Fodor's Expert Review Milk and Sugar Café

$$ Bay Shore Eclectic

Editor's Note: This location is no longer in operation.

This sweet yet sophisticated café-restaurant on Main Street feels like dining at your favorite aunt's house. The menu ranges from an ahi tuna salad and a BLT sandwich to a rack of lamb entree. It also features incredibly decadent desserts and some of the best coffee around. It is also a favorite place for Sunday brunch, plus weekly live jazz, psychic nights, and wine dinners.

Eclectic Casual Breakfast Lunch Dinner Brunch $$

Quick Facts

49 W. Main St.
Bay Shore, New York  11706, USA


Restaurant Details:
Rate Includes: No lunch or dinner Sun.

What’s Nearby