Fodor's Expert Review Top of the Bay

$$$ Fire Island American

True, the tuna sashimi appetizer is $23, but what else could you expect for romantic high-end dining in paradise—and with live music and a drag-queen bartender, this swanky place is anything but boring. It's one of the more upscale places on Fire Island, with a history dating back to its inception in the 1970s as the Island Queen. Dishes might include seared scallops with raisin gartique, Lobster pot pie, or the bistro burger. You can dine inside or out at this harborside eatery.

American Intimate Dinner $$$ LGBT

Quick Facts

1 Dock Walk
Fire Island, New York  11782, USA


Restaurant Details:
Rate Includes: Closed Sept.–May. No lunch, Credit cards accepted

What’s Nearby