Fodor's Expert Review Barony House

20 Mayfield Gardens, Edinburgh, EH9 2BZ, Scotland See on Map

It's hard to imagine a couple better suited for running a B&B than Aussies Paul and Susan. Paul is the infectiously enthusiastic welcome committee, who also bakes the bread for breakfast, while Susan is the artist, hand-painting border patterns below the cornices in some of the bedrooms and designing the beautifully bright fabric headboards. Their talents have paid off: Barony House is a gem.

YOU SHOULD KNOW The only downside to this lovely B&B is its slightly out-of-the-way location, in a residential area with a clutch of other B&Bs. But it's close to Arthur's Seat and still only a 20-minute bus ride into the city center.


There are nine rooms in total, all lovely and full of small historic and decorative touches, many of which are Susan's own work. Some overlook the garden, others, Arthur's Seat. Guests are welcomed with Tunnocks teacakes and dry sherry. Two of the rooms are in the servants' quarters (the basement of the house next door) with their own entrance, a lounge, and access to the garden.

Susan's artistic talents run in the family: she's related to the critic and artist John Ruskin.


Bathrooms are white and modern, and spotlessly clean. Some are bigger than others.


In the old townhouse style of a lot of B&Bs in Edinburgh, the hallway is traditional, and the welcome from Paul and Susan is second-to-none.


It's all about the breakfast, served buffet-style in a pleasant breakfast room.


There's an honesty bar with local gins and whiskies, and two lounges for guests to relax in.


Getting Around

The B&B is not in the center of Edinburgh but it is in a well-connected residential area that's still only 20 minutes by bus from the action. Walking it is not out-of-the-question either; it's only around 35 minutes on foot.


Delhi Diner (1-minute walk), right by the B&B, is a great Indian restaurant. Or Aizle (16-minute walk) offers inventive Scottish tasting menus.


South Pour (9-minute walk) is a friendly local serving craft beers. Or The Royal Dick (14-minute walk), by The Meadows in the Summerhall arts complex, is a kooky former veterinary hospital now serving very locally brewed gin indeed (there's a distillery and brewery on site) and other toothsome choices.


Funkiness, friendliness, and fun, all in a package that's both affordable and comfortable. Susan and Paul are originally Australia, but say when they came to Edinburgh they fell in love with the history and the beauty so much they never managed to leave.That was a lucky day for Edinburgh's B&B scene.



Phones: 0131-662-9938

What’s Nearby

People also liked

The Dunstane Houses

$$$ | 4 West Coates & 5 Hampton Terrace, Haymarket Edinburgh, EH12 5JQ, Scotland

A gem of a boutique hotel in a city strangely not overly blessed in th... Read More

Hotel Ceildh-Donia

$$ | 14-16 Marchhall Crescent, Edinburgh, Midlothian, EH16 5HL, Scotland

More like a small hotel than a B&B, the Ceilidh-Donia is a welcomi... Read More

Radisson Blu Edinburgh

$$ | 80 High Street, The Royal Mile, EH1 1TH, Edinburgh, Scotland

Right on the Royal Mile, in an old stone building that's a little remi... Read More

14 Hart Street

$$ | 14 Hart Street, Edinburgh, EH1 3RN, Scotland

This excellent B&B is in a quiet, picturesque Georgian neighborhoo... Read More

The Principal

$$$ | 19-21 George Street, Edinburgh, EH2 2PB, Scotland

A historic hotel on elegant George Street, the Principal Edinburgh is... Read More

Inn on the Mile

$$ | 82 High Street, The Royal Mile, Edinburgh, EH1 1LL, Scotland

The clue's in the name: this is a genial pub/inn, right on Edinburgh's... Read More