I like the Ice Cream Cafe in Orleans.

My top three:

1. Ben & Bill's Ice Cream Emporium (for great and unusual flavors--although I have yet to try the lobster ice cream!)
2. Sundae School (for their sundaes)
3. Four Seas (for good ice cream--but I think half the draw for a lot of people is how famous it is and all the famous people who have gone and still go there!)

HI klw25--finally a kindred soul who also likes Ben and Bill's in Falmouth Center!! Nothing against the other places b/c I don't go to that part of the Cape and don't know them, but B&B's is *really* good!! I have not yet tried the lobster flavor either; I guess I thought it was sort of a joke but maybe not...

Hi socialworker--I think Ben & Bill's is my favorite ice cream place anywhere. My brother-in-law, who has a house down the street from B&B's, has tried the lobster flavor and said it's kinda weird, but not bad. I think I'll stick with all their other yummy flavors. And that smell of chocolate when you walk in...mmmmhhhh! I can feel the 20 lbs. I've recently lost creeping back on just thinking about it!