Right you are Suzanne. It's Totonno's (not the first time I've made that mistake!) and is on 2nd Ave between 80th and 81st.

Thanks for sharing your favorites with us. Only problem which one do we try first ;-)

Topping for Mom_of_5

The restaurant scene in NYC changes rapidly, especially in an evolving neighborhood like Hell's Kitchen (excuse me, Clinton). Much of the info in an 18-month-old post is sure to be obsolete.