Fodor's Expert Review Polly's at the Pier
With an emphasis on fresh ingredients, this very casual spot right on the waterfront serves delicious fare. The gourmet grilled-cheese sandwich comes with your choice of three cheeses as well as delicious additions like basil, fresh Bosc pears, and avocado. Salads are a specialty, and many are made with local Bibb lettuce and organic mixed greens.
3 Strand St.
Frederiksted, Saint Croix 00841, U.S. Virgin Islands