I like fuerza bruta.
http://fuerzabrutanyc.com/press.html

Sorry if this is too late, Jen. Two shows that we loved in NY are Steve Cohens Chamber Magic. It was AMAZING and I got to help with one trick. Still can't figure it out. The other is Celebrity Autobiography. Hysterical!

http://www.chambermagic.com/

http://www.celebrityautobiography.com/index.php

Thanks, TC! Our schedule is pretty dang full for this weekend (and our bank accounts are not :) ), but I'll come back to this thread for suggestions if there's another trip in the near future. I'm definitely discovering that there's way more to do and see than we'll have time for!