Fodor's Expert Review Sweet Tomato's

$$ Shelter Island Italian

Editor's Note: This location is no longer in operation.

A favorite with locals and visitors, this converted storefront outfitted with a patio and tables draws you with its smell of Italian cooking. High ceilings and a comfortable bar await inside. Daily specials complement the menu's pasta, seafood, and fish dishes, many featuring local products. Enjoy a lively late-night bar scene.

Italian Casual Lunch Dinner $$

Quick Facts

15 Grand Ave.
Shelter Island Heights, New York  11965, USA

631-749–4114

What’s Nearby