Fodor's Travel Talk Forums

Fodor's Travel Talk Forums (https://www.fodors.com/community/)
-   Asia (https://www.fodors.com/community/asia/)
-   -   Japan - Yet another itinerary (https://www.fodors.com/community/asia/japan-yet-another-itinerary-850192/)

Boberg Jul 22nd, 2010 09:25 AM

Another flight would add another $500 - that's another big chunk! Barb

hawaiiantraveler Jul 22nd, 2010 09:32 AM

Almost sure the customs & immigrations luggage check would be done in NRT but KimJapan would know for sure. If they are arriving at 15:00 they have plenty of time. BTW the flights are on ANA(Ibex).

Kim should be up in 5 hours or so :)

Aloha!

hawaiiantraveler Jul 22nd, 2010 09:35 AM

if you qualify for the discounted airfare your price would be 13,000 yen per ticket.....approx $139.00 US in today exchange.

hawaiiantraveler Jul 22nd, 2010 09:38 AM

boberg,What airline are you flying in on? It doesn't matter if its an award ticket, all that matters is the airline.

Aloha!

Therese Jul 22nd, 2010 09:40 AM

Barb, the fare that HT's getting on Kayak may not be what you'd pay. Japanese airlines offer deals similar to JR Pass packages for foreigners. I've never done it myself, but if you're going very long distances in Japan it's a reasonable option.

In the end you have to decide whether it's worth the extra money. On this particular itinerary, for me, it wouldn't be: my pockets aren't that deep and I like train travel (especially the super reliable version of train travel that Japan offers) and either way you still get into Kanazawa that evening (or the next AM if you stop in Shinegawa and get up and catch an early train).

Therese Jul 22nd, 2010 09:42 AM

More simultaneous posting.

HT, maybe we should just phone Kim. I'm sure she wouldn't mind...

KimJapan Jul 22nd, 2010 11:39 AM

Whether from Narita or Haneda, I pay ¥10,000 for adding a connecting domestic flight to an international flight on ANA. If you connect in Narita, you go through immigration and a security chech there, and briefly have your bags....pitch them up, go through customs and drop them again. Easy.

If you connect using Haneda same thing except you take your bags with you on the bus. It's dead easy, too, but takes more time. Unless you arrive at Narita mid-day when there is no connection for a long time then it's hardly worth the time and energy. It I'd still easier than making 2 train changes to get to Kanazawa though.

KimJapan Jul 22nd, 2010 11:56 AM

Also, significant discounts are offered on the ANA website. You can book 60 days out but not before unless you book your international ticket there too. Right now flight 60 days out are showing at ¥9,700 super tabiwari fare - meaning huge discount fare. Usual discount is ¥16,009 and is just about always available. I don't think many, if any, pay full fare, which is all you will see on sites like kayak or expedia.

hawaiiantraveler Jul 22nd, 2010 12:08 PM

For what its worth, I have done the discount air ticket several times. Not the tabiwari fare(wow so cheap)that Kim is talking about but the Star Alliance Japan Airpass which is explained in the link in my post above. You just have a travel agent here issue the ticket and you pay from home before you go so you have tickets in hand when you leave home. Price currently is 11,000 yen or $127.00 US for those one way tickets but you have to be traveling on a Star Alliance carrier to qualify. But I would try the the Tabiwari fare that Kim suggest first as it is cheaper. I would try buying on the ANA website soon or call the 800 number listed for help.

Aloha!

Boberg Jul 23rd, 2010 05:56 AM

You are all gonna walk away from me when I ask you this BUT how unreasonable does a quote from INSIDEJAPAN sound for 19 nights, limo to airport initial, including the railpass, lodging in the upper 3/4 area - rail pass, others transport , 4 all day tours including the traditional Japan stay with hot springs bath in room, meals, etc. at Ichinoyu Honkan - two people $9916.00 - ?? Barb

hawaiiantraveler Jul 23rd, 2010 07:03 AM

I can't believe we fell for this troll. I our haste to help I never did the precursory check and I wish I had,lol.
Did you have fun fooling us Barb? Were we gullible enough for you?

Are you going to leave your three children home by themselves this trip to Japan? Should be a fun trip to Japan a week after you and the kids come back from 3 weeks in Italy? Don't your children start school in Sept like ever other child in the states? The Euro board caught on to you faster than we did. They are not as nice there are they,lol?

hawaiiantraveler Jul 23rd, 2010 07:06 AM

Oh....and yes pay the travel agent his $9916.00 today. Better than any deal I can think of especially since you have your plane tickets already. This is your lucky day!

hawaiiantraveler Jul 23rd, 2010 07:10 AM

alright so their not your childrem

Therese Jul 23rd, 2010 07:17 AM

Update me, please, HT, as I've missed whatever transpired on the Europe board and don't see anything too obviously out of whack in what OP's got posted there, though of course it may have been deleted by now.

It did cross my mind more than once that this was a troll, but in the end it doesn't bother me, as somebody may still see the info provided by Fodorites and benefit from it. Unless of course Fodor's decides to delete the thread entirely, which I think would be unfortunate.

Boberg Jul 23rd, 2010 09:58 AM

I apologize to any of you whom think I am anything other than an individual and husband trying to sort this trip out. I have just NOT had any luck securing hotels for the time frames - yesterday I found out there was a fall fesitval and that is why I could not get anything in Takayama which was still leaving me in Kyoto on another weekend. I am beside myself and yes do have flights so I just thought I'd explore another option and simply wanted to know if this was in the ballpark. I never meant to imply anything but I just can't seem to put it together on my own this time around. I don't know what you all mean by a "troll" etc but I am just a losto individual and I keep thank each of you for all your time and effort. I did not know it was inappropriate to ask for advice on a company. Sincerely, B arb

Therese Jul 23rd, 2010 10:12 AM

It's fine to ask about a company and even recommend a company, but it's not okay to pretend to be somebody without a financial stake in a commercial enterprise and then recommend it. Technically this individual would be shill, not a troll. A troll simply delights in upsetting people (usually by introducing controversial topics) or putting them to some effort needlessly. So the time that HT and I and KimJapan and others put into advising you on your itinerary would be time that we could have spent doing something else.

It can be hard to distinguish a troll/shill from somebody who is a little bit clueless (and it's perfectly fine to be a little bit clueless), and of course trolls know this and take advantage of it, typically presenting themselves as clueless when they aren't.

The more of a posting history that you've got at a particular site, the less likely that you'll be mistaken for a troll. On the other hand, repeated trolling by the same individual, even if using different screen names, eventually gets easier to recognize as the writing styles tend to give it away.

I'm still waiting to hear from HT, or maybe Fodor's will fill me in via email.

DonTopaz Jul 23rd, 2010 10:35 AM

I'm equally lost. Info, pls.

Mara Jul 23rd, 2010 10:46 AM

I am following this thread as well as I do on most Japan ones for ideas for future trips. I checked the Europe Board and OP asked about a possible trip to Italy in September back in June when he/she first joined fodors as far as I can figure out. Maybe OP decided to do Japan instead of Italy..... I think I've seen that tour operator mentioned on the tripadvisor Japan forums - maybe OP is checking there as well.....

Boberg Jul 23rd, 2010 11:31 AM

Yes to all of you I did inquire about Tuscany back a while ago (my apologizes) but I could not secure seats with our mileage from UA that is to expire in December. I am sorry for changing my trip plans. Is there any other personal history you might all want before I apologize once again. Social security number, etc. Also the thread about leaving my children at home, etc. was nice. Thanks!!! Sincerely Barb

Therese Jul 23rd, 2010 12:05 PM

Barb, have you ever seen the cartoon that shows a couple of dogs sitting at computer, and the one says to the other "On the internet nobody knows you're a schnauzer"? Many of us who've been involved in on-line forums have been burned by trolls and shills, and so we're sensitized to the possibility. Even long-time posters to Fodor's have occasionally been accused (incorrectly) of shilling---it's part of the price you pay for the advice.

Anyway, assuming you still want assistance, what dates are you looking at for Takayama? Hida Hanasato no Yu Takayama Ouan (on Japanican, USD 145/night for two people) looks pretty great to me. Free internet, right next to Takayama station (which is also where the bus arrives), breakfast included, rooftop open air onsen... I see availability for 10/12 through 10/17---does your Takayama stay coincide with any of those dates?

Mara Jul 23rd, 2010 12:37 PM

I stayed in the Rickshaw Inn this spring - they are pretty popular but it can't hurt to check....
http://www.rickshawinn.com/index.html

KimJapan Jul 23rd, 2010 12:53 PM

I think the price of $9,900 is high.
2 x JR Pass 14 days $1000
2 x 2 airport transfers $150.00
19 nights hotel very generous $300/night (too much for their 3-4 star) $6000
4 random tours generous $100/pax $800

Total $8000

If I understand correctly, that company just books you and you show up and go it all on your own. Steep booking fee.

Ichinoyu Honkan isn't special imo but it is inexpensive. There are hundreds of other choices in Hakone. Caters to tour groups and foreign guests.

You can do hotels for much cheaper. Many business hotels are as nice or nicer than what is called a 3-4 star hotel. The 3-4 star hotels often cater to groups and are in need of updating.

Many hotels do not accept reservations more than 60 or 90 days in advance, especially business hotels.

Boberg Jul 23rd, 2010 07:09 PM

Thank you - and yes I still want help Terese. I also thought the price was high but seemed like his itinerary really gave me some insight. My husband really wants to stay in Tokyo our arrival and not head directly out - so then I had planned leaving the 9th Shinjuku to Matsumoto one night - bus on the 10th to Takayama BUT that is festival w/e and no hotels until Monday - so would you think its doable to go Matsumoto - Kanazawa THEN to Takyama - Kyoto - I know from Hyp it is more hours on the train but ? ? ?

I hope MS HAWAII also sees my apology for whatever I have done wrong in regards to not being to secure free mileage tickets to Italy - and my children will be left alone (24 years old!!!)

Moving my daughter at college this w/e so I won't be bothering you for two days. Barb

Boberg Jul 23rd, 2010 08:00 PM

Hawaii traveler - just curious where you got the idea I was traveling with any one other than my husband. Some how I am getting the idea there is more confusion than my being thought of being what you all refer to as a "troll" I only have one grown daughter and have NEVER mentioned traveling with children Barb

Boberg Jul 24th, 2010 03:59 AM

Looks like the RickShaw Inn is available in Takayama on the w/e - with Festival Rates of course but won't need advice on switching those days around - thanks. But I'm sure I'll be back with transportation questions. Thanks again to all Barb

Orcas Jul 24th, 2010 05:49 PM

Barb, We stayed at the Granvia in Kyoto last week. It is priced higher for the wkend festival and price went down during the week. We had limited choices, as well, as it was a big festival wkend. The location is excellent, right at the train station. The subway and busses also start there. We spent very little time in our room. Also, being in Kyoto station, there are many, many other restaurants right there at the top floor of the two dept stores, Istaven and the Cube. By evening, we were tired and were glad to have choices right in the station, where we didn't have to get back out in the heat. Kyoto station is phenomenal. You'd have to see it to believe it. Suffice it to say, ultra-modern and fantastic.

When I first saw the room, I was disappointed, as we were paying enough that I expected more. But, it turned out to be just fine and we were extremely glad for the excellent location. It was very hot and it was great to have public transit and so many amenities at our doorstep.

The service was pleasant and having the concierge was great. We paid extra for the breakfast plan. They give you coupons and you can chose between 3 of the restaurants. One serves buffet style, including Japanese and western and we went there most of the time as DH is not a Japanese foodie.

We spent our first night in Tokyo as we arrived in the evening. We stayed near Shinegawa station (on the way to Kyoto) at the Strings Intercontinental. We got an internet rate. The room was small but really nice. The people were wonderful. The concierge (or whoever he was - he was Irish, I think) gave us the best Kyoto info we received our whole trip. You can take the Narita Express and hoof it to the Strings, which is practically in the same bldg (one bldg over).

We only stayed one other night in Tokyo, our last night. We stayed at the Hotel Niwa, which is a transfer and stop away from Tokyo Station and a 2 block walk from the subway. It was truly a beautiful, elegant and simple hotel. Loved it. It was in a university area with lots of restaurants on the next street - a relatively quiet area. But, it's not in the center of the action, so it depends what you are looking for. We only did one thing in Tokyo, due to limited time. We went to the Akihabara area, or "electric city," as it was nearby. It was truly amazing and worth a visit.

It all works out somehow. Will you be there when the leaves are changing? That would be quite beautiful.

sassy_cat Jul 25th, 2010 10:05 AM

Thanks for all the useful information.
I need to do more background research but planning a trip for April 2011 (only have 10-11 days)

Boberg Jul 25th, 2010 05:23 PM

Thanks for the continuing information. Yes the festivals sure put a kink in making reservations. We will be there for the color change - appears to go on quite a long time depending on where you are. Hitting the festival on the last day in Takayama but managed to secure the room. Appreciate all the sincere help. Barb

Therese Jul 25th, 2010 05:33 PM

Looking forward to your trip report, Barb.

Boberg Jul 25th, 2010 06:56 PM

OK hotels are starting to fall into place UNTIL Kyoto again!!! Am finding 3 star only range of almot $200 per night - none look too good - any experience with the following? Kyoto Station Hotel, Kyoto Tower, Hotel Keihan or the Kyoto Dai-ni - the Granvia is over $1,500 for the nights I need - which by the way are Oct. 15 for 4 nights. As usual your comments are appreciated. Barb

Orcas Jul 25th, 2010 07:41 PM

The hotel tax is 15.5% and the dollar is weak. We paid an average of $342/night at the Granvia for a king including breakfast and tax, and we mixed up the high and low time. We could not find space in the less expensive places due to the festival, so we bit the bullet. (I didn't start looking until April, either, which was late for the July festival.)

The Kyoto Tower is directly across the street from the Granvia, another great location. Read up in several guidebooks, on this website,or at tripadvisor to check up on the places. Everything is clean in Japan and people are very gracious, so I think most places are fine to stay in. If you can get somewhere cheaper that has good reviews, go for it.

Therese Jul 25th, 2010 07:49 PM

There are three Toyoko Inns showing availabilty for your dates, all at or under USD100 (including free internet and light Japanese breakfast). This chain is many people's preferred option.

I'd probably go for the Citadines ( that I mentioned previously, I think): brand new property, rooms very large by Japanese standards.

KimJapan Jul 25th, 2010 08:09 PM

I really have found that most 3 star hotels are no nicer (and often are not as nice as) good business hotels...but the price is higher. Toyoko Inns are popular. Also look at APA Gion and Kyoto Mystays. Don't lock yourself into staying at the station area. The sights are so spread out it hardly matters where you stay.

Boberg Jul 25th, 2010 08:36 PM

Therese, I go up to see if you answered (12:30AM here, ha) and of course you did. WHERE did you find the Tokyo Inn availability at? JapanIcan is not showing one and I see no direct site for them thanks, Barb

KimJapan Jul 25th, 2010 08:45 PM

Mystays Kyoto offers a corner view twin room with breakfast for 2 people for 4 nights starting October 15 for ¥54,900. Room is 22 m2 with two twin beds 122 cm wide each.

Superior room with breakfast is ¥58,900 and 30 m2.

Standard twin with breakfast is ¥42,900 and is 19 m2.

This price is the total price for the four nights including tax.

http://www.mystays.jp/kyotoshijo/index.html Japanese only. A friend stayed here not too long ago and said it was very nice. The price is certainly right.

KimJapan Jul 25th, 2010 08:48 PM

It's ToyOko Inn. http://www.toyoko-inn.com/eng/

Boberg Jul 25th, 2010 08:57 PM

Kim Japan - maybe I've lost it completely since it's 1 AM but that is the site I was on and it's totally in Japanese and I was not seeing why to switch to English??

KimJapan Jul 25th, 2010 09:19 PM

Mystays site is in Japanese. You can use google translate or similar to translate if you wish. Because its in Japanese is why I quoted the price options for you. You could fax a reservation request perhaps.

Therese Jul 26th, 2010 02:20 AM

As Kim points out, it's Toyoko Inn, not Tokyo Inn, and it's a chain of business hotels. Because you are now within the three month limit for non-member guests, you can book directly with hotel or through Japanican.

Citadines can also be booked at either Japanican or the citadines web site. These rooms are 25 sq meters and feature a full kitchen, so you can have breakfast without even bothering to put on your clothes. Very well reviewed at Trip Advisor.

Therese Jul 26th, 2010 02:35 AM

A note about star ratings: they don't necessarily mean what you might think they do. Some countries have official government-run ratings systems, some don't. But generally speaking none of them take into account things like cleanliness or friendliness, bit intead work from a formula that takes into account things like on-site restaurants and business centers and swimming pools and so forth.

The higher the star rating the more you'll pay for the room, and the more likely you'll be to pay extra for web access and breakfast and so forth, so when I'm looking for rooms I tend to look for properties based on reviews, not stars. The only time I ever take star rankings into account is when I'm bidding blind on Priceline (not an option for your trip, Barb) and even then I'm very careful to compare bidding histories. A four star hotel can easily be much worse value than a one or two star.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 02:29 AM.