Maui vs Nevis, please share your thoughts! Would u chose Nevis or Maui?
 

Currently we have 2 seats reserved to Maui from September 24 to 30. Thinking of Kea Lani or Ritz to stay. And than I read reviews about Nevis FS and can't decide. We want nice beach (it doesn't have to be anguill type beach), gourmet food, nice room, good service, peaceful, not too crowded and beautiful sceneary. Thank you.

Maui hands down. You won't regrett it!!

We just returned from Maui. Would go again in a heartbeat.

I've been to both and have to agree with the others, I prefer Maui. It's prettier. There are more things to do and the beaches in Nevis are just OK.

I've been to Maui, had a great time, but too commercial for me tastes. That being said, since you're traveling in the height of hurricane season, I'd go to Maui. I'm planning a trip to Nevis for January.