Paula, thank you for the kind words.
As for A Light in the Piazza, we (family and friends who've seen it) feel that it's a "chick thing," as it seems women enjoy it far more than the men.
Please, no sexist accusations....please!

No need to defend your preferences. Theatre is a matter of taste, and thank goodness for that- otherwise, everything on Broadway would be exactly the same. It is perfectly okay to dislike a show, as long as you respect that others may enjoy it. We are lucky that there is a true variety of theatrical offerings out there right now.

In terms of recommending shows, I think we all try to get a sense of the personal taste and preferences of the poster, and recommend something appropriate (whether we personally enjoyed it or not). The more specific, the better, in my opinion!

With tickets costing as much as they do, you want to try to find the best possible fit so you can have an enjoyable evening (or afternoon!).

Just my two cents :)

Woman in White by Andrew Lloyd Webber.........

Nicely said TarheelsInNj. I just purchased our tickets to the Producers based on some helpful information from Broadway savy Fodorites including HowardR. Looking forward to an entertaining evening at the theater.

Me? Wicked.

You? Don't know.

Just read the above comments. I HATED Titanic on Broadway. In my opinion, it tanked.

My friend, who lives on the UWS, said someone told her how it ended and ruined it for her.

Seriously, it was so awful that all four of us fought sleep. But, some loved it.

Cherokee, if you think you are going to see Wicked, buy the soundtrack CD. I'm on my second one - I wore out the first one listening to my favorite two tracks. The music is great! The story is fun. Even read the book - and am looking forward to reading the sequel...AND to seeing the touring company when it comes to my town.

My friend and I just saw "Dirty Rotten Scoundrels" and Wicked in NYC in September. I would definitely recommend both. Wicked is in the Gershwin Theatre which is amazing and the quintessential NY theatre experience. The girl who played Glinda was truly talented. Dirty Rotten Scoundrels with John Lithgow and Nortbert Leo Butz was a scream! It was great fun, and what made it amazing was the obvious joy these two had in being in this production together. By the way, Norbert Leo Butz was in the original cast of "Wicked" as Fiyero and is featured in the soundtrack. It depends on what you are in the mood for. "Wicked" is a grand production that will leave you with your mouth hanging open. "Dirty Rotten Scoundrels" will make you laugh - alot. You'll leave the theatre in a great mood. May I recommend Patsy's on 51st for a post-theatre dinner? It's an incredible Italian restaurant - walking distance from the Gershwin, and a very short cab ride away from the other theatre.