Fodor's Travel Talk Forums

Fodor's Travel Talk Forums (https://www.fodors.com/community/)
-   United States (https://www.fodors.com/community/united-states/)
-   -   NYC Survival Kit? (https://www.fodors.com/community/united-states/nyc-survival-kit-1653598/)

thursdaysd May 21st, 2018 05:40 AM

NYC Survival Kit?
 
The New York Times has a piece today on what you should carry when out and about in NYC:

https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/18/n...vival-kit.html

Only item I've carried when visiting is the water bottle, although I also have a lightweight folding umbrella and a shopping bag that scrunches down to nothing. Might add antiseptic wipes instead of the baby wipes as I'm on medication that suppresses the immune system, and the fan is a good idea.

What do you carry?

1IntrepidTraveler May 21st, 2018 07:50 AM

I carry about $50 in cash, in $5 denominations, for buying dirty water hot dogs and chicken over rice. Also, a pocketful of napkins or paper towels. You never know when you're going to need to wipe something off.

The spare metrocard is a good idea.

RoamsAround May 21st, 2018 08:56 AM

Totally “dumb” article. You don’t need an article to tell you what you need - just use common sense.

When traveling in NYC just carry the same stuff you carry when visiting any other major city in the world.

HappyTrvlr May 21st, 2018 06:06 PM

Small denomination bills for tips.

marvelousmouse May 21st, 2018 08:07 PM

Sigh, can’t view. I shall have to use my imagination on the stupidity given that most travel articles are either product placement or obvious.

My bag: antiseptic wipes, ibuprofen, reusable water bottle, wallet. Kindle if I’m dining out in the evening. So...pretty much what I’d carry at home.

why an extra metro card? I mean if you lose the first one, you can replace it at any metro station.

thursdaysd May 21st, 2018 08:14 PM

@mm - from the article:

“I carry an extra preloaded MetroCard, always. When the A train is pulling into Hoyt-Schermerhorn and I’m cursing because I knew my balance was low and didn’t refill my card the night before, that extra prefilled card keeps me from a 20 minute wait or Uber fare.”

marvelousmouse May 22nd, 2018 12:23 AM


Originally Posted by thursdaysd (Post 16733646)
@mm - from the article:

“I carry an extra preloaded MetroCard, always. When the A train is pulling into Hoyt-Schermerhorn and I’m cursing because I knew my balance was low and didn’t refill my card the night before, that extra prefilled card keeps me from a 20 minute wait or Uber fare.”

i suppose that would make sense if you had an appointment to make. Thanks for the enlightenment lol.

dfrostnh May 22nd, 2018 02:21 AM


Originally Posted by RoamsAround (Post 16733349)
Totally “dumb” article. You don’t need an article to tell you what you need - just use common sense.

When traveling in NYC just carry the same stuff you carry when visiting any other major city in the world.

I don't live near any major city so I thought the article was worth a read. It reminded me that in the long ago days all "ladies" used to carry a fold up plastic rain bonnet which I doubt are available anymore. I was surprised not to see some kind of city map since none of us had smart phones the last time we visited NYC and got off the subway at the wrong stop. Name of street was correct but maybe more than a mile from where we should have gotten off. However, in Chicago, a friendly security guard was more helpful with advice about how to get to Navy Pier than friend's smart phone. Never would have thought of ear plugs and probably wouldn't use them since I think it's important to keep eyes and ears open.

ekscrunchy May 22nd, 2018 04:10 AM

Don't play tennis and don't tote layer cakes to picnics, but dental floss is still a good idea, not only in NYC!

Although I do not always carry them, I think gloves are a good idea to prevent germs from subway poles and all else one might touch.. I even hesitate to shut off that annoying taxi music cause I don't want to touch the screen..imagine how often those are cleaned! Just some cheap cotton gloves would be really good to tote along in a purse.

The scrunched up bag for toting purchases is a must. And I always carry some kind of handkerchief aka cotton napkin liberated from an airline meal. Helps me when I get hot. And can use to open bathroom doors in restaurants or museums.

I have never liked umbrellas; difficult to carry around, easy to lose. Wear a jacket with a hood. Just never thought they were worth the trouble.

marvelousmouse May 22nd, 2018 04:13 AM


Originally Posted by dfrostnh (Post 16733723)
. It reminded me that in the long ago days all "ladies" used to carry a fold up plastic rain bonnet which I doubt are available any more.


You would, hilariously, be wrong about that. my mother is hooked on Vermont country store catalogue, but they also sell them other places online. My favorite:
The Bonnit (I mean, I don’t own one. I just like to fantasize about having hair worth protecting from the rain).

Re: cell phone: Nyt publishes some of the most absurd articles I’ve seen, and usually the writers assume everyone has a smartphone.

thursdaysd May 22nd, 2018 06:03 AM

@eks - good idea about the gloves. Now I am on medication that suppresses my immune system I should do that. I don't have a problem with the umbrella as my day pack has two outside pockets - one for water and one for the umbrella. Although it is small enough to fit inside. A hood may keep your hair dry but doesn't do much for the rest of you or anything you are carrying.

WhereAreWe May 22nd, 2018 06:30 AM


Originally Posted by marvelousmouse (Post 16733642)
Sigh, can’t view. I shall have to use my imagination on the stupidity given that most travel articles are either product placement or obvious..

It's not even a travel article. They asked NYC residents (not travelers) what their top 10 list is based on past experience. A tape measure made the list - I stopped reading when I saw that.

dfrostnh May 22nd, 2018 07:03 AM


Originally Posted by WhereAreWe (Post 16733832)
It's not even a travel article. They asked NYC residents (not travelers) what their top 10 list is based on past experience. A tape measure made the list - I stopped reading when I saw that.

well, obviously you never worried about whether the big turkey would fit in your oven. My maternal grandmother was a draftswoman and always measured things.

Thanks for the VT Country Store info. Now I don't have to wonder how a dear family friend has preserved her rain bonnets for decades. She used to teach English and never married. She wear TWO rainhats. One is the plastic bonnit type and the other is the old fisherman's type, I was scarred for life, however, because my cheapskate father bought me a boy's raincoat and hat (it covered the whole head and had a visor) because it was cheaper than the girl's version which came with the cute fisherman's style hat. Young fashionistas wore their hats backwards like a large brimmed bonnet. Dear family friend also never goes without proper hose even to a family barbecue.

marvelousmouse May 22nd, 2018 07:09 AM


Originally Posted by WhereAreWe (Post 16733832)
It's not even a travel article. They asked NYC residents (not travelers) what their top 10 list is based on past experience. A tape measure made the list - I stopped reading when I saw that.

ever so handy should you decide to impulse shop at ikea...

Or buying a new stylish collar for your puppy

um, and measuring your foot long hot dog to see if it’s actually foot long?

I dunno. I use my tape measure a lot but not when I’m out roaming around!

Vttraveler May 22nd, 2018 07:30 AM

I'm a lot older than most of the people interviewed and know quite a few people who have had heart attacks. I always carry chewable aspirin. Also Benadryl in case of an allergic reaction.

Odin May 22nd, 2018 07:44 AM

The only thing I need in NY is plenty of money (surprising amount of cash is needed for the numerous cash only places), anti-bac wipes/gel, travel insurance with medical cover, metrocard, Uber app, NY Ferry app and enough room in my suitcase for purchases.

Fra_Diavolo May 22nd, 2018 09:30 AM

Well, let's empty my pockets and see . . .

Tissue (actually a folded paper towel)
Wallet (contains Metrocard, library card, museum memberships etc)
Cash (usually around $200)
Keys
Phone
Reading glasses

In jacket pocket -- Barbour rain hat.

Yet, I survive . . .

sf7307 May 22nd, 2018 09:36 AM

Fra, I survive with much less than that! Most often, I walk out the door with just my phone, which has a slot for a credit card, my license and a $5.00 bill. I leave the door to my apartment unlocked, and I can get in the front door via my phone.

WhereAreWe May 22nd, 2018 12:29 PM


Originally Posted by dfrostnh (Post 16733845)
well, obviously you never worried about whether the big turkey would fit in your oven.

You are correct. I have never worried about fitting a big turkey in my oven when I'm on vacation in NYC.

suze May 22nd, 2018 12:31 PM

That list is dumb.

For a day walking around NYC, I would carry my usual pocketbook which does have things like kleenex, small makeup kit, etc. I might throw in a travel umbrella if rain was forecast. Or bandaids if I didn't trust my shoes. And a few anticeptic wipes in individual packets are always a good idea when traveling.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 12:38 AM.