Fodor's Expert Review Sarabeth's

$$ Old Town American

Named for the award-winning jam-maker and pastry chef Sarabeth Levine, who runs the kitchen, it naturally is proclaimed for its all-morning, all-afternoon breakfast, best enjoyed in the picket-fenced front yard of this circa-1870 synagogue. Lemon ricotta pancakes, pumpkin waffles, omelets, and homemade jams make the meal. Lunch offerings range from a griddled smoked mozzarella sandwich to poached salmon "Cobb" salad. Start dinner with the signature velvety cream of tomato soup, or roasted red beets and Gorgonzola salad. The daily special augments the short entrée listing that includes meat loaf, green-chili-pepper macaroni with three cheeses, and grilled mahi with tomatillo sauce. In the mood for dessert? The warm orange-apricot bread pudding takes its cues from Sarabeth's most popular flavor of jam.

American Intimate Breakfast Lunch Dinner Brunch $$

Quick Facts

530 Simonton St.
Key West, Florida  33040, USA


Known For:
  • Breakfast and brunch specialties, including famous lemon-ricotta pancakes
  • Daily specials
  • Good desserts
Restaurant Details:
Rate Includes: Closed Mon. Christmas through Easter, and Tues.

What’s Nearby