Fodor's Travel Talk Forums

Fodor's Travel Talk Forums (https://www.fodors.com/community/)
-   United States (https://www.fodors.com/community/united-states/)
-   -   Grand Canyon in March? (https://www.fodors.com/community/united-states/grand-canyon-in-march-762197/)

joysakura Jan 18th, 2009 07:42 PM

Grand Canyon in March?
 
Hi Everybody
We are in the very early stages of planning a trip in March to the Grand Canyon. We know very little, haven't been before, have 14 & 18 year olds, & are thinking that we'd like to do some hiking, but don't have time to train for hiking all the way down between now & early March.

So, my questions:
1. Recommendations for some hiking/walking trails?
2. Recommendations re where to stay, what to do, & how long to stay?
3. Mule trip worthwhile or stay exploring on top?

Our kids are on spring break, so we could have anywhere up to 5 days.

Thanks very much.



amwosu Jan 18th, 2009 07:49 PM

Dress warmly, I have friends that went the first week of April and it snowed.


amwosu Jan 18th, 2009 07:58 PM

March
South Rim
avg hi 51 avg low 25

March
North Rim
avg hi 44 avg low 21

You can fly into Las Vegas or Phoenix so you might want to add a day or two at one of those cities as well.

joysakura Jan 18th, 2009 08:18 PM

good advice with weather & airports. I'll check both Phoenix & Las Vegas. Sounds like we'll bring plenty of warm clothes & layers.

we like activity & nature. i'll do some reading, too, & start getting an idea of what might be possible.

any other ideas are much appreciated.

thanks

NewPlaces Jan 19th, 2009 10:04 AM

North Rim is closed until mid-May

enzian Jan 19th, 2009 10:07 AM

Hello--will this be late March? we have visited the Grand Canyon twice in early April, perhpas 10 days or 2 weeks later than your visit. The weather was perfect for hiking----mostly in the 60's during the day, although on our last day the temperature dropped and it snowed. (that was actually abonus, because the canyon was so beautiful in the snow).

Evening and mornings were very cold---we bundled up in warm jacket, hat and gloves each morning to go out and enjoy the sunrise.

You'll need to get your lodging reservations right away-----they do book up early. The best choice, by far, is to stay inside the national park at the South Rim. There are six different lodges, four of which are just steps away from the rim, some with canyon view rooms. The four right on th erim are El Tovar (the old, historic hotel), Thunderbird and Kachina (more modern and concrete-looking) and Bright Angel (another historic lodge, with cabins). Two lodges back from the rim (1/4 to 1/4 mile) are Maswik and Yavapai.

all of these can be booked through Xanterra at www.grandcanyonlodges.com

If nothing shows up on the website, give them a call. When people book rooms ahead and cancel, those rooms often don't get put back on the website.

The problem you will have is finding a room to accomodate all 4 of you, as none of the rooms have 3 beds. You can put a rollaway bed into some of the rooms with two queen beds at Maswik and Yavapai, and the deluxe rooms at El Tovar, but not into any of the rooms at Kachina or Thunderbird. The Bright Angel cabins, with a rollaway added, can accomodate three, maximum, but you could book a separate single room for the 18-year old.

The Thunderbird and Kachina rooms do allow four psople in the room, so if the kids are willing to share a bed (or if one of them can sleep on the floor), that would work too.

Hiking: there is a trail right along the rim for some distance both east and west of the hotel area. The area to the west (Hermit Road) is also served by a free shuttle, so you can walk partway and then hop on the shuttle.

Walking the rim in both directions is a good way to spend your first day at the canyon, getting a sense of the place and getting used to the altitude.

To hike partway down into the canyon, you coul dtake either of the two main trail. The Bright Angel trail leaves from the lodge area, and has lots of mule traffic. You can walk down as far as you like and then turn around. If you are not experienced hikers, a mile or two would be plenty; don't try to reach Indian Garden (the broad flat area you can see from the rim)

South Kaibab trail is reached by a shuttle bus, and is less traveled by mules, although you may stil encounter a mule train or three. This trail is a bit steeper but offers great views. Most dayhikers go as far as Cedar Ridge, 1.5 miles down the trail, before turning around.

Mule rides: they only offer two kinds at the South Rim---the 6-hour ride down to Plateau Point and back, and the overnight trip to Phantom Ranch. Here is the webpage with information and prices:

http://www.grandcanyonlodges.com/mule-trips-716.html

IF you are able to get reservations for the overnight trip to Phantom Ranch, it is a fantastic way to experience the canyon. It is quite expensive , unfortunately---it would be more than $1000 for the 4 of you. That does include your lodging and all your meals, however.

As for airpoprt choices---we prefer the drive from Phoenix (possibly stopping at Sedona for hiking there too). However, the car rentals are usually much less from Las Vegas (like half), and a stop at Hoover dam is interesting too. I suggest you check airfare and car rental prices before you decide.

joysakura Jan 19th, 2009 11:11 AM


Thanks so much for your help. How many days do you recommend? Is there plenty to do for 4 days without doing the mule ride? Even though it would cost a lot for 4 of us, we're going to consider it since it sounds quite amazing. Do you suppose that our Grand Canyon experience would be as fabulous regardless of whether we went down to Phantom Ranch? We're tempted since it seems that it would be incredible to be down there.

If we didn't do the mule ride, do you have other recommendations or would 3+ days be enough?

Are the hikes on Bright Angel trail & South Kaibab trail both 1/2 day-type hikes?

We'll see if we can book Thunderbird & Kachina, www.grandcanyonlodges.com Our teenagers are girls & willing to share a bed, so those places would work if they have availability.

So, a possible itinerary would be:

Day 1: Hiking along trail right along the rim for both east and west of the hotel area. If needed when we walk on Hermit Rd to west, we can hop on free shuttle to return.

Day 2 & Day 3 Hike into the canyon on either:
1) Bright Angel trail (leaves from the lodge area & walk 1-2 miles & then turn around, not trying to reach Indian garden-the broad flat area we see from the rim), OR
2) South Kaibab trail (reached by a shuttle bus, less traveled by mules, trail is a bit steeper but offers great views) & go 1.5 miles down trail to Cedar Ridge, then turn around

OR
Day 2 & Day 3: Do Overnight Mule Trip to Phantom Ranch, http://www.grandcanyonlodges.com/mule-trips-716.html

Day 4: Do a hike if did the overnight mule trip. If didn't do the mule trip, other recommendations? Or, other places in the area to visit?

Will figure out flights once we get hotel reservation & check rental car rates. I wouldn't have thought to check on rental car rates--great suggestion.

Thank you so much for your incredible help. Appreciate all of your ideas, & any other thoughts any of you might have. Thanks!

Nora_S Jan 19th, 2009 11:49 AM

Yes---if your girls will share a queen-sized bed, then Thunderbird or kachina offer the best combination of good location and value. El Tovar is a little nicer but the rooms are considerably more expensive.

Four days is a lot of time to spend there unless you are spending a night at the bottom of the canyon.

If you are interested in the mule trip and able to get the reservations to do that and spend the night at Phantom Ranch, then that is one of the best possible ways to see the canyon. You go down and up on different trails (using the Bright Angel to descend and the South Kaibab to come up, I believe) so you see a lot of different places. And Pphantom Ranch is a very special place. (We like the food there too).

It may be very difficult to get reservations for the four of you at this point. While the mule trips aren't as heavily booked as the hikers' spots, they still are likely to be fully booked for March. But it's worth a call to Xanterra. They have a separate place on the phone menu for Phantom, and the people there are very helpful.

If you aren't able to get reservations for the mule trip down, what you might consider is a loop around the canyon, like this:

Fly into Las Vegas, pick up the car and drive to Grand Canyon, south rim (5 hours driving). spend 3 nights there. Depart Grand Canyon early in the morning head for Page for the "smoothwater" raft trip on the Colorado River:

http://www.coriverdiscovery.com/

Then depart Page at 10:30 am, and you return there around 4:30. Spend the night there.

From Page, head back west through Kanab and Mt. Carmel Junction and continue through Zion National park. You could spend one or better yet 2 nights there, either in the park lodge or in Springdale. Zion is at a much lower elevation than the Grand Canyon rim so it will be warmer. There is great hiking there too.

enzian Jan 19th, 2009 11:55 AM

Nora_S, you beat me to it!!

I have to agree that 4 days is a lot at the South Rim unless they are hiking down or staying a night at Phantom Ranch with the mule trip.

The loop suggestion is a good one if they have the time.

We went to Zion for the first time last September and loved the place. The hiking is mostly easier than the Grand Canyon, and it would be warmer there, even in March.

joysakura Jan 19th, 2009 06:29 PM

Nora & Enzian---Perfect suggestions.

I'll still call about the mule trip tomorrow & see if it's an option. My guess is that it's full, which saves us trying to figure out if it's worth the time & money.

If we do mule trip, 4 days will work; otherwise, without the mule trip, do you think 2 days at South Rim & 1 Day on the raft trip works well?

Loop trip is great idea.

Flat water raft trip on the Colorado much cheaper than mule trip, & we'd get to enjoy the gorgeous canyon via the raft trip. I'm presuming that the views & scenary are fabulous on the raft trip. Looked at the link & it looks great

Love the idea of Zion, too, & will mapquest distances.

love the idea of us seeing more of a variety of places since we haven't been before.

great suggestions. I'll start playing with a possible itinerary. Thanks.



enzian Jan 20th, 2009 09:30 AM

From Zion, it is only 2.5 hours back to Las Vegas, so with an afternoon flight you can spend your final night at Zion instead of Vegas if you like.

I usually recommend staying inside the national parks, but Zion is one exception. There is a lodge (Zion Lodge) inside the park, and it is nice, offering cabins and suites that would be perfect for the four of you. but this place in Springdale, at the park entrance, has wonderful ambiance:

http://www.desertpearl.com/

There are also some less expensive places in Springdale.

And in town you will have a variety of places to choose for dinner.

At Zion, unlike Grand Canyon, you are in the bottom of the canyon, often along the river. Picture a valley like Yosemite, but smaller, and with red rock walls---that is Zion.

The Narrows walk at the end of the canyon is a favorite:

http://www.zionadventures.com/hiking...5Fnarrows.html

In March, the water will be very cold, so you won't want to go too far. You can rent shoes and walking sticks (highly recommended) from Zion Adventure Company. They also rent drysuits for the cold water if you like, but I would just pick a warm afternoon and go for an hour or so. You are in and out of the water, often walking on the sandbars, not constantly in the river.

joysakura Jan 21st, 2009 03:26 PM

Wow, Totally wonderful suggestions about Zion, the river & "outfitting" for the river & the lovely place to stay. Thanks so much. I'm going to mapquest it all & figure out a possible itinerary & be back in touch. Thanks!

emalloy Jan 23rd, 2009 03:28 PM

Joysakura,

Don't be discouraged if you don't get a reservation right away. I've stayed on the South rim several times and have never made reservations more than 10 days in advance in April and February. Twice we just drove in and inquired and found rooms in el Tovar once and Yavapai once. If you fly in and out of Las Vegas you might find a package deal for the first and/or last night at one of the hotel/casinos. You also could stop at Hoover Dam on the way to the Canyon. It takes 6 to 8 hours from Vegas to the Canyon so a visit to the Dam is a nice break. If you do a couple of nights in Vegas, check out red rock park, valley of fire state park or head over to Death Valley, it is about 2 and a half hours away and I find it awesome. March weather can be iffy in the canyon. We once had snow in April but were just wearing light jackets in April. I check www.weather.com 10 day forecast and then plan my time for the Canyon and call for reservations, being flexible enough to do the trip there when the weather and reservations are good.

brighton Jan 29th, 2009 06:01 AM

We went to the Grand Canyon last April and were too late in planning to get a room in the park. We ended up staying at the Best Western right outside the park. Our room was huge and the kids loved the bowling alley and arcade in the hotel which provided a nice break from hiking.

joysakura Feb 4th, 2009 11:56 AM

what do you all think re whether to stay in the village or in an area 15 or so minutes away that could be $100. cheaper per night.

inside the park, for us, a family of 4, at thunderbird or kachina, cost 180 for 2 adults, plus 18 for kids plus tax per night. $210-220 range per night.

the cost could be half that in nearby tusayan in a 2 or 2 1/2 star place that i'm guessing is 15-20 minutes away.

we would eat in the park & spend all our time there; just wondering if it's worth it to stay in thunderbird or kachina.

have to be there for the sunrises & sunsets, of course!

thanks


emalloy Feb 4th, 2009 12:32 PM

Joysaka,

There is something special about getting up and walking out to see the Canyon first thing in the morning. If you need to worry about the budget, consider doing a day or two in the park and the rest outside. If you know where you are flying in to there are options of other places to see on the way to or from the park to think about, especially if wether is a factor.

enjoy

joysakura Feb 4th, 2009 05:42 PM

sort of my feeling, too. liked the idea of grabbing coffee & going out to the rim, views, & sunrise. Good suggestions re a few nights at the South Rim & a few nights other places.

have been looking at the map & reading travel books. thought we could swing up to zion as some of you suggested earlier, & also perhaps go to bryce.

what do you all think? 2 nights & 2 days at Grand Canyon, 2-3 nights at Zion & 2 nights (or just 1 night?) at Bryce.

if there's snow, we thought it would be fun to go snowshoeing, cross country skiing & maybe even downhill. looks like bryce has the first two & brian head is less than 2 hours from bryce.

of course, now we're doing a huge loop from Las Vegas to Grand Canyon (3 nights, 2 days) to Zion (3 nights, 3 days) to Bryce (2 nights, 2 days) to BrianHead (2 nights, 2 days). Just ran out of time---

let's see Thurs night, Fri night & Sat night--GC
Sun, Mon, Tues--Zion
Wed--Thur--Bryce
Fri--Sat skiing
Sun fly back

decided mule trip was too expensive & didn't even check into it. couldn't justify over $1,000.

i'm in the process of booking our flights. we could have anywhere from 8 to 10 days, depending on the flights. looks like we could really use 10 days.

right now looking at flying from the east coast on Thursday, March 5 in the evening & returning from Las Vegas on Sunday, March 15th.

does it sound like we're trying to do too much on our national park loop with GC, Zion, & Bryce, & then throwing in a bit of skiing?

Enzian's idea of Desert Pearl sounds lovely by Zion.

Ideas for Bryce?

do we need to rent a car with 4 wheel drive in case of snow & difficult driving in the mts?

should we pay a national park pass since we're going to so many? If so, i'm thinking we probably buy it at our first national park stop.

we'll take lots of winter clothes, hiking boots, & dress in layers.

thanks for all of your help.

emalloy Feb 5th, 2009 03:54 AM

Joysaka,

Get a park pass at your first park. It lets everyone in your car into all parks for free for a year. I'm sure once you start visiting NPs you will be hooked.

Every time I've been to Bryce there has been snow and the trails down below the rim have been closed. I don't know about snowshoeing at that time of year or if they have trails for that. The loop drive gives you a great view of the hoodoos and natural bridges etc. We also have stayed there in the motel in the park and had no trouble with reservations. I'm pretty sure Xanterra handles reservations for Bryce, Zion and Grand Canyon you can link to them at www.nps.gov but if you call directly you will get better luck with the cancellation situation. I would always opt to stay in the park if I could because I'm a morning person and love to see the park before everyone else is up, we had mule deer right outside our room at Zion and along the rim trail at Grand Canyon. They all have places for breakfast that open reasonably early. The rooms are basic but clean (except for el Tovar) and have everything you need and cost about the same as motels outside the park. If your kids need pools, spa, game rooms,etc. then opt for out of the park. There also is a ton of information about the parks at the nps site which will let you know about trails, ranger programs, weather, directions,etc. Hope you have a great trip.



joysakura Feb 5th, 2009 04:31 AM

thanks very much. sounds like staying in the parks is what we all would prefer---we'll be up early anyhow since we're on east coast time, & it would be quite lovely to see wildlife first thing in the morning. basic is fine.

do you all think we need a 4 wheel drive? i was particularly thinking about the roads within Bryce & Zion, and up in the mountains by Brian Head.

will the weather likely be warmer at zion (than bryce) & will zion likely have less snow, more trails open, etc?

is 1 day & 2 nights enough at Bryce? we'd start at the visitor center, probably spend 1-2 hrs enjoying the 18 mile park road, spend a little time at Inspiration Point, & if open hike on either the Queen's Garden Trail or Navaho Trail (3 hrs). if the trails are closed, we can rent showshoe or skis, & do trails around the rim area.

3 nights, 2+ days at Zion about right? Or, 3 full days?
zion---drive the zion canyon scenic drive, stopping & seeing rock formations--see temple of sinawava & walk on 2 mile roundtrip Riverwalk, etc

thanks so much for all of your help


emalloy Feb 5th, 2009 05:07 AM

If you can do the activities in Bryce your time there will be fine, if not 1 night and a day and a half will be plenty. Zion will be much warmer, you will be down in the canyon mostly, in March light jacket would be all that you will need. I don't know about conditions at Brian's, haven't been there. A regular car can handle both Bryce and Zion, but we've always had a 6 cylinder to handle the uphills between places. If you are going in and out of Vegas, on the way from Zion down is less than 3 hrs., check out Valley of Fire State park, it's off I 15 about 2/3 of the way down and has interesting rock, some old CCC cabins, hiking trails, one that goes to "Mouse's tank" has loads of petroglyphs all along the path. If you go through you can drive along Lake Meade and hit Hoover Dam if you haven't done that on the way to the Canyon.

joysakura Feb 5th, 2009 08:15 AM

Thanks. Now that we've added a couple of days of skiing, I'm wondering about where to begin the trip & whether there's any wisdom in starting at one place or another.

What do you think of this possible itinerary:

Thurs-fly into Las Vegas & drive to Brian Head (3 hrs)
Fri & Sat-ski at Brian Head

Sat late afternoon--drive & eat dinner near Bryce (2 hrs)
Sat night & Sunday night--Bryce
Sunday--explore Bryce

Monday morning--drive to Zion (2 hrs)
Monday & Tues night & Wed nights--stay at Zion
Monday & Tues & Wed day--explore Zion

Thurs a.m.--drive to Grand Canyon (5 hrs?)
Thurs afternoon & Friday all day--explore GC
thurs & Friday nights--stay at GC lodge
Sat--drive back to Las Vegas

With the above possible itinerary, would it be best to go to Valley of Fire State park when we first arrive OR on our way back to Las Vegas

Mapquest recommends going back to Las Vegas from the Grand Canyon via the southern route---is that what you all would recommend?

If we went back to LV the southern route, then Valley of Fire could be put into our first day instead of our last day.

I haven't booked our flights yet so we can fly back on Sat or Sunday. once again, thanks very much!

joysakura Feb 5th, 2009 08:18 AM

p.s. Forgot to ask about the raft trip from Page & your recommendations about including spending a day doing this. i was figuring that we'd be seeing a lot of beautiful canyons at zion, bryce & grand canyon, & it would be lovely, but also somewhat similar to what we had seen. do you all think that makes sense. thanks!

emalloy Feb 5th, 2009 08:59 AM

The trip we took on the Colorado River from Page was from the Glen Canyon Dam to Lees Ferry. It was just a morning ride and involved no rapids at all. Our guide was great and the views were wonderful. We stopped at a beach where there were petroglyphs on a ledge and also a bathroom. Antelope canyon is also right near Page. It is a slot canyon that is on Navajo land. You go to their parking lot and I think it was about $20 per person for a ride on their truck up a wash and then about an hour in the canyon. If you google it I'm sure you can find pictures that are awesome and that will give you an idea if you want to take an hour and a half to see a spectacular small canyon.

joysakura Feb 5th, 2009 09:39 AM

thanks for the reminder about antelope valley---great idea. so, we'll stop in page & enjoy antelope valley, & support the navaho reservation while we're at it.

so, we'll return to LV via the northern route.

depending on the weather, we'll decide about rafting when we're there.

thanks again

emalloy Feb 5th, 2009 10:39 AM

I forgot to include the information on the rafting. Go to www.raftthecanyon.com I think not sure if its one t or two.

MFNYC Feb 5th, 2009 12:22 PM

We were there in March several yaers ago. They were having a snow storm the day we arrived. I'd say about 5" total. The next day was sunny and chilly. You could only hike if you had special spiked hiking boots for the ice along the trail.

We (also family of 4) stayed in the Kachina. It was the only available room on the rim. Bright Angel and El Tovar are just a few steps away. There's also a shuttle that runs along the rim and stops at each scenic point.

joysakura Feb 5th, 2009 12:39 PM

if the upper trails are icy, we don't have the appropriate spiked boots (or skills) for the Grand Canyon trails with ice.

is there plenty of wondering around on the rim for 1 1/2 or so days?

plenty of places to wonder around on the rim?

thanks for the rafting link, too!

WhereAreWe Feb 5th, 2009 12:49 PM

The General Store in Market Plaza should still rent crampons (a/k/a special spiked hiking boots) - actually, they strap onto the bottom of your boots. Hiking poles would be helpful too. I believe the crampons are pretty cheap, like $5 a day or so.

Call 'em to check: 928-638-2262

joysakura Feb 5th, 2009 01:35 PM

perfect solution. is that general store in grand canyon village?

WhereAreWe Feb 5th, 2009 01:59 PM

It's over by Yavapai, not right in the midst of the main village.

http://www.nps.gov/grca/planyourvisi...illage_map.pdf

joysakura Feb 5th, 2009 03:04 PM

thanks

very helpful & a great solution

joysakura Feb 6th, 2009 02:56 PM

love the idea of antelope valley & looked into it today.
looks like we can do EITHER upper or lower valley in various tours posted on the navaho park site.

recommendations re upper vs. lower?

pics are gorgeous--looks definitely worthwhile

thanks

emalloy Feb 6th, 2009 03:15 PM

Do the upper. Just drive out there and deal with the Navajos . There are outfitters in Page but they only can take you to the parking lot and the Navajos will drive you the rest of the way in. Bring a camera and although they say that it is best at noon, we were there in the afternoon and it was great, got fantastic pics, and it was much less crowded than earlier according to our guide. We just had one other couple in our group.

joysakura Feb 6th, 2009 05:26 PM

sounds good. maybe allow about 2 hrs?

i was WAY amazed by the beauty--it'll be great to see.

thanks for the idea.

trying to decide now about the river rafting---it'd be $250 or so i think for 4 people. happy to include it if you think it'd be more gorgeous views or nice scenery that would be really nice to "raft" by :)

thanks again

emalloy Feb 7th, 2009 04:21 AM

The group we went on the raft ride trip was good and it was fun to go down through the tunnel that was used when they built Glen Canyon Dam. We did the half day trip in the morning and then went to Antelope Canyon after lunch on our way out of the area. If your kids are looking for white water they'll be disappointed but you get a bit of a feel for going in the calm parts of the canyon and it was beautiful, only you can make the decision as to if it will be worth the expense and time. Check the web page to give you a better idea on that.

joysakura Feb 7th, 2009 07:21 PM

I believe our interest (at least my interest) would be more on the scenery & gorgeous beauty surrounding us & on a bit of history from the guide.

the page az calm water rapids website that was referred to has a trip from 11 to 4 or something like that (maybe arrive 10:30 a.m & leave at 11 a.m.). i'll check again & see if I can find a morning one since it would be perfect to do 1/2 day rafting, 1/2 day antelope valley

thanks

proudmommamb Dec 10th, 2013 10:01 AM

We are planning a trip hike the Canyon in March, 2014. I've tried to do all of the necessary research and preparation. I am wondering how your trip went. How was the weather? What activities did you decide to do? Where did you end-up staying? Thanks


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 02:15 PM.