Fodor's Travel Talk Forums

Fodor's Travel Talk Forums (https://www.fodors.com/community/)
-   United States (https://www.fodors.com/community/united-states/)
-   -   TIMESHARE uour opinion on buying timeshare (https://www.fodors.com/community/united-states/timeshare-uour-opinion-on-buying-timeshare-358201/)

keepmovingon May 10th, 2008 08:27 PM

TIMESHARE uour opinion on buying timeshare
 
I just wanted to know what are your views on the whole concept of owning timeshare, if yoy brought it how happy you are with it, if you usually get your week that you requested etc.

Pegontheroad May 10th, 2008 08:42 PM

No, no, no no! Don't do it! I bought into Royal Aloha and stayed at their units on Oahu, and Kona, and in Acapulco. I believe that was in the 80's.

When I was considering buying in, the units looked quite elegant, but they soon began to look shabby. The Kona unit didn't have air conditioning, and it got pretty hot. The maids would totally clean out the cupboards, so one always had to buy every bit of food you'd need, including salt and pepper. A minor point, but pretty irritating.

I later rented condos in which cupboards always contained non-perishable food left by other guests. That was convenient.

The units were not the prime apartments in the building. They really didn't measure up to other places that I rented, and the management fee went up every year. Finally, after I'd finished making the payments, the management assessed a fee equal to 25% of what I'd paid in the first place because the units needed updating. I decided that it wasn't worth that assessment, and I just let my membership lapse. I assume they sold my week to some other unsuspecting sucker.

It was also not easy to get the week I wanted, and some locations had to be booked a year ahead of time.

By the time I paid for the week and the ever-escalating management fee, I don't think I saved much money, if any.


travelbuff May 10th, 2008 09:26 PM

You also have to be careful because if there is a change in ownership the Times Shares somehow can be cancelled. It happened in the Bahamas not long ago. I almost bought and glad I didn't.

Mambo_ May 10th, 2008 09:45 PM

My sister is a big believer in the time share concept. She and her husband have happily owned one at The Ridge at Tahoe for many years. And they recently bought into another one owned by a larger company so they can trade places around the world.

They use their time at The Ridge, and they are given very good rates if they want to rent a unit other than their own. They can even extend that owner's rate to others, for last-minute booking. My daughter has taken advantage of it many times, renting very nice one bedroom condos at The Ridge for only about $129/night, during ski season no less.

My husband and I, on the other hand, took the other route and bought a second home many years ago. It's always available, of course, but it's pretty expensive when you add up insurance, maintenance, heating, taxes, etc. It appreciated tremendously, of course, but I'm still not sure it's better to own than to time-share. There's something to be said for both options, if you know what you're doing.

With the real estate market so low now, it is a good time to buy, if you can afford it.
:)>-

nukesafe May 10th, 2008 09:47 PM

Just do the numbers. When you figure in all of the costs, I think you will find it to be a really bum deal. For the price you pay for that week, you can rent a really nice place of your choice almost anyplace in the world, IME.

:-(


tekwriter May 10th, 2008 09:53 PM

Do you really want to be locked into the same location, same time of year for your vacation? Sure, you can trade to another location, or another time of year, but that costs over and above your timeshare payment. There's no guarantee for the quality of the unit you'll get elsewhere. The fees will pile up, so it will end up costing more than you're expecting. What if your income changes and you can't afford it any longer? If you're not locked into a timeshare, you can just forgo your vacation and save money; with a timeshare, it's the same as a mortgage - you're obligated to pay, no matter what. Keep that in mind. It's cheaper to pay as you go... really!

nukesafe May 10th, 2008 09:58 PM

Yep, Techwriter has it exactly right, IMHO. The other part of the equation is that the salesman will lure you with talk about your "equity"

Right --

Just try and sell it and see what sort of "equity" you can get out of it.

Been there, done that --

:-(

Rhea58 May 10th, 2008 11:44 PM

I agree w/last 2 posters..my husband & I had looked into it &
decided the cons did not outweigh the pros.
Also do not want to be locked into same place every year.
Thankfully, we didn't as now, as a widow, I do not want the hassle & prefer B&B;s, boutique hotels, etc.
which serve my interests better.

BarryK May 11th, 2008 02:21 AM

As big a rip-off as credit card interest rates. One thing to consider is there really is no secondary market for timeshares, so once you own it, you can't sell it.

gail May 11th, 2008 04:01 AM

If you go to a timeshare talk - especially the kind linked to free hotel/trip, beware. Leave your checkbook at home and bring someone with you.

My husband and I firmly believe that timeshares are a ripoff for us. We would never buy one. That said, we have been to 2 timeshare sales talks (to get free hotel, etc) and both sat there ready to buy 6 of them immediately - these sales people are amazingly persuasive and good at what they do.

ChristieP May 11th, 2008 06:39 AM

www.tug2.net has lots of timeshare info, including resales, etc. DO NOT BUY FROM THE DEVELOPER! You can almost always find a timeshare cheaper on the secondary market. DH and I have owned in Las Vegas for 5 years now. We have always managed to rent out our unit in the years that we haven't used it. And since we bought it very cheap by resale, we save a LOT compared to staying in a hotel there!

WannabeinaMontserrat May 11th, 2008 06:47 AM

Quite possibly the biggest rip-off/scam on the planet. Please compare the cost of the time share w/any other similar vacation. A) you won't save any $$ - B) you won't make any $$ - C) they are like herpes - once you get one, you'll have it for life.

socialworker May 11th, 2008 07:55 AM

As in all things, this is not a one-size-fits-all question or answer. We have 2 weeks in a small place on Cape Cod that directly overlooks the ocean. My husband *wants* 2 weeks on Cape Cod every year and the cost/availability of other ocean-front property is either prohibitive or non-existent.

However, this is very different than owning a week or weeks in a place that is rife with hundreds of large complexes all in the same area.

Many people are unhappy with their timeshares and this makes resales very cheap. If you want to buy one, explore eBay for bargains, but educate yourself on the properties and areas b/c you, IMO, have to be willing to use the time you actually buy and not count on it for the trade potential.

Pegontheroad May 11th, 2008 08:41 AM

I forgot to say that though I listed with to companies to try to sell, there was never a nibble, which was why I decided just to let it go.

keepmovingon May 11th, 2008 02:19 PM

great responses, thanks for all your input, I think it is just as youall said, a lot can go wrong, and some of them are like a big scam though some people believe in them,,,,
anymore suggestions

iceeu2 May 11th, 2008 03:58 PM

In addition to tug2.net that ChristiP recommended, go to timeshareforums.com.

Absolutely listen to the experts at these 2 websites before you purchase any timeshare.

TaxFreeTravel May 11th, 2008 06:08 PM

Don't tie yourself down to buying a timeshare, there's a lot of red tape when you want to switch options, etc. We knew that and almost bought one anyway - the sales people are SO persuasive and at the time they actually seemed to make sense. You can rent gorgeous unused time shares weeks for as low as $329...we are booking one for the fall.

xrae May 11th, 2008 09:16 PM

Never ever ever ever purchase from a developer. ALWAYS purchase on the secondary market if you decide it is for you. You can tell if a timeshare salesperson is lying: his/her lips are moving. If you purchase a timeshare mainly to trade, be prepared to be very flexible to weeks/locations when you're trading.

NeoPatrick May 12th, 2008 05:00 AM

"You can tell if a timeshare salesperson is lying: his/her lips are moving."

I love that --- so true!

keepmovingon May 13th, 2008 07:03 PM

yea, their lips are moving alright - to scam us into buying timeshare... from what you told me i would keep away
thank you


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 10:50 AM.