Fodor's Expert Review Michaels Restaurant

$$$$ Old Town American

White tablecloths, subdued lighting, and romantic music give Michaels the feel of an urban eatery, while garden seating reminds you that you are in the Keys. Chef-owner Michael Wilson flies in prime rib, cowboy steaks, and rib eyes from Allen Brothers in Chicago, which has supplied top-ranked steak houses for more than a century. Also on the menu is a melt-in-your-mouth snapper meunière in a lemon brown butter, Kobe-and-tenderloin meat loaf, and a variety of made-to-order fondue dishes (try the pesto pot, spiked with hot pepper and basil). To lighten up, smaller portions of many of the favorites are available until 7:30, Sunday through Thursday. The Hemingway (mojito-style) and the Third Degree (raspberry vodka and white crème de cacao) top the cocktail menu.

American Romantic Intimate Dinner $$$$

Quick Facts

532 Margaret St.
Key West, Florida  33040, USA


Known For:
  • Elegant, romantic atmosphere
  • Small plates available until 7:30 Sunday–Thursday
  • Steak and seafood, which dominate the menu
Restaurant Details:
Rate Includes: No lunch

What’s Nearby