Fodor's Travel Talk Forums

Fodor's Travel Talk Forums (https://www.fodors.com/community/)
-   Caribbean Islands (https://www.fodors.com/community/caribbean-islands/)
-   -   How many islands have you visited? (https://www.fodors.com/community/caribbean-islands/how-many-islands-have-you-visited-630493/)

A_Traveller Jul 21st, 2006 01:38 PM

Top 3:
Virgin Gorda
Nevis
Anguilla

Bottom 3:
Cancun
Nassau
Dominican Republic

babygirl722 Jul 30th, 2006 06:15 AM

St Thomas
St Vincent
Bequia
Mustique
St Lucia
Grenada
St Maarten
Belize
Turks and Caicos
Jamaica
Grand Cayman
Tortola
Puerto Rico
Cancun
Martinique
St Croix
St Bart's
Bermuda

Wow! I've never realized how many beautiful islands I've been to. I think I may have missed a few!!

christiegr Jul 30th, 2006 06:50 AM

babygirl,
Which is your favorite island of the one's that you have visited?


Christie

jacketwatch Jul 30th, 2006 06:55 AM

The top 3:
Jamaica
Aruba
PR
The bottom 3:
DR but only for the SD/Boca Chica area
St Thomas. Rip off city IMHO
These are the only two islands on my list. A third place I would not return to is the Rosarito resort area in Mexico, in the northern Baja area.

caribqueen Jul 30th, 2006 05:41 PM

Wow, lots of people love the caribbean as much as me!

St. Kitts x4
Nevis x4
Grenada x2

Nassau x3
Grand Bahama Island
White Cay
Gun Cay
Egg Cay
Puerto Rico (too many times to count)
St. Maarten
St. Thomas x2
St. John x2
Barbados
Martinique
Roatan x2
Jamaica x6
Cozumel x6
Cancun x4
Grand Cayman x3
Carriacou
Tobago Cays
Mustique
Bequia x2
Palm Island
St. Vincent x2
St. Lucia
Antigua
Mayreau
Curacao
Isla Mujeres

Top three listed at the top, bottom three:

Antigua
St. Lucia
Nassau

Still so many places to go! Great thread, thanks!

Tuxedocat Jul 30th, 2006 07:05 PM

I feel so inadequate. :( Maybe we bought our place in St. John too quickly and now we don't go anywhere else. And some of these aren't even very big:
St. John, St. Thomas, Tortola, Jost Van Dyke, Marina Cay, Peter Island, Virgin Gorda, Norman Island, Bermuda, Puerto Rico and Hawaii in transit. Ummh, Martha's Vineyard, Machinoc (sp) Island in Lake Michigan, Thousand Islands in New York and Taiwan are also islands.
We are looking into the Galapagos for next year. I still have dreams...

gregg1226 Aug 15th, 2006 06:39 PM

Travelling is so much fun!

I have visited:

St. Thomas
St. Maarten
St. John
Bahamas
St. Lucia
St. Kitts
Nevis
Curacao (as of 8/26/06)
Maui (as of 5/26/07)

St. John is, by far, our favorite island. It's like heaven on earth! Although Nevis was gorgeous...amazing! On the flipside...St. Lucia was VERY disappointing for us--just not ready for American tourists yet.

gregg1226 Aug 15th, 2006 06:42 PM

I counted islands I actually VISITED and STAYED ON.

I didn't count places like Puerto Rico, Barbados, Antigua...placed where we had airport layovers or switched planes.

If I included those...I think my list would be about 45 long!

JAGIRL Aug 15th, 2006 07:46 PM

<font color="green">If I included those...I think my list would be about 45 long!</font>

gregg : LOL! I think that's why I've not been to more Caribbean islands! :))

The thought of taking so much time to <b><i>get there</i></b>...why I might as well go to Europe instead! :D

jray Aug 17th, 2006 11:03 AM

I have been to all English speaking island due to my days a youth cricketer. Not yet been to Martinique, Culebra and maybe 5 other smaller island. Never been on a cruise either.

JAGIRL Sep 20th, 2006 09:26 AM

For SAnparis:;)

Reminding us all that there <font color="fuchsia"><i>really</i></font> are other islands out there besides St. John!

((#)) B-)

caribtraveler Sep 20th, 2006 03:48 PM

May this post hit 100 replies...
:-D

JAGIRL Sep 20th, 2006 05:56 PM

Wow...didn't realise it was at 93 now. ;)


o.k....o.k. so this post was just a cheap ploy to push it on its way :))

kenita Sep 20th, 2006 06:45 PM

mykonos-Greece
Crete-Greece
Santorini-Greece
Beliz
Kauai
Maui

RT1 Sep 21st, 2006 12:07 PM

Barbados
Antigua
St. Lucia
Grand Cayman
Bahamas
Puerto Rico
Aruba
St. Thomas

keefatniffy Sep 23rd, 2006 01:30 AM

Antigua x 2
Barbados x 3
Turks &amp; Caicos
Grenada
Tobago
Tortola
JVD
Carriacou
Puerto Rico
Canouan
Union x 2
Palm x 2
Bequia
Mustique
Dom Rep
Mayreau x 2
Tobago Keys x 2
Montserrat
Would go back to them all except for the Dom Rep.

Odin Sep 23rd, 2006 09:55 AM

Puerto Rico
Anguilla
St Martin
St Barts
Martinique
Guadeloupe
Barbados
Dominica
St Vincent
St Lucia
Grenada
Antigua
Bahamas
Bermuda
Aruba
Bonaire
Curacao

On my wish list:-
Saba
St Eustatius
Grenadines
BVI
Caymans
T&amp;C
Nevis &amp; St Kitts
Monserrat
Barbuda
Small islands off Guadeloupe eg Les Saintes/Marie Galante

Islands not on my wish list:-
DR
JA

Island I don't care to visit again:
Puerto Rico




fox99836 Sep 23rd, 2006 12:14 PM

Let's see...
Dominican Republic
Turks and Caicos
Puerto Rico
Vieques
Roatan, Honduras
Grand Cayman
Cayman Brac
Tortola
Jost Van Dyke

We are planning a trip to Grenada and Tobago - any recommendations? How does Tobago compare to Tortola or Jost Van Dyke? Thanks for any help out there!

ejcrowe Sep 23rd, 2006 12:41 PM

Fox, I think you'll love Grenada. Have you checked out the www.grenadatravelforum.com yet? I can't help you on the Tobago issues, but I do recall seeing a few posts asking about Tobago vis a vis the BVI on www.traveltalkonline.com on the Southern Caribbean forum.

My wish list:
Out Islands of Bahamas
Anguilla
Culebra
Bonaire
Mayreau
Canouan
Martinique
Saba
Statia

My wish list to visit again:
Nevis
Jamaica
Grenada

JAGIRL, we're almost there!

blamona Sep 23rd, 2006 01:03 PM

Not Caribbean, but wanted to be 100!!!!! 8-)
Other islands I've been too (non Caribbean)
Tahiti/BoraBora/Moorea/Manihi/Rangiora
Fiji
Maldives (hopped around so lots of them)
Seychelles
Phuket
Bali
Cooks (including Autuitaki, where they have &quot;survivor&quot;)
Capri
Azores
New Zealand
Australia
Gibraltar
:-)

ejcrowe Sep 23rd, 2006 01:48 PM

blamona, you're my hero! Not only did you post #100 on this thread, but you've visited some of the most far-flung and exotic places that are on my wish list.

JAGIRL Sep 23rd, 2006 07:48 PM

<font color="white">wow!! 100 posts!!</font>((8)) \:D/ \:D/((8))

<font color="white"> way to go guys!! </font>=D&gt; :D =D&gt;


Carola22 Oct 15th, 2006 02:24 AM

Aruba
Bonaire
Curacao
St. Maarten / St. Martin
Anguilla
Nevis
Saba (day trip)
St. Barths (day trip)

and going to:
Barbados
St. Vincent
Bequia

nason Oct 16th, 2006 07:20 PM



Antigua
Aruba
Bahamas Nassau
Bahamas Grand Bahama Island
Cancun
Dominican (Puerto Plata)
Jamaica
St.Martin
St.Kitts
Turks and Caicos

Day trips on cruise: Tortolla, Guadeloupe, St. Johns,

twigsbuddy Oct 17th, 2006 04:47 AM

Too few: St.Croix, St.Lucia, St.Thomas, Bermuda, Puerto Rico, St.John, beautiful, wonderful Jamacia, and just ready to leave for Barbados with my family for a nice ten day stay this time.

almesq Oct 17th, 2006 09:53 AM

Aruba
Anguilla
Barbados
St. Thomas
Puerto Rico
St. Maarten
Nevis
(And just made reservations for next March for Parrot Cay in T&amp;C--can't wait!)

And, not Caribbean, but close:
Bahamas (Nassua, Paradise Island)
Bermuda

And not an island, but on the Caribbean:
Riviera Maya, Playa Del Carmen Mexico

anonxx Oct 17th, 2006 04:56 PM

Just to mix it up a bit, in addition to going to many of the Caribbean Islands mentioned, we've been to the islands off Alaska, Stanton Island, England, Venice, Japan, etc.

StanKase Oct 17th, 2006 05:15 PM

I really participate in this forum to get and give information of &quot;real&quot; value to fellow travelers.
So, other than &quot;one-up&quot; or for passing idle time what value do 100+ folks receive from responding to this question.
I have asked about Andros Island, Bahamas and 3 resorts on the island and received 1 informative answer of a traveler who was there in the last 12 months.I asked on Lonely Planet and received 3 travelerrs who provided valuable information.
So, help me understand, please?

Carola22 Oct 17th, 2006 11:16 PM

I do find this forum very helpful - I asked a question here about Barbados and St. Vincent a few weeks ago, and immediately received a number of very useful and informative replies. Conversely, I try to respond whenever someone asks a question about an island or resort that I know. Responding to this question (about how many islands one has visited) is just fun, because you can check for yourself which islands you did visit. Also, as you can tell from this thread, and in that sense it IS useful! there aren't that many people on this forum who visited Andros island, which is probably why you didn't get many replies.

Sweege Oct 18th, 2006 08:11 AM

Since we're just having fun; in no particular order. All included at least one overnight; some visited multiple times:

Aruba
Curacao
St. Thomas
St. John
St. Croix
Virgin Gorda (honeymoon)
St. Kitts
Nevis
Puerto Rico
Barbados
Antigua
Grand Cayman
Martinique
Turks and Caicos (Provo)
Anegada
George Dog Island (day sail; ended up naming my 1st dog George after it.)
St. Martin/St. Maarten (both sides)
Anguilla

Close enough; was there:
Grand Bahama
Nassau
Cancun

Plus, stranded with wife on a dock in Tortola on first night of honeymoon b/c of a connection snafu, but that's a different story (and, yes, we're still happily married).

StanKase Oct 18th, 2006 08:23 AM

Fun is GOOD! I just thought forum was originally designed to ask specific questions

I acknowledge Andros, Bahamas, while the largest of the Bahamian Islands, only has 5-6 resorts and maybe 10 little motel/hotels.
But with folks visiting Culebra, Bequi, Harbour Island and Cooper Island, etc., it just seemed surprising to me.
Have FUN.


bluewater63 Oct 18th, 2006 08:28 AM

I am posting in this thread because this is where to people in the know seem to be.

We're going to be returning to San Juan from a cruise on Sat. 11/18. We have rented a Jeep and plan to leave early on Sunday morning, drive through El Yunque, then drive to Fajardo in the afternoon and fly to Vieques for the night. Any suggestions on which airline to use from Fajardo to Vieques, where to stay in Vieques, and which biobay tour to do? I hear that Vieques is a beautiful Island, but we are basically only going for one night to do the biobay tour. After our cruise, we will probably be beached out. Any comments would be appreciated.

bluewater63 Oct 18th, 2006 08:30 AM

Any suggestions on day excursions would also be greatly appreciated. Our cruise will be stopping at:
St. Thomas
St. Maarten
Antiqua
St. Lucia
Barbados

Thanks!

SAnParis Oct 18th, 2006 12:00 PM

Only a few - Puerto Rico, Antigua, St. Maarten &amp; Montserrat. Unless I can count all the Keys or maybe Kelley's Island in Lake Erie...I'm stuck @ 4 for now, &amp; I'll not being adding to the list my next trip in February either.

zuni17 Oct 21st, 2006 08:03 PM

I don't think I can remember all of them but I'll try:

Aruba
Jamaica x 4
St. Lucia x 2
St. Martin/St. Maarten
St. Croix
St. Thomas
Grand Cayman
Puerto Rico
Dominican Republic
Martinique
Guadeloupe

Not in the Caribbean:

Nassau
Turks &amp; Caicos
Bermuda
Kauai x 4
Maui
The Big Island
Oahu
Isla Mujueres (? spelling)
Cozumel

That's all I can think of. Probably missed some. I have so many more to add to that list when I get to them!!!


TnTWalter Oct 25th, 2006 02:09 PM

This is fun.

Nassau &amp; Paradise Island, Bahamas
Grand Cayman
Aruba
St. Thomas
Provo, T&amp;C
Cancun &amp; Playa Del Carmen Mexico (although not islands)
Trish

shillmac Oct 25th, 2006 04:41 PM

It IS fun, and something I'd never thought much about. For us, it's:

Hawaii, (Oahu and Maui)
Bahamas (Nassau, Grand Bahama Island,
Paradise Island)
Cozumel (does that count?!) :)
Puerto Rico
Vieques
St. Thomas
St. John (moored overnight and swam)
Tortola
Virgin Gorda

Those in my dreams--too numerous to mention!

JAGIRL, thanks for the fun post!

Bluewater63, for best results, start a new thread with your question. It fell between the cracks on this thread!

If you're not &quot;bent&quot; on travel to Vieques, I'd suggest a drive down to Ponce, over to La Parquera (where there is also a bioluminesent bay), a visit to San German, founded in 1507, up to the surf mecca of Rincon, over to Moca, where there is a museum dedicated to handmade mundillo lace (fascinating to watch)--and back to San Juan area along the north shore.

My daughter and I recently did this tour of the western side and it was SUCH fun. Less American influence, more typical Puerto Rican. We spent 2 nights, but it could be done in one. We also did some hiking in Guanica dry forest, west of Ponce. LOVED the Ponce Hilton resort. The Castillo Serrillos (sp?) in Ponce is fascinating as well--home of the Serrilles family of Don Q rum fame.

shillmac Oct 25th, 2006 06:22 PM

Oops, forgot Bocas del Toro, off the east coast of Panama--loved it there. Visit 3 of the islands in the archapeligo. My list is looking more respectable all the time! LOL!

clubconte Oct 26th, 2006 09:03 AM

Been to:
Martinique
St. Lucia
St. Martin (3xs)
Bahamas
Cozumel
Cayman Islands
St. Thomas
Aruba
Dominican Republic
Puerto Rico
Love St. Martin - Very friendly (Dutch side) great deals to go
Most favorite (&amp; still trying to get back there) was St. Lucia

cruzan19 Nov 2nd, 2006 01:07 PM

St.Croix(my home!)
St.john
St.Thomas(worst island in caribbean)
vieques(wonderful glowing bays)
nevis( old time charm. colorful wooden shacks and beautiful plantlife!)
montserrat(very very green and lush)
st.barths(o if i had money to live there!)
puerto rico(more cars than people. awful on east side of island).
St.Lucia(gorgeous)
dominican republic(pretty but very poor)


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 04:26 PM.