Kelley House in Martha's Vineyard?
 

Anyone familiar with the Kelley House and how it compares with its sister inn, the Harbor View? Any other suggestions for Edgartown accomodations?

Anyone?

what time of year are you visiting?
i have stayed at the Harbor View, but only real off season (as in February!!). i did like this hotel. haven't stayed at Kelley House, but i would recommend Harbor View. rooms are comfortable..the dining room is very good. great location: you can walk all over Edgartown.

We're planning mid-May. We'd consider a good B&B, if there is one that is conveniently located with great views.

people seem to love the Charlotte Inn....the Hob Knob Inn looks nice too, but both are right in Edgartown and do not have particularly outstanding views. but i would check out their websites.
i would still say go for the Harbor View!