Fodor's Expert Review Claws Seafood Market

$ Sayville Seafood

Some of the freshest natural, sustainable seafood in the area is to be found at this cute little red-and-white New England–style seafood market and restaurant with outdoors-only seating. It has arguably the best lobster roll around, along with market grilled fish, smoked fish, a raw bar, and some decent burgers. Have a hankering for frog’s legs? You can get them here. Live acoustic music sets the tone for a laid-back, relaxed meal. Expect a wait, however. The staff is helpful and friendly, but it sometimes takes a bit of time to prepare your food. Beer and wine are available while you wait.

Seafood Casual Lunch Dinner $

Quick Facts

20 Main St.
Sayville, New York  11796, USA


Restaurant Details:
Rate Includes: Market open year-round, but seating area closed around late Oct.–early Apr., depending on weather

What’s Nearby