Fodor's Travel Talk Forums

Fodor's Travel Talk Forums (https://www.fodors.com/community/)
-   Europe (https://www.fodors.com/community/europe/)
-   -   A question for you Brits (https://www.fodors.com/community/europe/a-question-for-you-brits-687912/)

NeoPatrick Mar 15th, 2007 01:18 PM

I'll never forget years ago here in Naples, Florida when I was ushering at a community theatre production of Fiddler on the Roof, when two people stormed out of their seats through the lobby five minutes into the show. "We came here to get away from the Jews, we're not about to watch a play about them". I was in shock. Not so much by the anti-Semitism, which was fairly common here, but by the fact that anybody could be so stupid that they didn't know Fiddler on the Roof was about Jews!

Nikki Mar 15th, 2007 02:50 PM

But apparently in French we are all Anglo-Saxon together. No need for anti-Semitism or racism then.

GreenDragon Mar 15th, 2007 03:01 PM

You know, this is the progression.

Europeans call the Americans Yanks.

Americans call those that live in the north Yanks.

Northerners call those from New England Yanks.

New Englanders call those from Vermont Yanks.

I guess the Europeans think we are all from Vermont :)

Seriously, though - calling the folk from the British Isles Anglo-Saxon is ignoring the last 1000 years of history! Sure, there is a good chunk of Angle and Saxon blood in British veins today, but you've also got Celt, Roman, Norman(Viking), other Vikings, Briton, and Picts... as well as recent immigrations of Indian, Polish, Armenian, and all sorts of others...

Calling a country by a racial name just doesn't cut it, IMHO. Especially a country as culturally rich as, say, the UK or USA.

Stepping off my soapbox now :)

Oh, and if you think Scots don't mind being called Brits, say that in a Glasgow Pub one night. Go ahead.

ripit Mar 15th, 2007 03:13 PM

A certain subset of New Englanders around the greater Boston metro area would have a real problem with having anything about them being referred to as a "Yankee" ;)

Carrybean Mar 15th, 2007 03:17 PM

PalenQ:

<i>but i'm not sure if they're Welsh (a perjorative adjective by the way in the U.S.)</i>

Did you mean &quot;welch&quot; as in to &quot;welch on a bet?&quot;

fnarf999 Mar 15th, 2007 03:28 PM

I'm a bleedin' Yank barstid, and I unhappily weigh more than 1.4 million grains, though I stand but a mere four cubits high.

Carrybean Mar 15th, 2007 03:29 PM

Hmmm, maybe welch is a variant on welsh. Never knew it as a slam against the Welsh.

waring Mar 15th, 2007 03:37 PM

The 'Anglo' part refers to the English who being predominantly fair skinned and fair haired (thanks to the Vikings!)looked like angels.&quot;

Bluff! Anglo, Aenglish, English etc comes from the same root as angling. Means fisherman.

To start a tangent, I predict the dissolution of the UK in the not too distant future.

UK Parliament, Scottish Parliament, Welsh Assembly, Northern Irish Assembly.

Errr aren't we missing a Parliament for the majority of the Nation?

Tellingly, the 300th Anniversary of the Union of England and Scotland is passing unnoticed.

I heard tell tell that they were going to produce a commerative stamp, but nobody knew which side to spit on.

waring Mar 15th, 2007 03:38 PM

The 'Anglo' part refers to the English who being predominantly fair skinned and fair haired (thanks to the Vikings!)looked like angels.&quot;

Bluff! Anglo, Aenglish, English etc comes from the same root as angling. Means fisherman.

To start a tangent, I predict the dissolution of the UK in the not too distant future.

UK Parliament, Scottish Parliament, Welsh Assembly, Northern Irish Assembly.

Errr aren't we missing a Parliament for the majority of the Union?

Tellingly, the 300th Anniversary of the Union of England and Scotland is passing unnoticed.

I heard tell tell that they were going to produce a commerative stamp, but nobody knew which side to spit on.

Barbara Mar 15th, 2007 05:48 PM

&quot;Tellingly, the 300th Anniversary of the Union of England and Scotland is passing unnoticed&quot;

It didn't go unnoticed in Scotland.

My local newspaper had an interesting article about a book written by an Oxford geneticist, Stephen Oppenheimer &quot;The Origins of the British, A Genetic Detective Story&quot;.

Here is a tiny link to the story:

http://tinyurl.com/yve5mf


emmalee_71 Mar 15th, 2007 06:58 PM

Well it looks like you've got your replies so I will just add i'm 5'3 and leave it at that :-)
I don't mind being called a Brit and it's better than being called a soap dodger by an ozzie dude I used to know :-)))

LoveItaly Mar 15th, 2007 08:01 PM

Well this has been most interesting, lol! I certainly did not mean to rile anyone up. When I posted &quot;Brit&quot; I did mean those in Enland btw, not the other countries of the British Isles.

My question has been answered and for that I thank you.

And if you think Brit is an insult you should hear what we in the SF/Bay Area of California are sometimes called!

Josser Mar 16th, 2007 01:41 AM

I'm always amused by Aussie &quot;jokes&quot; about soap dodgers.
I think that it must be a sort of inverted cultural cringe.
It may be in response to our stereotype of a bloke in a sweaty singlet with corks round his hat.

Neil_Oz Mar 16th, 2007 03:21 AM

I'd never until now heard the term &quot;soap dodger&quot;, but a mate of mine, originally an English immigrant, is fond of exclaiming on entering the pub &quot;Jeez, I'm dry as a Pommy's bathmat!&quot;

The metric system was accepted pretty quickly and comprehensively here, but there are some few instances where the old Imperial units are just more convenient, and I think it will take a while to shake them off - mainly feet and inches for height, and we still pump the car tyres up to 32 psi, not some number of kilopascals.

Neil_Oz Mar 16th, 2007 03:28 AM

Americans might not like &quot;Yank&quot;, but at least it beats &quot;Septic&quot; (rhyming slang - septic tank = Yank), or the derivative &quot;Seppo&quot;.

WASP has always struck me as a silly term - I mean, how many black, brown or yellow Anglo-Saxon Protestants do you know? In Australia the term &quot;Anglo-Celtic&quot; is now more common I think. But given that latest DNA research it seems that distinctions between the Anglos and the Celts have no racial basis anyway, so it's all a bit pointless. I'm sure our Irish cousins won't have a problem with being called Brits.

Kate Mar 16th, 2007 03:33 AM

&quot;When I posted &quot;Brit&quot; I did mean those in Enland btw, not the other countries of the British Isles.&quot;

Then you should have said English! LOL, actually I don't care if you call me a Brit, I think it sounds quite affectionate. Our national music awards are called the Brit Awards and nobody seems a bit bothered about that. I find all the whinging from 'some' Scots, Welsh, English and Cornish for that matter really boring. Like it or not, we ARE all British.

Kate Mar 16th, 2007 03:35 AM

&quot;I'm sure our Irish cousins won't have a problem with being called Brits.&quot;

I think you'll find they'd have a HUGE problem with it, considering they actually AREN'T Brits (Brit being a British Citizen, not an inhabitant of the landmass called the British Isles).

ira Mar 16th, 2007 03:40 AM

Hi GH,

&gt;Much of England was settled by Danes and Germans until the Normans invaded in 1066, but the Normans were Vikings who'd settled in northern France.&lt;

A few thousand years before, they were all Celts.

((I))

chimani Mar 16th, 2007 03:43 AM

Oh, for Heaven's Sake - are you so ignorant that you don't know that the UK is part of the EU?

It wouldn't surprise me at all. Sort of parr for the course.

And that the EU is metric - ditto..

And Neil_oz is your yardstick?. You are obviously so ignorant that you don't know that Oz means Australia.

But none of that should be a surprise. Welcome to idiot land. Do you have any idea how much you are LOATHED.

Clearly the absolute best source for information about the UK would be the UK. Clearly you are too stupid to find out via Google.

If I had one wish right now it would be that Americans stayed at home. I find it hard sometimes to wonder why they would want to leave the good ole USA seeing as it is so totally without flaw. I mean - your way of life is so perfect that you have killed thousands in Iraq - cos they are not like you; not Christian; not greedy capitalists - whatever it is that you need them to be

I propose a ban on all Americans entering Europe until they see sense.

chartley Mar 16th, 2007 04:20 AM

As they say. &quot;You can tell a Brit, but not much&quot;


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 10:37 AM.