe during high season.

What about Thailand? The people are friendly and its very reasonable to travel there.

I would go to South Africa. The country is beautiful and has something for everyone.

It kind of depends on what you want; beaches, beauty, culture, friendliness of people. For beauty and beaches I would say Bermuda and Maui. For culture and history I would say London(my favorite, love the theatre and history)then Paris. My husband who has traveled to 45 countries loves Thailand. He says it is a beautiful country, good food and the people are nice. We also both love Switzerland and had a wonderful stay in the beautiful city of Lucerne.

I'm with AAFrequentFlyer. The most important parts of the question are missing. Where are you now? If you live in Orlando, should we suggest you use them to fly to Miami?

And what airline is it? How can we suggest where to go when we don't know where this particular airline flys?

But with two more posts, you still don't seem to have grasped that concept.

I'd fly to Amsterdam, Paris or Munich, then spend three weeks seeing all three of those vicinities via train before reluctantly flying home.

Tahiti!

New Zealand hands down.

Okay, Tahiti as a stop over for a few days on the way to New Zealand!

This thread started and seemed to have ended last July!
Surely by now the OP has made here decision and taken her trip!
It is sad though, she never let us know what she decided.

I find that disrespectful.

A lot of the satisfaction of helping others here comes from knowing what their final decision was, or from reading the Trip Report.

It is also curious that she never revealed, in spite of pleas from those attempting to help her, where she lives, where she has been, what her interests are, or which airline provided the "free" tickets.

If you read her other posts since last July, you can infer that she lives in Denver and has visited Las Vegas, Orlando, Savannah and Williamsburg in the last 8 months. Maybe she used the "free" tickets for une fo those trips.

I like the Tahiti/New Zealand idea best!
That's what I would do if I ever find myself in the "2 tickets to anywhere" dilemma.