Fodor's Expert Review Meetinghouse Creek Inn
Editor's Note: This location is no longer in operation.
The seafood at this waterside restaurant, 4 miles east of Riverhead, is a big draw—it all comes from local sources—but the kitchen also turns out good steaks and pasta dishes, and in addition to the regular menu there's a daily $23 prix-fixe dinner. There's a patio for open-air dining, or you can enjoy a beverage at the outdoor tiki bar. If you're arriving by boat, docking is fee. Reservations are suggested.
177 Meeting House Creek Rd.
Aquebogue, New York 11931, USA