Fodor's Expert Review Inn at Creek Street & New York Hotel

More than a century old, this quaint hotel is adjacent to the inviting New York Café, which serves three meals a day. The delightfully old-school hotel rooms are on the small side, but they have character in spades: one-of-a-kind antique furnishings, cozy quilts on the queen beds, and tile floors with pedestal sinks in the bathrooms. The property also maintains a handful of vacation rentals around the corner, including three two-level suites along Creek Street that feature kitchenettes, jetted tubs, loft bedrooms with spiral staircases, and decks overlooking the water. Suite amenities at other locations vary, so check with the hotel.