Fodor's Travel Talk Forums

Fodor's Travel Talk Forums (https://www.fodors.com/community/)
-   Europe (https://www.fodors.com/community/europe/)
-   -   The running of the bulls, day 3 (https://www.fodors.com/community/europe/the-running-of-the-bulls-day-3-a-1057232/)

Robert2533 Jul 9th, 2015 06:38 PM

The running of the bulls, day 3
 
toros de Victoriano del Río - 09 jul 2015

http://www.rtve.es/alacarta/videos/s...aster/3203555/

cdnyul Jul 9th, 2015 07:07 PM

Didn't watch it, but found some images that give me great pleasure:

https://encrypted-tbn2.gstatic.com/i...1trCIr7-A_ypKQ

https://encrypted-tbn1.gstatic.com/i...Q1bCPDWZKcF3Ow

One of my favorites:
https://encrypted-tbn3.gstatic.com/i...lToh4MoK6MYvMq

Another "like"

https://encrypted-tbn2.gstatic.com/i...roIoz1cTDtiL-Q

I wish they would all end like that:

https://dionneshannette.files.wordpr...r-the-bull.jpg

Mark

alvamo Jul 10th, 2015 04:56 AM

Tradition which is famous thanks to Ernest Hemingway, it´s said more than 60% of people who run the San Fermin are foreigners (Americans) (24%),; -(Australians o kiwis) (11%). Only 6% from Pamplona.

Fra_Diavolo Jul 10th, 2015 05:39 AM

cdnyul --

"Didn't watch it, but found some images that give me great pleasure"

You are one sick person.

Robert2533 Jul 10th, 2015 07:02 AM

> it´s said more than 60% of people who run the San Fermin are foreigners (Americans) (24%),; -(Australians o kiwis) (11%). Only 6% from Pamplona.<

Where did you get those stats? 6% from Pamplona?

The vast majoriy of "runners" are from Navara, Basque country, Aragon, Madrid Catalunya and a few Brits and a hand full of Scotts.

There are a few thousand from Australia and New Zeland, but very free actually run the encierro. Most are too drunk to wake up early enough, and would be removed from the route by the Police if they did show up.

Americns runners make up about 6% to 8% of those who actually run on most days.

Every one else stands on the side, blocking the runners and causing pile ups.

Bedar Jul 10th, 2015 07:56 AM

Robert, surely you don't run anymore, right ? I know there are some who do forever, like Matt Carney, but please, not you. We need you here !

alvamo Jul 11th, 2015 05:14 AM

La procedencia de los conteos de personas proceden de este sistema, según nos indica el Ayuntamiento de Pamplona: "Las cifras de corredores se corresponden con los recuentos realizados sobre la base de las fotografías obtenidas a partir de las imágenes proporcionadas por la Policía Municipal, procedentes de cámaras situadas a lo largo del recorrido, minutos antes del cohete que anuncia el inicio del encierro."
El 56% de los corredores de los encierros de estos Sanfermines era extranjero:

-Estadounidenses (24%),
-Australianos o neozelandeses (11%)
-Británicos (4%),
-Franceses (2,5%)
-Sudamericanos (2,5%)

Según las encuestas realizadas por el Ayuntamiento 739 corredores (8% del total) del encierro eran de Pamplona, un 6% del resto de localidades de Navarra y un 30% españoles

http://www.sanfermin.com/index.php/e...o-de-sanfermin

PalenQ Jul 11th, 2015 07:31 AM

Go Bulls - 4 gorings today - those who abuse animals deserve what they get! Culling the herd IMO. and one bull refused to run, returning to the pen - first time in a long time - bulls getting smarter than the runner? But it all ends up as hamburger in the end.

Fra_Diavolo Jul 11th, 2015 07:48 AM

"Go Bulls - 4 gorings today - those who abuse animals deserve what they get!"

Another sicko.

PalenQ Jul 11th, 2015 08:38 AM

Another sicko.> Along with those who needlessly torment and abuse animals - they are your clarions of nice healthy folk? Catalonia outlawed bullfighting and soon all of Spain will as well.

Do you enjoy seeing animals abused - get your fun out of that - now that's sicko IMO.

Fra_Diavolo Jul 11th, 2015 12:34 PM

"Do you enjoy seeing animals abused"

No I do not. But I certainly don't take joy in seeing humans gored. I accept it as part of the ritual, but I do not enjoy it.

PalenQ Jul 11th, 2015 01:50 PM

Well I don't either really - I wish no one would be foolish enough to let themselves be gored - so I will temper my remarks but in a way the more gored the less this will continue is my rational.

And I guess traditions have a role - women were not allowed to run with the bulls until recently - the first ones being snatched off the gauntlet by macho men - again I can appreciate the tradition but I abhor needless animal abuse - one reason I am a vegetarian, besides health reasons. I will remark no more here on this - I can see both sides but some day it will all be a in the history books I hope. Meanwhile let the tradition continue and the local people decide what is right and wrong for them - again I hope they sooner or later become compassionate for animal abuse but we have states where dog fighting is legal - Lousiana I believe and many where they are tolerated so who is to speak.

Cheers.

Fra_Diavolo Jul 11th, 2015 02:02 PM

Cheers.

IMDonehere Jul 11th, 2015 07:26 PM

So you let others do your killing where you do not see it.

Here are just a few products you will have to stop using if you are ethical as you claim that come from cows and bulls:


Leathe.

Gel capsules often are made from bovine gelatin.

Bars of soap probably come from processed cow tallow fat. Asphalt roads may contain bovine fatty acids.

Cars and trucks may ply those roads on rubber tires made
with cow oils.

The explosive nitroglycerine is manufactured from glycerine, which is extracted from cow fat.

Cattle byproducts go into everything from photographic film to matchstick heads.
Consider:

Glue made from cow's blood is widely used to make plywood.

The cow's nasal septum is processed into chondroitin sulfate, an alternative medical treatment for arthritis.

Extracted protein from horns and hooves goes into foam for fire extinguishers.

The root gland of the tongue yields pregastric lipase, which is used in cheese production as a curdling agent.

Tissue from the small intestines becomes catgut for racket strings or surgical sutures.

Epinephrine from the adrenal gland can treat hay fever, asthma or other allergies, or stimulate the heart in the event of cardiac arrest.

Catalase, a liver enzyme, goes into contact lens care products.
_________________
Have a pleasant dinner.

pariswat Jul 11th, 2015 10:09 PM

I don't always agree with PalenQ, but I'm with him 100% here.

No one forces the fools to run. No one gives the bulls a choice.

BTW, this 'tradition' has just been removed from the cultural patrimonium.

cdnyul Jul 12th, 2015 01:58 AM

My grandparents were farmers and, as a child, I have seen chickens beheaded and pigs slaughtered. On occasion, my favourite rabbit would be our dinner.

What I have not seen is the animals that we ate being gratuitously abused.

Death was not the highlight of their life.


Mark

IMDonehere Jul 12th, 2015 07:10 AM

There is one apocryphal tale the The Encierro was first run by butchers, as an attempt to give the bulls a chance to seek their revenge.

PalenQ Jul 12th, 2015 08:04 AM

Go Bulls! (Chicago!)

Mactheknife60 Jul 12th, 2015 04:25 PM

PalenQ might be interested to know that bull running (correbous) still thrives in Catalonia. Bullfighting was banned not out of compassion for the animals but for political reasons i.e. the classic 'corrida' involving the torero in his 'suit of lights' is perceived by catalan separatists as a foreign imposition. Go to catalan villages or towns in the summer months and you'll find toros embolados (bulls with their horns tipped with rags dipped in tar and set on fire), ensogados (bulls trussed with rope and pulled around the village square) etc. A grotesque affair. Andalucia is bullfighting territory para excellence. Try going into a tasca in Carmona (Sevilla) and telling them that bullfighting's days are numbered. They'll either laugh in your face or run you out of town. It ain't that easy or that cut and dried.

Bedar Jul 12th, 2015 05:35 PM

Bravo and Ole, Mac !!

IMDonehere Jul 12th, 2015 09:42 PM

From EL PAIS in English

http://elpais.com/elpais/2015/07/06/...68_816212.html

ribeirasacra Jul 12th, 2015 10:39 PM

Here in Galicia, in the city of A Coruña there is a movement to stop the bull fighting.
https://www.facebook.com/galiciamell...uradas?fref=nf
Yes it is a FB page as they have yet to get a website working.

pariswat Jul 13th, 2015 12:05 AM

We should boycott Sevilla then.

And watch fights with chickens or dogs. Seems it is cultural in some countries.

alvamo Jul 13th, 2015 04:54 AM

I´m andalusian and for me is a shame all the corridas and the ferias, now in august we have 2 weeks of bullfighting in a row, 6 bulls are killed everyday in La Malagueta.

IMDonehere Jul 13th, 2015 05:17 AM

To be fair, Ribe, bullfighting was never popular in Galicia to begin with.

Bedar Jul 13th, 2015 05:34 AM

And, there's an independece movement in Galicia, too.

ribeirasacra Jul 13th, 2015 08:20 AM

It must have been quite popular for there to be several arenas in Galicia.
Independence has nothing to do with this action. Your comment is as if all of the Spaniards have no compassion for animals.

Going back to the events in Pamplona.
Not only is this event unsafe for bulls it is unsafe for women too.
http://www.elmundo.es/espana/2015/07...22b8b457a.html

PalenQ Jul 13th, 2015 09:44 AM

Sexist - too and Spain - a pseudo modern country - remains a backwater of sexism and sanctioned animal torture. Yet folks continue to hype this macho sadistic event where women are bullied to remain out of the action. Bravo Espagne!

kimhe Jul 13th, 2015 02:03 PM

<Spain - a pseudo modern country - remains a backwater of sexism and sanctioned animal torture>

Exceptionalism at its worse!

colins Jul 14th, 2015 03:26 AM

I'm just wondering how it works to participate in the bull run: Do you have to sign up previously? Where can you do that and is it necessary to do it in advance? Are there any requirements - except being drunk of course?

I'm just curious ...

Colins

kimhe Jul 14th, 2015 08:14 AM

<I'm just wondering how it works to participate in the bull run>

No signing up, just be within the enclosed route some half an hour before the run starts. My best memory from running is the tense "convivencia" spirit in the bars along the route in the minutes leading up to the run - when everybody drinks chocolate and feed eachother with churros or whatever - and then go out in the street with their rolled newspapers to sing the blessing "A San Fermin pedimos..." shortly before the bulls are launched just down the road.

Only idiots are drunk at this hour, and those who obviously pose a danger to others (the biggest problem when it comes to injuries is people stumbling on top of eachother, and then it can get nasty if a bull is right behind) will not be allowed into the route or shown away by the police: http://runningofthebulls.travel/la-p...-the-festival/

IMDonehere Jul 14th, 2015 10:17 AM

Sexist - too and Spain - a pseudo modern country - remains a backwater of sexism and sanctioned animal torture. Yet folks continue to hype this macho sadistic event where women are bullied to remain out of the action. Bravo Espagne!
_________

If you are going to insult a country, at least do it in their language. It is not Spanish. Not Catalan. Not Euskadi. Not Galego. That's right French.

As far as being backward and sexist
Decriminalized prostitution in 1995
Legalized gay marriage in 2005
The Mayors of Madrid and Barcelona are leftist women

And considering that Franco has been dead only for 40 years, I would say that Spain has made much progress than many nations.

Facts and logic the enemies of prejudice.

PalenQ Jul 14th, 2015 11:15 AM

IMD - you have shown me the light - yes my initial reaction was a hyperbole not proven out in facts - The Running of the Bulls remains sexist and endorses animal torture but not all of Spain which with your facts come to light sounds like Spain is as progressive in those realms as any European country.

Bravo!

PS - I were not writing in Spanish nor French - Bravo being also an Anglicism like used in our rodeos.

IMDonehere Jul 14th, 2015 11:21 AM

No you just ignoring all the other progressive accomplishments in Spain because it does not fit your prejudice and narrative. No matter what language you think you are using.

BTW, the etymology of bravo is Italian meaning bold.

pariswat Jul 14th, 2015 11:31 AM

Bravo Espagne is not French.

Thanks PQ for your clarification (and I mean it).

Generalities are always wrong of course.
Except when about Belgians : we're all beautiful, smart, well behaving, and ... so humble.

PalenQ Jul 14th, 2015 11:41 AM

Bravo Espagne is not French.>

I was subconciously using French for Spain in stead of Espagna - put an e instead of an a.

Bull-fighting like our rodeos and bull-riding is a macho sport appealing mainly to men I think - bullying (no pun intended) women off the Running of the Bulls course is just that - a macho perception of women as inferior in that regards - surprsing in a Spain so enlightened (seriously).

IMDonehere Jul 14th, 2015 11:50 AM

Bull fighting started in Crete about 2000 years ago and if makes you feel better there are depictions that women used to confront the bulls as well at that time.

Maybe the Spaniards will contradict me, but I think one reason why Spaniards cling to bull fighting is the homogenization that the EU imposes on other areas of the members' lives. It is identified with the Spanish and something that keeps them unique and does not need approval of a committee comprised of foreigners.

(PQ it is España in Castilian.)

PalenQ Jul 14th, 2015 11:59 AM

http://www.spanishdict.com/translate/(spain)

It's Espana in Spanish, right - I am a stamp collector!

Robert2533 Jul 15th, 2015 11:35 AM

Poor Matt Carney died years ago. I met him the first time in '85 as he paraded around with his entourage. He was a very runner when he was much younger.

Robert2533 Jul 15th, 2015 06:25 PM

Please note, there where officily 1,400,000,000 visivators to Pamplona for the fiesta, Allowing those without rooms to spend 300€ and those with rooms to part with an average 3,000€ `each, MECA will have collected somewhat around 310,000,000€


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 12:05 PM.