New York City 4-Star Hotel Suggestions Needed
 

Looking for a "close to it all" hotel (theater district / shopping) that is relatively reasonable. Mother / daughter traveling in early or mid November. Any hidden gems out there? Any suggestions are greatly appreciated!

>>that is relatively reasonable. << means almost nothing. What is your actual budget?

While I wouldn't call it a gem, the Shoreham is well located for Fifth ave. shopping and walkable to the theater. It's in need of renovation but run by Affinia who manage a good hotel. The Park Central which has been a dump for many years is newly renovated and well located. The Hilton Garden Inn Times Square and west 35 st are only 3* but in many ways nicer than the 4*s. if you can share one bed, the St. Giles Court is often a secret sale on quikbook.com (works like Hotwire). It will say Murray Hil delixe 4*.

You are coming at the busiest, most expensive time of year and want a hotel in the most expensive location.

Precisely how much are you willing to spend per night and can you share one double bed (or do you need two beds, which would be an upgraded, more expensive room).

Based on many, many other posters who had similar questions, I'm guessing that "relatively reasonable" means about $200 per night to the traveler. Including taxes...

Anybody want to take over or under?

I've given up trying to guess.

Some have realistic expectations - but there are also those who think $100 will cover a room any where/any time.

The Beacon Hotel is wonderful and reasonably priced. But not about $200. Prices in NYC are probably cheaper in early November than closer to Thanksgiving.

What is reasonable? I often stay in the Times Square area as I mainly go to NY for theater, and last time I stayed in the Hotel at Times Square (I think that's its name, on 46th St, owned by Apple Core). That used to be a Quality Inn as I recall, I stayed there then, also. It's fine and it reasonably priced. I was just checking its rates for someone else looking for a triple in November, and you can get a 2 rm suite there for only $300, so I'm sure doubles are reasonable. This is an excellent location, only a block or two from a subway stop, near the theaters and some good restaurants. Their doubles are only about $210-240 the third week in November, if available.

I have no idea if it is a 4* hotel, let's be reasonable, it is perfectly comfortable and decent.

Why not try Priceline.

oh FYI http://applecorehotels.com/apple-core-hotels/

I've also gotten good deals at the Novotel a bit north of there, around Thanksgiving, but right now their rooms seem to be more around $300 a night in November. I paid more like $200 which was a good deal a couple years ago. They are probably a 4*.

Without input from the OP there is really very little we can do.

Does she have $250 or spend? Or $400?

Does she have to have a 4" hotel (those aren't, although they may be fine)?

What amenities does she have to have?

And what are her exact dates? (If it's the same time as the marathon she is up the proverbial creek!)

http://new-york.hotelscheap.org/

I used them for my trip last year and didn't have any problems. They have cheaper rates than Expedia or Ebookers, but the problem with NYC is that it's just really, really expensive. I'm not sure if you'll find something in the center for that price, but you can always try.

>>I'm not sure if you'll find something in the center for that price, but you can always try.<<

What price? The OP hasn't told us her budget.

The only problem with that web site is that the cheapest hotels are either places you wouldn't stay (used by prostitutes or unstable/unsavory people) or out by the airports or other long distances from Manhattan.

And for someone who doesn't know the city - she could end up in an unpleasant, not to say unsafe, place.

Probably the cheapest decent hotel in Manhattan is the Jane - and the "reasonable" rooms are minute and have shared baths.