Jamaica x 1 (didn't love it)
Aruba x 4 (love it)
Provo, T&C x 3 (heaven)
Others....Cancun x 3 (used to like it; too built up now)
Cozumel x 1 (liked it)
Playa del Carmen x 4 (used to be our #1 place until we discovered the T&C Islands).
On our short list to try...Grand Cayman and Anguilla

Jamaica
DR
Haiti
PR incl. Vieques
USVIs
BVIs
St.Barts
St.Martin
St.Lucia
Barbuda
Antigua
Isla de Mujeres
Cozumel
Bay Islands
Los Roques
Margaritta
Aruba
Bonaire
Guadeloupe
Les Saintes
Barbados

CARIBTRAVELER: Ziggy is nowhere as popular as Damian Marley whose 'Jamrock' took island by storm and inspired many other 'ghetto protest'
singers. Commercial dancehall/US hip-hop may monopolize the radio/club playlists (Sean-Paul, Rhihanna,etc.) but Luciano is one of the enduring favorites on island.

Here's my little list.

Jamaica x2
St Lucia x2
St John #2 coming this November, notice a pattern here?
BVI's Virgin Gorda, Marina Cay, Jost Van Dyke, day trips
Grenadines, Union, Palm, Mayreau, Tobago Cays, day trip.

The island fever hit bad after St Lucia in 2003 and I can't seem to stop going there now. What an affliction!

Caribbean Islands:
Puerto Rico
Antiqua
Anguilla
St. Barts
St. Maarten/Martin
Saba
Statia
Tintamarre
Prickley Pear
Grenada
St. Lucia
Carriacou
Canouan
Mayreau
Bequia
St. Vincent
Tobago Cays
Palm Island
Young Island
Union Island
Trinidad
St. Kitts
Nevis
Barbados
Outside Caribbean:
Bermuda(loved it but has been many years)
Bahamas(once was enough)
Cancun(again once was enough)
Anastasia Island, St. Augustine FL
Cape Hatteras, North Carolina
Wheeling Island, Wheeling WVa
and last but not least Neville Island, Pittsburgh Pa. Those who know the area will appreciate my listing the last two :)

Haven't been to PA, but I love OBX! So, yes, I do appreciate the last two!!

With all of the travelers visiting so many places I have a question: Who has stayed at Parrot CAYE in T&C? How were the accommodations, food (it is isolated so one has to count on their restaurants), courtesy of staff and snorkel and diving outings they offer? We are planning on putting down a deposit next month for March or we cannot get in. All relevant first-hand feedback in past 12-18 months would be welcomed!
Thanks.

Tivertonhouse: How interesting. I had NO idea, so thank you very much for that info.

I'm impressed with everyone's lists. My short list is:
Turks and Caicos, Grace Bay
St Martin x 2
Aruba
Jamaica
Barbados

Maui
Cancun x 2

Just started visiting the island as of last year - we cruised twice so we were able to hit pretty many islands....

Puerto Rico - twice - one cruise, one land based vacation
St Thomas
St Lucia
Barbados
Antigua
St Martin
Grand Cayman
Belize

Not as many as some of you but here goes:

Jamiaca
St. Thomas
Vieques
Puerto Rico
Petit St. Vincent
Carriacou
Grenada
Union Island
Palm Island
Barbados
Aruba
Tobago Cays
Turks & Caicos: Provo, North Caicos
Exumas, Staniel Cay
Harbour Island
Eleuthera
St. Lucia
Grenada
Abacos: Green Turtle Cay, Great Guana Cay, Treasure Cay
Isla Mujeres
Cozumel
(Cancun, Tulum, Playa del Carmen, Akumal - just Caribbean water!)

And soo many more to go!!

Oh Dear !! I have a VERY short list.
1.Barbados
2.Margarita Island
3.Jamaica
I guess what kept it shorter was 3 trips to Costa Rica. I think this is indeed a fun idea, and it IS informative. I can see who is interested in the same islands as I am, and in future direct questions at them.

This would have been a really interesting post if everyone would have told their top 3 favorite islands. Particularly those who have ten or more. So how about it?

Top 3:
Jamaica
Los Roques
Les Saintes/Iles des Saintes

Bottom 3:
The DR
Aruba
USVIs

Can't someone comment on Parrot Caye in the T&C Islands??

Lots of travelers here!:)

1)St. Martin
2)Grand Caymans
3)Turks and Caicos (one of my favorites!)
I want to hit many more!

stankase: I have only passed Parrot Cay by boat. I have never stayed.
But just passing by, I can say "wow"

Parrot Cay is very high on my list for upcoming trips -- especially since American Express just added it to their 2007 list of hotels/resorts to use your points!

Top 3 - Tortola, Grenada, Turks and Caicos

Bottom 3 - St. Martin, Paradise Island, Puerto Rico

Antigua
Barbados
Bermuda

BVI's
Anegada
Jost Van Dyke
Norman Island
Peter Island
Tortola
Sandy Cay & Spit
Virgin Gorda

Guyana
Jamaica
Puerto Rico
St. Lucia
St. Maarten
Turks

USVI
St. Croix
St. John
St. Thomas

Top Three:
Peter Island
St John
St Lucia

Future wish List:
Bahamas-out islands
Grenadines

Top 3
St. Vincent and the Grenadines
Saba
St. Barts

Least favorite 3
Bahamas
Cancun
Trinidad