Go Back  Fodor's Travel Talk Forums > Destinations > United States
Reload this Page >

Hawaii, the Big Island June 2011: lots of hotel detail

Hawaii, the Big Island June 2011: lots of hotel detail

Jul 17th, 2011, 07:56 PM
Original Poster
Join Date: Nov 2007
Posts: 1,011
Hawaii, the Big Island June 2011: lots of hotel detail

We spent a wonderful nine days on the Big Island following a modification of an itinerary suggested by Frommer's: two nights at the Four Seasons Hualalai, three nights at Nohea Cottage in Volcano near Volcano National Park, and four nights at the Mauna Kea Beach Hotel. Any less would have been too short, with unlimited time and money we would have taken two weeks, adding at least one night at each place we stayed and perhaps two in a cottage near the Waipi'o Valley or splitting the final two days between the Four Seasons and the Mauna Kea. I should note we usually opt for two week vacations where we stay in two places one week each; we are not big fans of moving around . Because the Big Island is so big and seeing things would take so much driving time, I highly recommend Frommer's three stop approach. Also, we truly loved each place we stayed, each very different from each other.
Our first stop was at the Four Seasons, just 20 minutes from the Kona airport. We arrived on Saturday noon and didn't leave the property until we checked out at lunchtime on Monday. Our experience with the hotel's outstanding service began with my phone call asking for a rose to be placed in our room in honor of my husband's birthday when we arrived. The concierge was lovely, wrote a note for him in Italian, and when we arrived some weeks we found we had been upgraded to a prime oceanview room. Staff was unobtrusively gracious throughout our stay--the beach staff in particular were wonderful.
Our room was large, with beautiful slate floors, a luxurious bathroom and a spacious lanai. Both in the room and everywhere else in the Four Seasons, we were struck by how beautiful and also extremely comfortable the furniture was. Although the ocean was not swimmable (one big negative), the swimming pools were gorgeous, including a 28 meter lap pool with a blue tile bottom which is the most beautiful pool I have ever swum in. There is also a salt water pond where you can snorkel. Sunscreen and leave-in hair conditioner are by each pool, as is cold water and cool wet washcloths to refresh you.
There is also a beautiful walk along the sea, which is spectacular and fairly long.
Our very best experience here was a morning we spent on the beach reading and watching the ocean in comfortable lounge furniture that has a kind of hood to shade you if you want it. Staff brought us virgin lava flows and mahi mahi tacos (which were the best food we had on the island) in bento boxes for lunch. The word "paradise" did come to mind. The Four Seasons is very expensive, but worth it and I think the bottom category golf/ocean view rooms would also be fine.
After lunch on Monday, we headed south, stopping for an excellent at the very simple Coffee Shack in Captain Cook, which has a fantastic view over the valley out to the ocean. It had excellent salad, great homemade carrot cake and perhaps the best coffee I have had ever. In retrospect we would have gone with burgers or fish instead of pizza, but the place and the rest of the food was great. After lunch we continued south, stopping at the impressive Place of Refuge (note: VERY hot in afternoon) and the beautiful Punalu'u Black Sand Beach on our way to Volcano and Nohea cottage.
This beautiful tranquil cottage in the midst of a rainforest reminded me of William Yeat's famous poem, "I will arise and go now and go to Innisfree, and a small cabin build there with bee and wattles made...' The cabin was small as a house, but spacious as a cottage, incredibly peaceful and romantic. The intricate craftsman wood and open space of the cottage was filled with built in window seats in the living room and bedroom, french doors opened everywhere to the rain forest that surrounds the cottage. Three walls in the bedroom are window, a hob room opens to a covered lanai to sit or picnic. There is a wood heating stove, an entertainment area and a gourmet kitchen. I am so SAD this cottage is not in California. We went because it was near the park; if it was close, we would return yearly just to be there. Very reasonably priced for the luxury. The owner Kathryn was also very helpful, even let us do our laundry during our three night stay there.
Volcano Park itself was magnificent and eerie even though the lack of fresh flowing lava was the major disappointment of our vacation. We spent one day driving first on Kilauea Crater Drive, then on the Chain of Craters road to the sea. On both drives, there are several half mile to mile long walks; we highly recommend all of them. During our time in the park, we relied heavily on Andrew Doughty's Hawaii The Big Island Revealed (It along with Fodor's, the Rough Guide and Frommer's were helpful throughout the trip. I have never regretted my penchant for buying multiple guidebooks). On the Chain of Craters road drive, the walk on the lunar like lava was particularly spectacular. There is a viewpoint with picnic tables where you can lunch on the way.
On our second day in Volcano National Park, we again followed Doughty's advice and took a beautiful morning hike through rain forest and across a crater before ascending again to our parking place ( the Kilauea Iki trail (a little over 3 miles--moderate). After spending the afternoon at our cottage lunching on the covered lanai facing the rain forest and enjoying the hot tub, eating very good Thai takeout food for dinner,we returned to the park at night to see a spectacular array of stars, the first time either of us had seen the Southern Cross as well as the red glow of Caldera volcano against the black night sky.
We left regretfully on Thursday morning, drove to the Rainbow Falls in Hilo, crowded and not worth it,then continued on to the Hawaii Tropical Botanical Gardens, which were breathtaking. This incredibly beautiful nature preserve was filled with flowers, ponds, waterfall and birds; it is well worth the price of admission. Allow yourself two hours. We drove on, stopping at the Woodshop Gallery Cafe (my husband had an excellent ahi burger) on our way to Akaka falls, where we took an enjoyable 15 minute loop walk through rain forest to see the two falls there. The natural beauty was a nice contrast to the humanly designed beauty of the Botanical Gardens (if you have to pick one, go for the manmade grandeur of the gardens). We drove on to the Waip'o Valley overlook and finished the day getting lost taking 190 instead 19 at Waimea. Our mistake cost us an hour and a half but the road was beautiful and we were rewarded with a perfect rainbow. We arrived at the Mauna Kea beach hotel tired and had dinner on the lanai in our room watching the sunset.
We chose the Mauna Kea to spend our final four nights on the Big Island of Hawaii partly because of its beach and location, partly on the recommendation of two friends whose judgment we trust a lot . I had some concerns about it because internet photos made the hotel look too massive to me and perhaps too much like an expensive version of a Best Western (we like Best Westerns). However, my reservations melted away within 20 minutes of arriving. Up close the architecture of the hotel is spectacular, again and again bringing pleasure with curves and angles. It is filled with museum class art of Asia and the Oceania collected by Lawrence Rockefeller and the view and sounds of the ocean took my breath away each time we entered our room. The interplay of art, architecture and nature reminded me of two of my favorite museums in the world, the Miho in Japan and the Museo of the Dogana in Venice. It is very special. I see why people return to the Mauna Kea again and again; I will be sad if we never go back. It is a hotel which could win a special place in one's heart.
Our room was much nicer than I thought it would be from the Internet, though not as luxurious as the Four Seasons. It was lovely, with beautiful wood, tile floors, a very comfortable bed and excellent decor. The fact that it was possible to cover up the flat screen TV facing the bed was a very nice touch. Bathroom was just ordinary but fine; toiletries were great and the shower head was fantastic. The service was very good, the activities program excellent and the beach was both beautiful and wonderful for swimming. There was a much appreciated excellent complimentary bottle of champagne in our room when we arrived, in honor of my husband's birthday.There were only two significant downsides to the hotel, one easily remedied. The swimming pool is old, small and disappointing. The table on the lanai (where we spent many magical hours) is too high to be comfortable for room service. We had to sit on ottomans that were too low and meals were somewhat uncomfortable. We recommend replacing either the table or the chair and ottoman so they work better together.
I looked at the mountain view rooms and would highly recommend paying the extra $200 a night for an ocean view. Rooms are identical, but mountain view rooms overlook golf course, the lanais are hot and without a sea breeze, you cannot hear the ocean or see the sunset. The ocean view experience is truly special and I am a mountain person not an ocean person.
At the Mauna Kea, like with the Four Seasons, with the exception of a half day sailing snorkeling trip arranged through the hotel's activity program, we never left the property, alternating swimming with sitting on the lanai talking and reading or walking through the hotel looking at the museum quality art. This vacation came after a difficult year and we don't regret at all so often having opted for what the Italians call "il piacere di fare niente" (the pleasure of doing nothing). However, we do have a sizable to do list for our next trip: snorkeling and dolphin watching in Kealakua Bay, the Green Beach, more time in the lush tropical eastern part of the island, hiking and star gazing on Mauna Kea. I am quite sure we will return, though the beauties of the smaller Kawaii are a touch dearer to our hearts.
A special aloha and mahalo to Hawaiian Traveler of this forum who first recommended the Four Seasons and to award from my husband's company's very able travel agent Leslie Borghetti of Custom Travel in Massachusetts (her business). Leslie was able to find us a package of flight, rental car, the Four Seasons, cottage in Volcano and the Mauna Kea which was $2000 less than I had priced out individually with the two major hotels; she found us Nohea Cottage at Volcano Places. We highly recommend her. Lesl
cmstraf is offline  
Jul 17th, 2011, 08:42 PM
Join Date: May 2004
Posts: 6,343
cmstraf, I am so glad that everything worked out for you at the FS. It is a little slice of heaven on earth. Hope you two get to make it back some day soon!

hawaiiantraveler is offline  
Jul 17th, 2011, 09:55 PM
Join Date: May 2003
Posts: 1,630
ah the mauna kea vs four seasons question. stayed 10 years in a row @ the mauna kea in the same room each time: ocean view on the 7th floor. the year after the earthquake closed the hotel we shifted to the hapuna prince : that's where the big pool is at the resort. actually enjoyed the beach @ the hapuna more than @ the mauna kea as one could walk over to the state beach park as well.

as an architect i love the mauna kea and started staying there on the advice of my golfing parents. for my ex and i it was a veg on the beach vacation. when we first started staying in the early 90's many of the staff were original employees and the service was/ is exquisite and personal.

a few years after our run @ the mauna kea began, the four seasons opened. one of the mauna kea managers who moved there invited us for a tour and lunch. i was underwhelmed. yes the bathrooms are big ( but how much time can i spend in one in hawai'i??). the layout reminded me of a suburban garden apartment complex and there appeared to b little privacy on the small lanai's. hawai'i w/ o a beach ? i just do not get. the mauna kea and the hapuna r the only hotels w/ beaches on the kohala coast. i just can't imagine staying anywhere else!

has the volcano finally stopped oozing? i thought it would last forever. we were fortunate to see lava flow day and night while we were there.

i love the sunday buffet @ the mauna kea. i would go in @ 11am and eat until 1:30 slowly and very thoroughly

thanks for the report

AndrewDavid is offline  
Jul 18th, 2011, 06:56 AM
Original Poster
Join Date: Nov 2007
Posts: 1,011
Hi Andrew,
The lava has not run out--there was a huge fissure in March which was spectacular, but it means that the lava has to build up again. I agree about the suburban garden outer aspect of the Four Seasons, but our room (as well as bathroom) was truly spectacular, with a large sitting area with couch and incredibly comfortable furniture. The dinners were fine but not outstanding, but we loved the dining area. And the mahi mahi tacos...And the beach. Try it sometime to see what you think. A tour would not do it justice.

The architecture, art and ocean views of the Mauna Kea still have me sighing. It was truly a wonderful experience. We walked to the Hapuna Beach hotel and saw a couple of rooms and were underwhelmed. Perhaps there too you need to stay there before really knowing.

cmstraf is offline  
Jul 18th, 2011, 09:02 AM
Join Date: May 2003
Posts: 1,630
The architecture of the hapuna and its rooms is underwhelming. it was originally built for the japanese mass tourism market which was collapsing as the hotel was opening. the main design criteria was that every room have a view of the ocean. that's why its such hike to some rooms.

unfair though to compare to the mauna kea which is a mid century century masterpiece designed by skidmore owing and merrill's san francisco office and has the benefit of a dramatic site and the rockefeller art, including that stunning buddha in its own staircased buddha hall.

glad u got to experience both!
AndrewDavid is offline  
Jul 18th, 2011, 04:10 PM
Join Date: Jul 2006
Posts: 13,810
I laughed at the mention of the Frommer's, but it made your trip pleasant, and a nice old school detailed report. Thanks!
jetset1 is offline  
Jul 18th, 2011, 09:29 PM
Original Poster
Join Date: Nov 2007
Posts: 1,011
Yes, the buddha was incredible.

And yes, I hesitated to mention Frommer's on this site, but I tend to be a nondenominational guidebook purchasing, doing my best to keep the industry going. I usually buy both Fodor's and Frommers, Rough Guide, Rick Steves if we are going to Europe, also Cadogan if we are going to Italy....I figure that just one good tip makes for a worthwhile purchase!
cmstraf is offline  
Jul 19th, 2011, 05:25 AM
Join Date: May 2005
Posts: 16,423
Sounds like a great time, cmfstraf!
(However, "The lava has not run out--there was a huge fissure in March which was spectacular, but it means that the lava has to build up again." is not at all correct, volcanologically speaking.)
sylvia3 is offline  
Jul 19th, 2011, 09:48 PM
Original Poster
Join Date: Nov 2007
Posts: 1,011
I believe you--science is not my strong point!
cmstraf is offline  
Jul 20th, 2011, 12:54 PM
Join Date: Mar 2003
Posts: 435
Enjoyed your trip report, which brought back memories of our week on the Big Island last December. We had a lovely dinner at the Four Seasons one evening. We, too, stayed at the Mauna Kea and cannot say enough good things about this resort. Paradise found.
Uma is offline  

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are On

Thread Tools
Search this Thread

Contact Us - Archive - Advertising - Cookie Policy -


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 12:16 AM.