Nantucket Restaurants

Company of the Cauldron

  • 5 India St. Map It
  • Nantucket Town
  • American

Published 07/14/2016

Fodor's Review

In this tiny dining room, a sconce-lighted haven of architectural salvage, chef-owner All Kovalencik issues only one prix-fixe menu per evening (Monday's, priced slightly higher, is lobster-centric). Fans gladly forgo choice, when the chef's is invariably so dead-on. Rundowns of the weekly roster are available online, and a typically tantalizing lineup might span rosemary-skewered shrimp with Tuscan melon, beef Wellington made with wild mushroom duxelle, and a combo of chocolate ganache and chocolate gelato (don't hold back!). While cherry-picking the menu for recurrent faves, cognoscenti also tend to reserve tables for nights when Mary Keller plays her celestial harp.

Restaurant Information


5 India St., Nantucket Town, Massachusetts, 02554, USA

Map It



Restaurant Details:

  • Closed mid-Dec.–mid-May. No lunch
  • Reservations essential

Published 07/14/2016


Book A Trip



  • CARS

Map View

What's Nearby

  • Restaurants
  • Sights
  • Hotels

See all restaurants in Nantucket