NYC Amazing Pizza in Theater District?
 

We will be going to see '12th Night' next month to celebrate a birthday... a group of 7 adults.

Birthday boy wants pizza... but need a place where we can sit down. Any suggestions for great pizza in the theater district, or an easy subway ride away?

John's Pizzeria
260 West 44th St

Try John's Pizza... fits your location-yummy pizza-seating requirements. Nice atmosphere and very reasonable for NYC!

http://www.johnspizzerianyc.com/

http://www.tripadvisor.com/Restauran..._New_York.html

Don Antonio's has an excellent reputation.

http://donantoniopizza.com/

I'm going next week so can give a first hand opinion then!

fantastic... i checked out john's and it looks like a great space... and t.a. gives it really good reviews... we will plan for john's. (well.. unless the upcoming report on don antonio's is just too tempting )

thanks much for this, and saved me lots of time and fretting.

thanks for the john's pizzeria recommendation... we did, indeed, go there and it was perfect. had a really big booth and the pizza was good... and the bianca-type pizza was memorable. i also liked that they served some very good salads family style... with the spinach being better than most. the price was really good for such a lovely room... all in, it was a perfect fit for the occasion. thanks much fodorites!

How did you enjoy Twelfth Night?

kind of you to ask, neopatrick... twelfth night.. oh my... it was a wonder! the best shakespeare production i think i've ever seen... and can't imagine it with female actors, because the cast was just perfect! it was just a great evening... and ended with snowy walk and a gathering for cake (from amys) at our hotel. love new york!!

Didn't you want to lift up Mark Rylance's skirt and see if he was really on wheels?

neo... omg... you are so right!!!